Were they really freedom fighters?

tanveer.indian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
We imagine a freedom fighter as a black-and-white figure about to be thrashed by a hoisted baton, or sprinting away from cops in half-pants, or holding the tricolour and going somewhere. We imagine a freedom fighter as a rebel who challenged the Empire and who now is eligible for pensions and railways discounts.
Yet, a large number of people who are called freedom fighters today probably went to jail for reasons other than waging a noble war against the British. Some old hands say, a considerable number of youth who took part in the picketing were not very different from the great Indian hordes of hooligans one sees today jogging happily in a mass demonstration and waving to the cameras.
Every age has an in-thing and during the pre-independence days freedom struggle was that thing. And the young wallowed in its free entertainment. Many of whom are today 'freedom fighters'. Also, several people who receive the freedom fighters' allowance today played amusingly fringe roles in the massive theatre of rebellion.

Hindi litterateur and a former Maharashtra minister, late Ram Manohar Tripathi used to recall his uncle's contribution to the freedom struggle. The uncle owned a grocery shop in a small town in Uttar Pradesh. During the Quit India Movement when violent protests engulfed the country, some boys wanted to torch the local police station.
Tripathi's uncle refused to join the protestors but loaned a can of kerosene from his shop to the mob. Years later, the same uncle, now much older and slightly bent, walked up Tripathi's first floor home at Kurla in Mumbai, with a request to recommend him for the freedom fighters' pension.

After Independence, the government announced several incentives for freedom fighters. Those who spent more than six months in jail are given Rs 10,001 per month today while those who were imprisoned for less than that period get Rs 4,000 per month. It is no wonder that the number of freedom fighters in the country is magically increasing instead of dwindling with the inevitability of death.

An interesting nature of the list of freedom fighters is the sheer number of women in it, especially from impoverished backgrounds. There is a reason behind this apart from the natural patriotic fervour of many. There was a time in the struggle when 'Jail bharo' was in fashion and many men, especially daily wage workers who didn't want their families to starve, sent their wives instead.
Ahilya Rangnekar, who was deeply immersed in the struggle, remembers meeting many such female prisoners at Yerwada which is now famous for hosting Sanjay Dutt. "Some women told me they were there because they wanted their husbands to remain free and earn," says Rangnekar, a former MP, seated in her modest Matunga house, its plasters now peeling off.

Many were also jailed for "symbolic protest". In the tumultuous days of 1940s, Anand Rai cut a sapling from a reserved forest and duly reported it to the district magistrate. "I wrote to the district magistrate that I had disobeyed a law by cutting a sapling from a reserved forest. A few weeks later, I was arrested," recalls the 84-year-old Rai, a self-styled Gandhian.
Rai's journey from home to jail was interesting. A sub-inspector, one Gopalachari, who had arrested Rai proved to be fanatically patriot. After arresting him, Gopalachari kept Rai in an affluent home for a night before transferring him to the coarse bed of prison.

The lives of freedom fighters were not always entirely consumed by the struggle. They knew how to juggle imprisonment and business. Jagatdeo Narayan Verma, who accompanied Mahatma Gandhi from Bihar to Mumbai and never returned home, had a small homespun khadi shop in Matunga. During his imprisonment in Yerawada and elsewhere, his manager would visit him in jail every fortnight with the ledger.
"My father would instruct the manager on how to run the business," says the freedom fighter's son RJ Verma.

Needless to say, a considerable number of surviving freedom fighters went through tremendous agony for the cause. They were tortured and some had to spend days wearing manacles weighing 14 kilograms. Ramesh Kulkarni was 16 when he joined the freedom movement in January 1943. He would sing Vande Matram with older boys in the streets of Dadar in Mumbai.
He would also volunteer to distribute bulletins to underground freedom fighters. One night the police picked him up, and before he was pushed into an overcrowded Worli jail, he was detained at a police station evocatively called Shaitan Chowki in Central Mumbai. "The officer thrashed me badly. My limbs ached for days," says 82-year-old Kulkarni, who gets disconsolate today every time a government servant is rude with him.
Tanveer
Edited by abide - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

7

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

tazy_rahul thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
hey abide nice post nd nice avi

but if u dont mind i wish to say that using flag in avi is quiet ..... i dont know wat to say but during evening time this avi is not prohitable

* no offence to anyone i dont wanna hurt any1 i just wanna know is it allowed to use national flags like this bcoz i too wanna use it as my desktop background but i was stopped by some one so are v allowed ....just a question 😛
Edited by sweety_rajveer - 18 years ago
tanveer.indian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sweety_rajveer

hey abide nice post nd nice avi

but if u dont mind i wish to say that using flag in avi is quiet ..... i dont know wat to say but during evening time this avi is not prohitable

