Movie Reviews: Gandhi My Father

Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
By Taran Adarsh, August 3, 2007 - 11:57 IST

"The greatest regret of my life…
Two people I could never convince --
My Muslim friend Mohammed Ali Jinnah and
My own son Harilal Gandhi."

Making a film based on true events is difficult. Not only does it entail lots and lots of research, but to recreate the bygone era and get the right set of actors to enact the characters is another challenge.

Write your own movie review of Gandhi My Father

It's all the more tough if the film is based on Mahatma Gandhi. And a far bigger challenge is to present the relationship shared by the Mahatma and his son Harilal.

Everyone knows about Mahatma Gandhi, the Father of the Nation, but not much is known about him as a father to his children. GANDHI MY FATHER tells the story of Harilal Gandhi and the relationship he shared with his parents, more particularly with his father, the great Mahatma.

GANDHI MY FATHER leaves an indelible impression on the viewer. Since the story of Harilal is not known to many, you absorb every incident like a sponge absorbs water. It's an enlightening experience… and also a moving one. Your heart goes out to Harilal and his plight, more so towards the sunset of his life, makes you moist-eyed.

GANDHI MY FATHER tells a story not told before and director Feroz Abbas Khan tells it very well. Put your hands together for one of the finest films to come out of India. This one deserves to be the official entry for the Oscars.

To sum up, GANDHI MY FATHER is a must watch for every Indian. Strongly recommended!

Somewhere in the shadows of a great man [Mahatma Gandhi] lived his son [Harilal Gandhi], roaming the streets of India like a beggar. Converting to Islam as a rebellion, reconverting to Hinduism as a penance and finally drinking himself to death.

Mahatma Gandhi could transform the soul of a nation, but could not save the soul of his own son. The film unfolds a personal tragedy about a principled father and an unfortunate son.

For most viewers, the story of GANDHI MY FATHER is an eye-opener, since it tells a rarely heard story and tells it exceedingly well. The storyteller recreates the era with flourish, not once deviating from the core issue. The story is not about the freedom movement and the pivotal role played by the Mahatma, but it highlights the sensitive relationship between a father and son.

As a cinematic experience, GANDHI MY FATHER unfolds in the most simplistic, but compelling manner. Since the director is talking history, he ought to do the balancing act well. He reproduces facts without resorting to cinematic liberties and at the same time, simplifies everything so that the viewer can decipher it well.

A landmark film in all respects, highlighting a scene or two would be doing gross injustice to the film. For, every sequence has the power to keep you hooked and most importantly, carries the stamp of a genius.

The director has ensured that every department works in tandem. David Macdonald's cinematography is superb. Special mention must be made of the B & W, grainy frames that compliment the actual footage. The production design [Nitin Chandrakant Desai] is perfect. The ambience transports you to the early 20th century. Make-up [Penny Smith] is of international standard. The transformation of the characters as they age looks so real. Costumes [Sujata Sharma] suit the theme well. Background score [Piyush Kanojia] is appropriate.

Akshaye Khanna is extraordinary in the role of Harilal Gandhi. He portrays the varied emotions -- angst, sorrow, anger, frustration, love -- with great understanding and maturity and comes up with his career-best work. Darshan Jariwala as Mahatma Gandhi is another great performance you carry home. Although a number of seasoned actors have portrayed the part of Mahatma Gandhi on the big screen, Darshan's performance easily ranks amongst the best.

Shefali Shah is awesome. Note the sequence when Harilal converts to Islam and Kasturba Gandhi visits him. Or the final moments before she bids goodbye to the world. The actress deserves the highest marks. Why don't we see more of Shefali on the big screen? Bhumika Chawla is excellent. Her portions, with Harilal mainly, are well enacted.

On the whole, GANDHI MY FATHER is a treat for movie lovers. As mentioned at the very outset, it's a must-see for all Indians. At the box-office, it holds tremendous appeal for the multiplexes, where it should grow with a strong word of mouth. Strongly recommended!




http://indiafm.com/movies/review/12629/index.html

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.7k

Users

3

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Gandhi My Father - Movie Review

Posted by: Indicine Team | August 3rd, 2007 | 11 Views |

"To people he was a father, To his son he was a father he never had" - a perplexing statement isnt it? Well, the whole world is aware of Mahatma Gandhi's struggle in the freedom of India. Millions of Indians saw a 'Father' figure in him, and for these he was 'bapu'. But how many are aware of his personal sacrifices? How many are aware of the bitter relationship that he shared with his son?

Produced by Anil Kapoor, Gandhi My father tells the story of Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (Darshan Jariwala) and Kasturba Gandhi's (Shefali Chhaya) relationship with their eldest son Harilal Karamchand Gandhi (Akshaye Khanna). Veteran Feroz Abbas Khan has directed the film which is based on his play 'Mahatma vs Harilal'.

