noone is saying jalal is right. but the point is tht he was spineless many times in front of jodha as well. whether its in TM case or in pardoning SD. why he needed to listen to jodha??? but when we said this we were told to leave the forum. anyways, if he havent talked with jodha, he havent talked with others as well. the truth is jalal & jodha r same in ruku's case whether u agree or not. if in a joint family a mother allows her child to share with others the father does the same. if jalal knows ruku appointed zeenat, jodha also knows tht same. if we talk about punishment then HB & GB also deserves it, bcoz hassan hussain were their responsibility & zeenat could have executed the same plan even if she was not a dhai. yes he was wrong is blaming jodha, but jodha was also wrong by not protesting & agreeing. if u say jodha was devastated thts why she cant react, same goes for jalal. & not talking to jodha was not a punishment for jodha he detached himself from evryone whether its HB, SB even from rahim. infact, he detached from himself. it was not for punishment but he had lost his faith. even after hasan's death jodha also detached herself from evryone. so not talking was not a punishment. yes chittor war was absolutely a crime & thts completely on his own. as per ruku goes yes he should have said ruku after hussain's death i agree but same goes for jodha. she can stop praying for 3 yrs. but cant answer ruku strictly. yes as u said 2 wrongs doesnt make one right, same goes for jodha. being pure soul cant be an excuse for evrything.
P.S.:- @ ela, did i ever said dont criticize jalal??? ur expressing ur views im doing the same. if i dont agree with any of the comments dont i have the right to write it??. or if u feel tht i should not say anything then its ok, i wont say anything.
Edited by munnirony - 11 years ago