Nerungi Va Muthamidathe review

Aarthi_01 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Movie Reviews
Find Movies By: Latest | Alphabets | Release Date

Nerungi Va Muthamidathe

M Suganth, TNN, Oct 31, 2014, 09.47PM IST
0
inShare
A
A
Critic's Rating:
Cast: Shabeer, Pia Bajpai, Sruthi Hariharan, Y Gee Mahendra, AL Alagappan, Thambi Ramaiah, Bala Saravanan
Direction: Lakshmy Ramakrishnan
Genre: Drama
Duration: 1 hour 54 minutes
Avg Readers Rating:

Check out Nerungi Va Muthamid.. show timings in

Chennai
Mon 10 Nov 2014
Find
  • Times Of India
Synopsis: A fuel crisis has thrown life out of gear across the country. A lorry driver is making a clandestine trip from Trichy to Karaikal carrying 2,000 litres of diesel. Why is he on this journey? How do people who board the lorry influence the journey? And, for what purpose is the diesel being transported?

Synopsis: Using a multi-strand narrative, Lakshmy Ramakrishnan constructs a film that is part road movie, part thriller, and part drama. The film is set against the backdrop of a fuel crisis and there are at least a dozen key characters. There is Chandru (Shabeer), who agrees to transport 2,000 litres of diesel from Trichy to Karaikal for politician Kaleeswaran (AL Alagappan); Subramaniam (Y Gee Mahendra), his petrol bunk owner father, who is always criticizing his ne'er-do-well son; Chokku (Bala Saravanan), his friend, who keeps waiting for his heirless chithappa to die so that he can become a rich man.

Then, we have the characters who end up hitching a ride in the lorry " Maya (Pia), a youngster who has a misunderstanding with her singer mother Sita (Viji); Maha (Sruthi) and her lower caste lover who take refuge in Chandru's lorry, and whose elopement has resulted in violence in their village; a motormouth (Thambi Ramaiah) who might be more than what he seems. And finally, a minister (Lakshmy Ramakrishnan) who is masterminding something sinister with the mysterious man whose escape kick-starts the film.

Lakshmy manages to give us the backstory of many of these characters, and keep the plot moving at the same time so that we have enough to care about them and wait in anticipation of what happens next. The use of songs (Kaligaalam, which is used for Maha's romance, is the best of the lot) to narrate the backstories is a nifty touch.

However, these sub-plots feel cliched " inter-caste romance, antagonistic father-son relationship, misunderstood mother, corrupt politician " that we are never really surprised by how they develop. The lovers learn a lesson, the son redeems himself in the eyes of his father, the mother's horrific past makes the daughter realize her mistakes, and the politician gets his just comeuppance. In her debut Aarohanam, Lakshmy gave us characters who continuously surprised us in a good way but here that doesn't happen. The performances, mostly, come across as artificial because the actors are playing archetypes rather than rounded characters.

But there are also times when the director gives too much space to certain characters that the film's pacing suffers. If Thambi Ramaiah is made to go overboard in the name of comedy (Bala Saravanan, in contrast, comes across as restrained), the sub-plot involving Maya and Sita feels inconsequential. Maya is feeling guilty about hurting her mother and wants to apologize for it, but we never get the need for urgency in this track. She knows her mother is going to Malaysia only for a concert but then starts thinking that she will not return forever because of her harsh words! Lakshmy could have even done away with this track and the film wouldn't have suffered at all. Yes, Maya's presence helps when incensed villagers stop the vehicle to search for the eloped lovers and later when the lorry is stopped by the cops. But the director could have very well avoided the first twist and used the couple itself for the second occasion. Instead, the lovers, whose tale resonates better than Maya's, are sent off midway and in rather inelegant fashion. The tacking of a romantic angle between Maya and Chandru towards the end is cringe-worthy.

But the stranded terrorist sub-plot is handled well. We are told convincingly how the cops come to know about his presence (chance interception) and the hunt for him doesn't come across as too cinematic (thankfully, we do not get a daring cop character). The same goes for the manner in which Chandru finally outwits Kaleeswaran when he realizes for what he is transporting the diesel. There are no heroics involved, just plain common sense, and that makes this journey worthwhile.

