I'll still say II2 was the best - Page 2

Sorry, I dont agree. I feel II-1 was the best, closely followed by II-3. Yes II-2 had some real gems like Karu, Amey, Meenal but overall it was not good. Sorry, just my opinion. Anyways, I love II no matter what.

Originally posted by: Pentaminous

Yea..II2 was Best..!! 😃

Has to be Amey was there.

II 2 had it's charm...II 3 is full of drama the judge's fights the contestants love stories. Sony is trying to create so much of drama in the show... I wonder how much more will they stoop for TRP's?

Originally posted by: sonyaee

And I will still agree with you 😊
Besides Amey and Karunya, lets not forget Antara and Meenal. They were very good as well.

Deepali is my favorite in II3 but tere bina jiya was disappointing. Antara was much better with the song even though she had a few pronunciation problems. But she managed to bring the romance into the song which Deepali did not. Side note: Both wore similar saris too. 😆

I so agree with u sonya😛 II-2 is the best for me too...

I havent heard Deepali version but according to Payal & Koeli too Antara's one was much better😳😛


Anyways I dont think any of this idol gonna have playback offers soon...Anu promised to emon like he gave to amey earlier...He promised all time for antara...so I am not considering his promises this time for sure...all others will get much offers in stage shows & all but for playback it will be tough for them I guess...

Originally posted by: sonyaee

And I will still agree with you 😊
Besides Amey and Karunya, lets not forget Antara and Meenal. They were very good as well.

Deepali is my favorite in II3 but tere bina jiya was disappointing. Antara was much better with the song even though she had a few pronunciation problems. But she managed to bring the romance into the song which Deepali did not. Side note: Both wore similar saris too. 😆

yea i 2nd agree wit u not becoz antara is my fav frm idol 2 but she was jus too gud wit dat song nd sang is soo soo beautifully filled wit full of romance melody nd evrything.. i still keep hearing dt song frm Antara..😊

Sadly I have to now accept that II 2 was much better. There was a time when I argued how II 3 singers are at par with each other that it is tough to choose one and now I know that I was comparing mediocre singers. In II 2 there were only two singers for me, Amey and Karunya but those two are much better than all the singers of II 3 together and yes! including Amit.

I still think Deepali is much better than the girls in II 2 though. I didn't like any II 2 girls but II 1 girls were the best. Aditi Paul and Prajakta.

i disagree tht INDIAN IDOL 2 was best......wo to mujhe koi sattey bazi ka game lagraha tha.......na hee logon ki awaz achi thi......xcept amay date......nd in this idol they all r best nd hv a best voice quality