What if Sandhya is in fact the mystery lady

Page

Next Last

GovindaGovinda

@GovindaGovinda

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

This question has been lingering in my mind ever since I read IF posts -

this is hypothetical question - what if Sandhya actually donated the kidney but do not want to let the family know -

I really hope she is not the one but if she is, does anyone blame Suraj for this?

I would blame him for not Sandhya donating the kidney but for Suraj to have put her in that place meaning she could not discuss such a hard decision with anyone including once upon a time the love of her life -

if their relationship is like it was before, they both would have discussed and taken the decision like that time when the old man (babasa) got sick day before her training, she did not want to go but she discussed it with her husband

if Sandhy did give her kidney for Bhabo, I would never forgive Suraj for this, neither will Ankur

this only what if question

Quote

Frequent Posters

thala

@thala

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

good post GG

i too feel the same

she has donated but made a poor lady to act as the KD

she is on leave and is taking rest in some other place

neither ankur nor RP knows

but iam sure either zak or ankithat knows the truth

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

HalleNJ

@HalleNJ

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

why suraj has to be blamed? 😕 I dont understand 😕
As though Sandy has not hid things from him when they were in good terms...

even if she donates it, why didnt she tell suraj to please him...coz she herself knows he wouldnt agree to it...

see CVs has butchered suraj...I know that, but why blame him for everything? The only blame he should carry is making sandy an IPS...thats where everything started...isnt it?

Edited by niruba - 10 years ago

Quote

@Lvdt

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

gg your topic, we'v seen,sandy has done so many secret sacrifices [esp for bhabho, remember LC kaand,after tel maalish ready for consummate mrg 😆 ] i mean keeping secret without letting suraj know about that.so shudnt we give benefit of doubt to suraj also??

i prefer cvs stay on the side of realism first nd make sandhya human rather than super women.

i repeat sandhya needs to be shown as a human.

Edited by -ShahMSDian- - 10 years ago

Quote

Jaishankar

@Jaishankar

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

I cant blame Suraj for Sandy's own decision.Even if Surya were not separated at the moment what is the guarantee that Sandy would have discussed this,Knowing Sandy and her history she could have very well hidden this info somehow in the most illogical way as shown before and came through scott free without Suraj knowing that she donated her Kidney or she would have eventually convinced him about her motive(only CV's can pull off such illogical sequences like they have done before).

So dont think Suraj can be blamed here for Sandy's decision.Sandy's decision of donating KD is independent of Surya's relationship as from her perspective Bhabo is more than mother to her and if Sandy indeed has decided to donate KD she would have done so irrespective whether Surya were together or separated.

All this is being done to show Sandy mahan at the cost of Suraj which is illogical as usual.Looks like they want to make Sandy immortal aby sacrificing Suraj.Request CV's let Sandy remain mortal and spare all of us from this KD BS.

Edited by Jaishankar - 10 years ago

Quote

Venus12

@Venus12

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

Yea I was thinking the same thing and she just got this lady to act as the donor. I'm hating this so much and after this there is no way I can see the old suraj ever surfacing (atleast for me) no matter whatever he does👎🏼

If in fact it's revealed that she is the real donor, then all of them who rebuked her (suraj incl) will now worship her.. I never wanted sandy back into the rathi mad house this way🤔

Quote

JuhiR

@JuhiR

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

Very high chance of Sandy being the donor.

I will not forgive Suraj either because he pushed her into this...by telling her she would have thought differently if Bhabo was her own mother.

Anyway I was never very fond of Suraj during the first year of the show because of the torture Sandy went through from bhabo and gang, and because he was a mute spectator to all that torture; then I kind of accepted him after he helped Sandy's dream come true; but after the way he dumped her with a nonsensical explanation, I cannot tolerate him any more.

He can go and worship his mom all his life.

Quote

HalleNJ

@HalleNJ

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Govinda, one more thing...if every sacrifice of sandy, Suraj is to be blamed, then i dont call it as sacrifice then, sacrifice is done by selfless people for love, it is not done because of hurt or to prove a point...why would she prove her love to bhabo by donating her kidney and career...just because suraj said she doesnt treat bhabo as her own mom, doesnt mean she has to donate her kidney to prove that...

Edited by niruba - 10 years ago

Quote

Sonali_11

@Sonali_11

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

Im very much sure that Sandhya is the actual person who donated the kidney , she just does not want rathi family to know about it ...

She has done this to save Bhabo who is acting like a mother and was a genuine supporter through out this track, Even if such situation cropped up during the time when Bhabo was against her, she woud have done the same. Suraj cannot be blamed here , he did not even reveal to Sandhya that Bhabo is unwell.

Im sure Ankita knows where sandhya is and she is the one donated the kidney ..

If Sandhya is not the one, then it cud be that she found out she was pregnant and arranged for a kideny ..The chances of this case are less though.

Quote

GovindaGovinda

@GovindaGovinda

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: niruba
Govinda, one more thing...if every sacrifice of sandy, Suraj is to be blamed, then i dont call it as sacrifice then, sacrifice is done by selfless people for love, it is not done because of hurt or to prove a point...why would she prove her love to bhabo by donating her kidney and career...just because suraj said she doesnt treat bhabo as her own mom, doesnt mean she has to donate her kidney to prove that...

All I am saying is Suraj is not to be blamed for her sacrifices or deeds but this situation is different - if Sandhya and Suraj are together, if she offered to donate her kidney, at least Suraj would have been there to take care of her - but here she is all alone - no one to take care of her except her Bhabi - the situation that she was put in is sad -

sacrificing the kidney is not my issue - I take it back - it is but do not want to discuss it here - the issue is she had to do it secretly with out her husband knowing - so now whole life we see Suraj in this zombie mode knowing the truth, full of guilt etc etc - now another emotional blackmail by his wife - it has been Bhabo till now -

she hid stuff from him in the past because of Bhabo and Suraj relation - she did not want to upset that

I still do not understand how she got consent form signed -

At the end my frustration is how they are portraying everything in this show - mom's hold on their children after they are grown up is rediculous - career vs. family is even more absurd

I guess that is DABH - they give what ever is liked by the viewers

Quote

1 2

Sandhya

What if Sandhya is in fact the mystery lady

Related Topics

Explore Topics