Critic's Rating: 3 star
Cast: Shabeer, Pia Bajpai, Sruthi Hariharan, Y Gee Mahendra, AL Alagappan, Thambi Ramaiah, Bala Saravanan
Direction: Lakshmy Ramakrishnan
Edited by --aarthi-- - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

637

Users

2

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

Aarthi_01 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe Review - Compelling journey

IndiaGlitz [Friday, October 31, 2014]
3 Comments

Of the many things that we take for granted, availability of fuel is a vital need that we ignore to value to the amount that it demands attention. Price hikes and scarcity are not a new phenomenon but what if this is to prolong for as long as it slaps the reality of everyday dependency on our face? 'Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe' is a movie about what we otherwise consider to be lesser concern, but is as essential to our daily life, as the basic necessities, for the attachment we have created to fuel. But not only has diesel drawn the limelight, some of the social injustices and life after that, are also added in subtly.

Plot:

The story is based in and around port city of Karaikal. A couple from different financial and religion-based communities find the perfect match in each other. Obviously, this is vehemently opposed in their village, and they have no option but to run for life. A youth from an ostensibly well to do family strays to follow his heart, oppose his father and drive trucks and lorries, ferrying goods for the thrill. A girl from an affluent background refuses to understand her mother, for the mystery of who he father is. These three are linked in the common thread of travel.

The couple Maha and Pichai are tracked down by relatives, primarily for honour killing. The young girl Maya discovers the truth behind her father's mystery as an injustice to her mother; but when she goes to meet her, it is already too late, and add to that, Maya falls prey to a road accident. And the lorry driver Chandru on the other hand runs headlong into deep trouble, for smuggling two thousand litres of diesel amidst fuel crisis, getting him eligible to be sentenced for crime at a national level. Where and how the journey ends is the story of 'Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe'.

Performance:

Pretty Piaa plays Maya, who is risen by her single mother played by Viji Chandrashekar. Maya never understands until the end, why the identity of her mother is a haze. The confusion in her face and pented up anger is apparent on her face, through all the scenes. And finally when she unleashes the truth, there is clear tone of understanding. Her deft at wearing the right expression compensates for the lack of dialogues for her role, and her face speaks for herself. Viji, on the other hand, has an intense character. Her acting is typical of how a confident woman leads her life and those of others, despite heinous oddities.

Shruthi Hariharan is only a few movies old, but her skills can be gauged amply by her previous Kannada outing, in the award winning 'Lucia'. Shruthi plays Maha, of a higher class, who falls in love with Pichai from a very low stratum. Both show immense dedication to each other and courage to face the cruel world together, mutually blinded by love. Their acting in proper understanding of the situation, willing for a positive change and patience, is smart.

Shabeer drives the travel forward, as Chandru the lorry driver. Despite being the son of the owner of a petrol bunk, played by Y Gee Mahendra, Shabeer's screen character chooses to quit education, and drive lorry to his whims. As the father, Y Gee Mahendra gets more and more angry at each level. But he also cares in the end like a father would always be. Cool, confident, composed yet menacingly violent when the time demands - that is all that makes up Chandru, and is played to perfection by Shabeer.

Picture:

The is an intense story with many characters and loops, but the sole reason it is appealingly presented is the perfection in cinematography, editing, screenplay and direction. The story is the journey of three different families and Vinod Bharathi takes you along in the beatiful journey through his lens. There are sequences where the scenes shunt back and forth between the past and present, and if not for Sabu Joseph's class editing at these and also in the journey otherwise, it would not be easy to understand the crux of the story. Kudos to Lakshmy Ramakrishnan for a very thoughtfully crafted, meticulously planned and beautifully narrated story, that is first of its kind in Kollywood. Although there are no run-around sort of duets, the film essentially needs music as its fourth pillar and Madley Blues have done a commendable job at that. The breezy movie is visually appealing, thanks to the thoughtful art direction and camera.

