Comparison of SidNi situation

One thing that is troubling me today is can we really compare the situation of Roshni (today) with Sid's (6 months ago)??
Past:
At that time Simran did the deeds
Sid was unaware about it.
Roshni assumed sid was with his mother.
Did not trust Sid. why? because he did lie about his identity and continued with the relationship.
there was literally no proof of sid being unaware and innocent about the property issue , only his words.
patels were badly insulted.
sId arrived when the patels were already thrown out and in a new home.

Present:
Dd did the deeds.
Roshni was unaware about it.
At the house, Sid said out loud, why did u do this roshni? and it made it look like he didn't trust her until he got the news dd filed the conplaint. so why did he trust her? coz there were evidences right in front of him.
Roshni did not lie or do anything bad. instead was trying hard to win beejis heart
khuranas were insulted.
Roshni reached on time at the police station before they went inside the jail. took the conplaint back. supported the family. made that woman shut up.

so my point is that both the situations were different and I think sid's comparison to an extent was not justified. it just pointed out that what roshni did 6 months ago, her reaction was wrong and she doesnt love him(trust him). who would have at that time?

lol.. I don't know if it made sense or not.

Excellent comparison dr...👏⭐️ Actually ur post cleared my doubt, so b4 knowing DD is complaint against them he mu roshni that she may be did it intentionally... They both are loving each other unconditionally there is no doubt in that but doesn't completely trusting each other...😕

Originally posted by: rachana10

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Excellent comparison dr...👏⭐️Actually ur post cleared my doubt, so b4 knowing DD is complaint against them he mu roshni that she may be did it intentionally... They both are loving each other unconditionally there is no doubt in that but doesn't completely trusting each other...😕</font>

Yes they love each other a lot, but trust :-/
after their patchup all this mistrust will also go away..

No, I don't think the comparison was completely out of place. And the situations were also somewhat similar. It would have been apt if he told about MMS issue. That was more like someone else did and Roshni came and accused Sid in front of everyone😕

And when Sid and family was arrested, what Sid was his initial reaction to what police said that Roshni complained against them. He told he can't believe Roshni did it and we can't say he mistrusted her just by that dialogue. It was just to mislead audience. Even if they came out of the jail w/o Roshni's help and didn't know it was DD who did it, I don't think Sid would have accused her w/o hearing her side of story. If Sid's trust was weak as Roshni, he could have accused her of having planned it with DD to take revenge on them, like Simran said😕

And before 6months Roshni didn't believe him b'coz of his lie but she never wanted to hear his side of story or gave him a benefit of doubt, and accused him for using her to get her property ( which is somewhat justified considering her situation)😕 But the Nani attack accusations and MMS one really showed Roshni's immaturity and I think he should have talked about that too.

So, even though situations were slightly different what Sid was trying to convey was apt and Roshni understood it.

@zoo - that is what I was trying to say that instead of comparing what happened 6 months ago, he should have compared with the mms issues..
There are some similarities, but the intensity of the situations were different..

Originally posted by: rachana10

Excellent comparison dr...👏⭐️ Actually ur post cleared my doubt, so b4 knowing DD is complaint against them he mu roshni that she may be did it intentionally... They both are loving each other unconditionally there is no doubt in that but doesn't completely trusting each other...😕