* no offence to anyone i dont wanna hurt any1 i just wanna know is it allowed to use national flags like this bcoz i too wanna use it as my desktop background but i was stopped by some one so are v allowed ....just a question 😛

Thanks for the compliment sweety.😊

Usage of a national flag is absolutely okay / alright as an avatar 😛 but not a flag made of plastic or cloth that is hoisted offline.😳

There's no such thing called day/night on the net.😛

Hai na?😛

I'd read an editorial in the Times of India, which had criticised the issuing / issuance of a/an NBW (Non-Bailable Arrest Warrant) against Aamir Khan.😊

I'll send its link as soon as I get it.😊

He'd only attended a function as a chief guest and was in no way connected with the hoisting of the national flag on Aug 15, 2007.😊

Moreover, the flag was lowered and removed by 05:30 p.m. in the evening itself that is quite before the sunsets in India.😊

So some publicity seeker had filed a frivolous PIL (Public Interest Litigation) just to seek public attention.😛😳

I think it is perfectly alright/okay to use it as a desktop background on your home PC.😕😳

However, I'll check out the rules regarding the flag and will surely let you know at the earliest.😕😳

I'd like to add that I'm using a bigger flag 😛 on a public social networking site for the past one and half year(s) without any problem.😛

Tanveer😊😃

IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
Nice post abide ji !
tanveer.indian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Thanks a lot for your feedback Mythili ji!😊😃

-Tanveer😊😃

raj5000 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Thanks Ejazfan, Temi, Elas for directing Tanveer here.

Welcome to DM, Tanveer!!

RE: Topic

Hard to say without any definate criteria spelled out as per law. How can someone's claims of participation in freedom validated? its hard and I think depending on current financial status of claimers, benefit of doubt should be given to all... for onething that they lived in that environment and must be some or other way affected. Finally does the Govt. have fund to support ?

PS - Cleaned and Bumped the post.

Edited by raj5000 - 18 years ago
tanveer.indian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Thanks for welcoming and for the feedback.

There was a media report on the TV channels in the last week of Nov 2007 that an Indian soldier who had taken part in the 1999 Kargil war and who was awarded India's highest military honour the 'Param Vir Chakra' whose name I can't recall is being given a meagre pension of Rs.696/- or Rs.693/- only.

Perhaps his name is Bana Singh but I'm not sure.

-Tanveer

Edited by abide - 18 years ago
qwertyesque thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Ok the article seems to indicate that jalianwala baug was a charade..and people didnt really die there they were just trying to act the hooligans of today... its that ridiculous and that british were playing with indian psyche... ok the question is where does it get real... Its important to note that people lost lives in this struggle which is not the same as people dying in stampedes in hooliganistic demonstrations. People who as much as stood up there to get the Lathis... are as much venerable... Its easy to see things in hind-sight..and trivialize them.. the in-thing is not the freedom struggle the in thing is that we miss an hitler one tyrant to invade us to understand the true value of what we possess and what we owe to all these people who contributed to the freedom struggle one way or the other..... 😊

Freedom struggle was a mass movement made of numbers.so anybody who as much as just stood there becomes a participant.. the leaders were driving the movement.. and thats not the same as trade union leaders leading a strike by numbers...

Edited by qwertyesque - 18 years ago
raj5000 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: abide

Thanks for welcoming and for the feedback.

There was a media report on the TV channels in the last week of Nov 2007 that an Indian soldier who had taken part in the 1999 Kargil war and who was awarded India's highest military honour the 'Param Vir Chakra' whose name I can't recall is being given a meagre pension of Rs.696/- or Rs.693/- only.

Perhaps his name is Bana Singh but I'm not sure.

-Tanveer

Your are welcome!Pension itself is exploited term ...people who need are unavailed and ppl who are doing god are tooo. Would say Govt should decide compensation per case basis....

raj5000 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: qwertyesque

Ok the article seems to indicate that jalianwala baug was a charade..and people didnt really die there they were just trying to act the hooligans of today... its that ridiculous and that british were playing with indian psyche... ok the question is where does it get real... Its important to note that people lost lives in this struggle which is not the same as people dying in stampedes in hooliganistic demonstrations. People who as much as stood up there to get the Lathis... are as much venerable... Its easy to see things in hind-sight..and trivialize them.. the in-thing is not the freedom struggle the in thing is that we miss an hitler one tyrant to invade us to understand the true value of what we possess and what we owe to all these people who contributed to the freedom struggle one way or the other..... 😊

Freedom struggle was a mass movement made of numbers.so anybody who as much as just stood there becomes a participant.. the leaders were driving the movement.. and thats not the same as trade union leaders leading a strike by numbers...

So agreed on bold but how to identify them...?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".