Plus:

No running-around duets, no unnatural fight sequences, optimum emotions, and subtly put strong social messages - there is a lot to write on the positive aspects of the movie that seems almost entirely perfect. Not only is it a journey that is enjoyable by all, despite the absence of regular masala, it is also a strong movie that highlights many social concerns including smuggling, casteism and violence on women, apart from household concerns like misunderstanding of parents by children and confident women leading their lives against heinous oddities. Not only have problems been pointed out, they end in an amicable solution, which makes the story a practical take.

Puzzles:

Although nearly everything is perfect, there are a few portions of the movie which could have been explained better, for the lack of which, they stand out as sore thumb in sharp contrast against the otherwise wholesome story. Unanswered questions include running away of Maya's friend at the mention of police, and also the identity of his parents that is mysteriously under wraps. The question of the future of the lovey-dovey couple that eloped is also left unanswered. Lack of masala is compensated for in the magical sudden transformation of Maya's emotions in the end.

However, these small hitches do not hamper the otherwise perfect picture at large. Based on a journey in a lorry, rolling out under the title inspired by the lines on many such beasts, 'Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe' is a path-breaking movie in Tamil cinema history.

Rating: 3/5
Verdict: A must watch movie like never before

Aarthi_01 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe' - refreshingly creative (IANS Tamil Movie Review)

Film: "Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe"; Cast: Pia Bajpai, Shabeer, Shruti Hariharan, Viji Chandrasekhar, Thambi Ramaiah and Y. Gee Mahendran; Director: Lakshmy Ramakrishnan; Rating: ***1/2

There's a thin line that divides being preachy and creative while addressing a burning issue.

When A.R. Murugadoss's "Kaththi" attempted to win the audience's heart by portraying mass suicide of farmers just a week ago, it only made me sympathetic, but didn't quite move me.

Lakshmy Ramakrishnan's "Nerungi Vaa Muthamidathe", which is about the recent petrol and diesel crisis, doesn't tread that same path, and instead addresses the subject at hand with unparalleled creativity, without ever getting priggish.

In an important scene, an undertaker pours liquor on a dead body before setting it on fire because of shortage of petrol or its substitute products. A tea shop owner, who is awakened from his deep slumber, is shown preparing black tea because milk has not been delivered due to the petrol crisis.

Likewise, a group of workers doubtfully talk about the delivery of a consignment of onions. In another important scene, we see the signboard 'Today's wastage is tomorrow's shortage'. That's how subtly and artistically Lakshmy has handled the subject. There are no scenes about how devastatingly lives are been affected due to the crisis.

And the reason Lakshmy handles the core subject maturely is because she focuses on the three stories that run parallel to each other.

A couple, Maha and Pichai, are on the run because they're from different communities. Chandru, who hails from an affluent family, opposes his father and drives trucks. Maaya is the victim of a strained relationship with her mother (whose portion is handled beautifully), who hasn't told her daughter who her father is. Their stories are narrated through brief flashbacks, conveniently played to us via songs (which are soothing), to ensure that we never get bored. They are linked in the common thread of travel.

While focusing on the three stories, never does Lakshmy deviate from the subject. In almost every scene, you hear or see the impact of the crisis on public life. For instance, in the opening scene, as a group of women talk about a batch of onions that's getting ready to be transported, we hear about the petrol situation on the radio in the background. In another scene, two important characters sit down to talk, news about the issue is played on the television.

Too many characters leave us guessing about the story till the last minute. But we are not told why some of these characters are introduced and later disappear. Like the guy who emerges out of water in the first scene or the couple who travels with Thambi Ramaiah in a shared auto or the motive behind the involvement of the central petroleum minister. Maybe Lakshmy didn't want us to get distracted from the main story and her lead characters.

The performances are fresh. The music by Madley Blues is uplifting, while the cinematography is stunning. Just as she promised, Lakshmy has proved that she can make a better commercial film that's sensible and original. And the way she handles her women characters shows why women filmmakers know how to handle their own kind perfectly. Heroines should feel proud to work with Lakshmy.

Edited by --aarthi-- - 10 years ago
supercool3 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
This movie seems to have got some very positive reviews from the critics. Looking forward to watching it, especially 'cause it's by Lakshmy Ramakrishnan.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".