In the shadows of the Father of the nation lived his own son Harilal Gandhi, straying in the streets of India like a beggar. Harilal Gandhi is a looser, who fails to live upto the Gandhi surname. A rebellion converting to Islam, converting back to Hinduism as a remorse for his past conduct and finally drinking himself to death 5 months after the death of his great father. Mahatma Gandhi succeded in saving the nation from the British, but failed miserably in saving his son.

Sounds amazing and very interesting, doesnt it? How i wish the execution could do justice. Unfortunately, Gandhi My Father disappoints. The first half of the movie lacks the moments required to carry a historical. The pace in the first hour is sluggish. The narration picks up in the second half with a few brilliantly executed scenes. The railway station scene wherein Harilal gifts his mother a Orange and while the whole crowd that has gathered is cheering the Mahatma his son is cheering his mother, Kasturba Gandhi. Amazingly executed and Akshaye Khanna is in full form in the all important scene.

Technically the movie is strong and director Feroz Abbas Khan deserves credit. Cinematography by David Macdonald is splendid. The pre independence era and the overall look and feel has been captured on celluloid in detail. The background music is first rate.

Akshaye Khanna is brilliant. He has lived the role of Harilal Gandhi. Although not a very meaty role, he is bound to win a lot of accolades for this performance. Darshan Jariwala too has delivered a knockout performance. To state that he is Brilliant as Mahatma Gandhi would be a understatement. Shefali Chhaya excels, yet again. Bhoomika Chawla is good.

To sum things up, Gandhi My Father is a average movie with powerful performances by the lead actors. The movie has its moments but just not enough to carry a historical. Somehow, somewhere there is something lacking. In short Gandhi my father failed to live upto my expectations.

Rating: 2.5 / 5
Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Newsweek finds Gandhi, My Father gripping

Gandhi, My Father, a new film on the Mahatma has been acclaimed by Newsweek "as a gripping account of the stormy relationship between one of the world's greatest political icons and his rebellious eldest son."

Based on the biography Harilal: A Life, by the Gujarati scholar Chandulal Dalal, Gandhi, My Father-shot in Hindi and English "sheds light on the human side of the Mahatma, whose non-violent resistance to British rule helped win India its independence in 1947," notes the American magazine in its Aug 6 issue.

First-time film director Feroze Abbas Khan and Bollywood star turned producer Anil Kapoor blend sweeping sets and colourful costumes to create an emotionally charged period piece that occasionally verges on melodrama but is also sprinkled with genuine moments of comedy, it says.

"This is a story about a clash of principles between father and son," says Newsweek citing Khan, who first tackled the subject in his play Mahatma vs Gandhi. "Harilal carried his Gandhi identity like a curse around his neck. It was something that he just couldn't shake off."

Veteran actor Darshan Jariwala gives a refreshing portrayal of a man whose cast-iron morality could transform a nation yet failed to save his own son, the magazine says. Shefali Shah (Monsoon Wedding), who plays Gandhi's wife, Kasturba, and Bhumika Chawla as Harilal's wife, Gulab, give powerful performances as women caught in the cross-fire. Tushar Gandhi, the 47-year-old grandson of Manilal Gandhi, the second of Gandhi's four sons, is quoted as telling critics of the film that they should reserve judgment until they see it.

"The film remains sincere to the subject," he says, admitting it made him shed a few tears. "It is as though somebody has understood the pain of what our family went through."

Khan is meticulous in his effort to deliver a balanced narrative, painting neither Gandhi nor Harilal as the villain, says Newsweek noting previous films on the subject - like Richard Attenborough's Oscar-winning epic Gandhi - portray the great man as a political saint.

Gandhi, My Father upends this notion, depicting the Mahatma as a difficult patriarch whose ideals shaped a nation but hurt his family, it says. As Khan points out: "He loved his son and family, but he loved the nation more." It's a distinction that makes for a compelling film.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?id=25 4a9a5c-8546-48d4-aa70-8f784d0cb121&ParentID=caee0d93-25b8-44 ae-8862-75d5af648d59&&Headline=EMNewsweek%2fEM+finds+EMGandh i%2c+My+Father%2fEM+gripping
Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
Gandhi My Father

Anil Sinanan, Times Bollywood critic

Director Feroze Abbas Khan, PG, 134 mins, Subtitles

Stars Darshan Jariwala, Akshaye Khanna, Shefali Shah, Bhoomika Chawla.

1948, India. When the Bombay cops pick up a gravely ill destitute off the streets, they need his fathers' name in order to admit him to hospital. Why does the dying beggar answer 'Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi'?

Much is known about Gandhi's non-violent ideals and the 'Quit India' movement he founded which was directly responsible for the British grant of independence to India and the creation of Pakistan. Little is known about his family life.

This bio-pic attempts to redress the balance. It traces the disintegrating relationship between the Mahatma or 'Bapu' (father) (Darshan Jariwala) as he was fondly known, with the eldest of his four sons, Hiralal (Akshaye Khanna).

