Book 5 - My worst so far

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Shooting_Star

@Shooting_Star

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#21

Book 5 isn't my favorite but I didn't hate it I liked how she finally put Harry's anger and hurt in there, it would have been fake if he went through is whole life and never cracked.

Quote

mistystar

@mistystar

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#22

Book 5 was very dull for the first few chapters for me...but once they got back to school, it got alot better...but i got rather annoyed by harry's constant temper...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sumant

@sumant

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#23

What i disliked abt book 5 was that Harry was too overboard in his behaviour... 😔 Almost shouting at every point of time..
Also the death of SIRIUS.. 😭 😭
Umbridge b'coming Headmistress
Harry banned from Quidditch 😒
It was not a very gud time reading that book... 🤢 🤢

Quote

Nishani Haripersadh

@Nishani

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#24

I have re-read Book 5 again a few days back and I must say I take some of my words back. Sure enough, it does have a lot of plots that we were not very happy with...but reading it again made me understand things in a newer light.

I guess I was too overwhelmed with what was happening that I didn't read it with an open mind.....but going back to it, I have realised that the book is not that bad.

But I still stand by my word and say that it is not my fave of all the books so far published. I still like Book 4 way too much (even thought Ced died there 😭 )