Balika Vadhu Written Update 30th October 2014

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

DrMCallgari

@DrMCallgari

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#21

Thanks for update

@Hina thanks for beautiful JaGan caps

JaGan are such a delightful couple You watch their scenes million times you never get tired of them Their love is so beautiful 😊

Standing applause for cvs for handling Jhoomar's track so well and giving such a strong social message through the words of their lead Jagya His words were so apt

I agree with mahi Jagya was putting Ramesh to shame when he said there should not be any trial of your case You should only be hanged Thats the only punishment for you He never said or meant one should take law in his hands when he handed Ramesh to police he followed law but if he said those lines to shame Ramesh then nothing wrong in it If people are molding it to other side then how they are so sure court trials always right ? Come on in courts too innocents are sentenced and criminals are freed Courts are no longer temples of truth so next time people will say court trials should not happen innocent get punished in it?

The other school kids will know some day or the other because the crime happened with jhoomar in a public place It is better they know now and they understood too and are supporting Jhoomar instead of it they one day know in a shocking way and poor Jhoomar gets embarrassed in front of them for none of her mistake

I also disagree with the criticism on the closure of track It was much betterly and sensibly , giving strong social message

i cannot understand Anandi Anoop and Sanchi drama 😕

Quote

SPuja

@SPuja

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#22

Thanks for detailed update.

What has happened to BV writers? They think they can show anything - even in Sanchi's case - they did show identity of victim revealed and no punishment to the culprits as required by law. Now the matter is more serious because the victim is a minor (they do not reveal name of minors even if the minor is the culprit - for example we still do not know the name of minor involved in Nirbhaya's case) - how will Jhoomar now go to school - when everybody knows what she has gone through - Jaitsar is still a village (the creatives themselves are confused and time and again use village and villagers for Jaitsar) and a conservative society...

Then again Bhaili - what are the principles of Bhaili? To give concessional rate to the first customer? They should have shown this customer to be some organisation working for people - such as an orphanage, old age home etc. - and then justify Bhaili's stand that they will not quote increased prices to this customer because of their work profile - that would look reasonable. Bhaili is non-profit for only Anandi - she is not there to earn - but for women working there - it is a source of livelihood - business principles should be applied to help the women working there.

In films - hero do all the stunts - but a serial with social message showing a DC or a MLA doing stunts and fighting is bad. Who can grab a knife's sharp edge and the goon with the handle cannot even snatch it? If anyone does this in reality - he will lose his fingers... Why show MLA going to fight goons - he should have sent police...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

saba113

@saba113

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#23

I don't think anything has happened to BV writers but criticism is too much 🥱The drama is for entertainment It is not a social message Gyaan Even the social message based documentaries shown on real life instances are carrying dramatic flavor to attract the attention They are trying to be conveying apt social message as much as they can but members here want them just to sit and distribute social message Gyaan May be they can only do one thing Keep giving lectures only No story nothing 🥱

Quote

SPuja

@SPuja

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#24

They do not even have a story - someone rightly said - it is now like Panchtantra - just a group of small tracks with no continuity with the previous or future track...

Quote

saba113

@saba113

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#25

They dont have story now ok then when they had story before ?what was so special about previous story that is not special now

Agree the main leads have settled The Bal Vivah thing over but they are introducing short tracks in their lives and maintaining social message too The tracks do give some message Jhoomar's track did give except some people think they did the biggest crime they did in revealing jhoomar's identity to school staff and kids were also there Only in front them not in front of Panchayat of all village ?but what was wrong in over all message of track ? Nothing

anyways i am not here to argue again will be accused i am just supporting selective characters thats it Lets agree to disagree

Quote

ButterflyOnRose

@ButterflyOnRose

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#26

They did not call press or media and revealed victim's identity in front of them They did not call the panchayat and beaten drum in front of them They did not show anything in front of all village There were only some school staff probably the head committee as no school have so less staff and police , some students of higher class As mostly from them were Dadisaa's class fellows not even all school kids were present It is not possible to hide victim's identity from all world or is it ? I think where an incident occurs some people in surrounding do know but news spread like a fire if media gets it and they did not call media Regarding the kids they were not small kids as i see they were mostly higher class students Nandu and Dadisaa's class fellows they can keep quiet I think cvs have shown the track quite logically better than Sanchi's case