Told in flashback, the film establishes the uneasy tensions in the family's South African sojourn where Gandhi practised as a barrister up to 1915. The patriarch's steely insistence that Hiralal abandon his education and wife Gulab (Bhoomika Chawla) in order to assist him in his fight against the inequitable apartheid system, leads to resentment by the young Hiralal.

Post 1915, the entire family relocates to India where resistance to British imperialism is gaining momentum. Hiralal tries to assert his own independence but he is thwarted by opportunists who use the Gandhi name to establish fraudulent companies and discredit the freedom movement. The Mahatma publicly disowns his wayward son; Hiralal sinks into alcoholic depression.

Adapted from his stage play of the same name, Feroze Abbas Khan's debut is an exploration of a taboo topic in modern India: the possible demerits of Gandhian idealism. Indeed, the film has already created controversy in India.

The fuss is unwarranted. Made with the co-operation of the surviving Gandhi family, Khan's film frustratingly refuses to take sides and portrays both protagonists as flawed individuals caught up in circumstances beyond their control.

It is a film of performances: Jariwala gets the Mahatma's mannerisms eerily right, Khanna attempts to emote but it is Shefali Shah as the suffering wife Kasturba who holds it all together. Her understated portrayal of the woman who attempts to bridge the emotional gap between father and son eschews melodramatic hysteria.

The rambling narrative of the first hour with a few short songs (frustratingly, not subtitled) could be edited. Khan's direction betrays his theatrical background: many scenes simply act as a convenient plot device in order to propel the narrative.

But this is a largely successful attempt at intelligent Indian cinema. Moving without being manipulative, Gandhi my father is largely devoid of the bolly-clichs so typical of the 'formula'.

A worthy companion piece to Attenborough's Oscar classic.

RATING : 4 / 5
Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
Gandhi My Father

Gandhi My Father With a sweeping scope and a strong attention to detail, this beautifully made film centres on the stormy relationship between Gandhi and his eldest son. It's overlong and repetitive, but it impressively gives us a full-bodied portrait of the icon.

In 1906, Mohandas and Kasturba Gandhi (Jariwala and Shah) were living in South Africa, where Gandhi worked as a lawyer challenging segregationist rule. Their eldest son Hari (Khanna) returns from India with his new wife Gulab (Chawla) hoping to make something of his life. Over the next 40 years, the whole family returns to India, where Gandhi leads his entire nation in a peaceful uprising against the British colonialists. Meanwhile, Hari struggles with addictions, bad decisions, a weak will and living with a very famous father.

This is a fascinating story with some surprising edges, as we see Gandhi in a very new light--still as an important leader, but also as a man with cheeky humour and a strong will who never manages to sort out his relationship with his number one son, disapproving his marriage, belittling his opinions and yet also willing to forgive and support him. It's a complex relationship that's never simplified in the film, and is notably well-played by the cast.

Writer-director Khan manages the tricky job of balancing reverence for the immortal figure who fathered a nation with the flesh and blood man who wasn't always so perfect. He shows us a side of Gandhi that's even more sympathetic than what we've seen before--a man so dedicated to justice that he refuses to give his children any advantage, and then can't understand why people criticise him for that. And as Hari is suffocated by his father's expectations, judgement and emotional distance, it's not surprising he goes off the rails.

As it progresses, the film loses track of Hari's siblings and children to focus closely on his father's politics and their troubled relationship. This narrows the film sharply, losing the family context and falling into the cyclical nature of Hari's alcoholism, jobs, scams and religions. All of this tragedy, reconciliation, heroism and stupidity are somewhat tiring to watch. And yet it's a vital, important portrait of Gandhi. And an intriguing look at a man who can't live in, or escape, his father's shadow.

Ratings: 3.5/5
Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
By Taran Adarsh, August 4, 2007 - 08:57 IST

B.O. update: 'Gandhi My Father'

GANDHI MY FATHER: The opening response has been very poor. But the silver lining is the appreciation from the multiplex junta. A lot depends on how the film behaves on Saturday and Sunday. Will the appreciation translate into good business is to be seen.

http://indiafm-live.indiafm.com/trade/boxoffice_update/index .html
Pradarshak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
"Gandhi my father" is worth watching in recent times. A movie made in a very good taste. This is what we call movie, original and utmost Indian in every aspect. Not some sleazy slick flick copied from Hollywood. We should be proud in promoting such movies, this one should go for the oscars.
preity*zinta thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Fashion_2005

By Taran Adarsh, August 3, 2007 - 11:57 IST


GANDHI MY FATHER leaves an indelible impression on the viewer. Since the story of Harilal is not known to many, you absorb every incident like a sponge absorbs water. It's an enlightening experience… and also a moving one. Your heart goes out to Harilal and his plight, more so towards the sunset of his life, makes you moist-eyed.



http://indiafm.com/movies/review/12629/index.html

I totally agree with that part. I just finished watching the movie. I was really interested in the movie. I like knowing Gandhi's relationship with his son and everything that happened. The story was well told and everyone did a fantastic job!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".