Originally posted by: Pemberley
[quote]
About rani signed chalte chalte, Rani was the first choice but she said she don't have dates then the role went to ash and did ash asked rani if it's ok with her? Then why should rani ask ash? Rani didn't do anything bad to ash that ash got so offended that she broke her friendship with ran [/quote]
This is incorrect. Rani was not the first choice--you must remember that at that time Rani wasn't very successful. Aishwarya was first choice and even began filming. Salman came on set and verbally abused both Ash and SRK. They closed down set and SRK decided to recast Ash with Rani. The problem lies is that Rani did this all behind Ash's back. You must remember that they were best buddies--it wasnt' just another actress replacing another it was a friend. Aishwaray has every reason to feel betrayed by Rani. She was hurt by SRK as well and he's since apologized. But he wasn't a best buddy like Rani supposedly was to Ash. I know you guys are fans of Rani but I think you should admit that what she did to Ash was a betrayal of their friendship.
As for Rani as an actress. She's good in some roles and not so good in others. I think she's overrated because of Black where everyone thinks everything she does is great. She is not. She was not believable in Kank. She didn't have the depth or sexuality to carry off that role. She was weak in Baabul where she cried and cried yet I felt absolutely no emotion toward her character.
So please stop with the Rani is the greatest actress because she is not.
okii just cuz rani signed a film with srk...ash felt dat she was betraying her...WTF....if dat was friendship then im sorry to say.....wat a selfish friend ASH was....how can u leave a friend just cuz she signed a movie....u have 2 keep ur professional n personel life seprate...n datz wat rani did i guess..
Debate Mansion