Regarding MLA sahab going to fight goons Well in today's episode what i said was correct He did call police and they followed him He only wanted to catch the goons red handed doing crimes and he did Now before people say police could come earlier too why Jagya was shown beating goons Then the simple answer This is a serial They have to follow how a fiction story goes in every piece of writing where a hero is center of attraction of readers and viewers If hero won't do anything All police and other people do , who will watch their serial? If Jagya would have only ordered police today to arrest the goons many of viewers who tuned to colors to watch BV would not have liked it i give my example i would not have , Viewers watch it for entertainment and only a hero and heroine can give them that This is only fiction serial not some reality television show it has always been fictitious made for entertainment If they manage to provide social message with it and give convincing social message thats quite better but it cannot change the fact it is a drama made for entertaining viewers much like films are Till they are logical and don't spread some bad social message , show less bloopers at least i won't criticize them To me they have done this Jhoomar's track and land grab track quite nicely

Its not like i am supporting Jagya so please don't blame me for it I did criticize where their tracks were not right For example Ganga's pregnancy track Till date i am angry with cvs for it but now i don't see any fault

Quote

aparnauma

@GoodDoc_2105

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#27

I don't see why the decision not to sell at revised rates to their fisrt customer has to be seen as an emotional decision by Anandi.

Even in profit oriented business organisations customers are made to feel that they are special to the organisation.

Here it becomes even more important because the first customer not just bought the products but pledged her/his support to the organisation called Bhaili and what all that organisation stands for.There is no reason why that customer had to buy from Bhaili in the first place.They bought them because they supported the cause of Bhaili and later on Bhaili expanded and had started getting more customers.

Not even a profit oriented business organisation forgets their first customer so why should Anandi/Bhaili treat that customer as just any other customer?

I don't think it is an emotional decision on part of Anandi it is a business decision.

------------------

As for Collector fighting the goons - At the end of the day it is a drama and not a documentary on issues.

There is something called creative licence.

So what if it is a social message oriented show? It is still a drama - the messages are the issues and the questions they raise.

Here thru Bhaili they are raising questions in business ethics.The makers don't need to tell us what is wrong what is right.They are only there to raise questions and make the viewers think about them.

Balika Vadhu has been raising issues and it is making viewers think about them.That is where their job should stop.They are nobody to tell us viewers what is wrong and what is right.

I don't get why people feel it is the duty of the media to tell what is wrong and what is right.It is NOT their duty.They can only point out the issues and allow the viewers to come to their own conclusion.

Quote

aparnauma

@GoodDoc_2105

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#28

I don't know why it is being said that there is no story.

At least Anandi's story is happening.

With each track they are showing her growth and her personality developing.

Especially starting from this Feb.

Anandi's story did always go very slowly and it always moved at snail pace.

One whole year after honey moon was dedicated to her becoming a complete part of Shekhar family and her becoming one of the Shekhars and all the tracks including those horrible tracks featuring bad Sanchi Ira becoming irrational in her efforts to get her daughter what she wants then Sanchi's fall and and her transformation - All these tracks did show Anandi's growing bond with the Shekhar family and them understanding what drives Anandi and her efforts to understand them and adjust to them.

Now that part is over they are slowly moving towards Bhaili and since it needs drama - they brought in Anop who is a stubborn man with his own ideas as part of Anandi's team at Bhaili - Through Bhaili they are tackling business ethics issues.

It took Anandi 3 years to come into her own after she was dumped by Jagya from a tenth pass to becoming Sarpanch

Now it is just about 2-3 years since her marriage and after moving to a new place and she had to start a new life that too from scratch.So obviously the story will move slowly,

Quote

mahi12

@mahi12

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Balika Vadhu has been raising issues and it is making viewers think about them.That is where their job should stop.They are nobody to tell us viewers what is wrong and what is right.

I don't get why people feel it is the duty of the media to tell what is wrong and what is right.It is NOT their duty.They can only point out the issues and allow the viewers to come to their own conclusion.

agree with this It is only a drama made to entertain viewers A fiction story They try to create social awareness as much as they can. Media 's job is to create social awareness rest it 's person's own belief of right and wrong how they will deal with same issues in real BV does not tell us you should exactly handle the situation how Jagya Anandi Ganga or Shiv does

Its only a serial They have to entertain viewers They are no body to tell us what is right and what is wrong I don't think anyone of us watch this show just for social message and know what is right and what is wrong ? Do we ?we watch it for entertainment so we want some entertainment Until or unless they are logical about the story ., they don't create big bloopers , don't spread some wrong information i have no issue If the MLA , collector , social worker , the nurse won't fight with goons Police will do everything then what is maza 😆And viewers attention is mostly on leads They want to see hero and heroine in action They are always center of attraction in any story Take any novel , film , drama anywhere

Coming to story of show Main story might be over Now there is no child marriage but this is a good idea to introduce short tracks in Anandi and Jagya's life relating to different issues It is nice seeing them tackling these issues with help of their respective spouses This is a better idea than generation leap

Quote

1 2 3

Balika Vadhu Written Update 30th October 2014 - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics