Why a gurugraph ??!!

The whole point of introducing a gurugraph was to bring in objectivity to the comments given by the mentors!! But that is what seems to have got lost somewhere...!

Every other performance gets a 10, 10, 10 on the gurugraph... How does one differentiate a bad from a mediocre, and a mediocre from a good performance in that case.... Mauli, Raja, Aneek (and actually a few more) got a complete 30 on that meter? Do the judges want to say that they al sang equally well or bad... Aneek was good.. Raja was at best mediocre with the song and Mauli was bad! Then why a 30? And shouldnt a 30 mean that it was a flawless performance?

The mentors just seem to be competing amongst themselves as to who can give higher points for mediocre singing... Looks like they get a commission proportionate to the points given out!

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

The whole point of introducing a gurugraph was to bring in objectivity to the comments given by the mentors!! But that is what seems to have got lost somewhere...!

Every other performance gets a 10, 10, 10 on the gurugraph... How does one differentiate a bad from a mediocre, and a mediocre from a good performance in that case.... Mauli, Raja, Aneek (and actually a few more) got a complete 30 on that meter? Do the judges want to say that they al sang equally well or bad... Aneek was good.. Raja was at best mediocre with the song and Mauli was bad! Then why a 30? And shouldnt a 30 mean that it was a flawless performance?

The mentors just seem to be competing amongst themselves as to who can give higher points for mediocre singing... Looks like they get a commission proportionate to the points given out!

this is reality tv
and they seem to be doing a good job

gurugraph is only needed to ensure that you vote as much as can for your favorite singers

if one judge ( read alka ) gives correct marks the other judges and the channel get behind their backs because they dont want to annoy any singers' fans

so to please all you get 10 10 10

😆

I think that has been kept just for the entertainment for the Guru's. Those graphs make the least sense.

To me it looks more like a time pass thing. Or maybe have been put just to make the Guru's feel a bit more important. 😉 😆

Of all the performances Mauli getting perfect 30!! Ridiculous. I thought atleast Vishal Shekhar would mark bit more sensibly. But no even they have decided to take the same path as Ismail ji and Himesh. Do they mean to say Mauli and Musarrat was at par!!!

Gurugraph or Mentometer or whatever name given anywhere are going through the same weather. Everyone is following the same. But here lets stick to mentometer... Please a request!!

the answer to your question, gurugraph is the graph made by gurus hope it helps

point noted and edited post above
just one thing whether we like it or not
there is no such thing as a free lunch
ppl are not running a talent hunt for charity

why would they remove a saas bahu show and replace it with a musical show if it doesnt fetches them money

all is well as long as it fetches TRPs

Originally posted by: raunaq

the answer to your question, gurugraph is the graph made by gurus hope it helps

😆 good one.😆😆

But jayaji seems to be having a problem with the 'gurugraph' since last week.😆 j/k😆😆

Originally posted by: lalit1

point noted and edited post above
just one thing whether we like it or not
there is no such thing as a free lunch
ppl are not running a talent hunt for charity

why would they remove a saas bahu show and replace it with a musical show if it doesnt fetches them money

all is well as long as it fetches TRPs

👏

We should keep one thing in mind that the channel houses are business houses. They will do everything for money.

But yes Guru's should maintain some consistancy while giving the Guru Graph ratings. Those ratings effect the voting patterns.

Originally posted by: Thakur Saab

😆

I think that has been kept just for the entertainment for the Guru's. Those graphs make the least sense.

To me it looks more like a time pass thing. Or maybe have been put just to make the Guru's feel a bit more important. 😉 😆

Of all the performances Mauli getting perfect 30!! Ridiculous. I thought atleast Vishal Shekhar would mark bit more sensibly. But no even they have decided to take the same path as Ismail ji and Himesh. Do they mean to say Mauli and Musarrat was at par!!!

It indeed looks like the new toy on the block😉😆 That mentors seem to be playing with to find out ki agar 10 points de to bar graph kitna upar jaata hai😆 And what was that from HR.. Mauli, tell your fans to watch Hay Baby First Day First Show, and I will convert the 5 to 10.. Kya comedy hai😆

On a more serious note, a graph or a scale that makes no sense, and only sends wrong signals across needs to be thrown out!

Perhaps what Lalit says is right.... This format of reality TV on this show seems to be a pretty unrelated to a musical contest! And hence everything has to sell before anything else!

I only feel sorry for the select few talented contestants like Aneek or Amaanat who are on the show!

Originally posted by: Thakur Saab

👏

We should keep one thing in mind that the channel houses are business houses. They will do everything for money.

But yes Guru's should maintain some consistancy while giving the Guru Graph ratings. Those ratings effect the voting patterns.

its better to give all 10s then do the obvious discrimination that adesh and himesh did to debojit and ID giving 6&7 and also ujjaini being given 6 by adesh whilst being given 9 by ID