canadianbeauty thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Hello my IF friends!
Now, I know this topic may be controversial, but I really wanted to express my thoughts. I didn't mind Sarika at first. I was totally in favor of her, and felt bad that she'd also been a victim of Param's dirty ways. However, over time, I've lost a lot of sympathy and patience for her character, partly because I don't really understand her or her motivations.

I know Romy is to blame for a lot of what's happening, BUT Sarika also has a role to play. I also don't really see her being a great Bahu for the Bhalla family. If you compare her character to Ishita, they are not very alike.

Here are the reasons for my viewpoint:

1. When the Param thing happened, instead of being a strong and assertive young woman, Sarika decided to take no action, and helped put the blame on Ishita. Yes, she was being blackmailed by Param, but I didn't see any ounce of her having any integrity in this situation. She only stood up and told the truth when Raman promised to support her.

2. She received countless warnings about Romy - from Raman and Ishita. It's not as if she was a naive and totally innocent girl being lured into his clutches. She willingly took part in everything with him. At one point, she went to farmhouse alone with him and there was a lot of drama because of this. At the farmhouse, when she was framed with Romy, she didn't take this situation as a warning that she should probably keep her distance from him and the Bhallas. She clearly knew, at this point, that no one supported her relationship with him. In fact, Raman even told her, in very clear terms.

3. She is supposed to be a strong, caring, and intelligent woman, who takes care of her mother. Then why haven't we witnessed any scenes of her being strong, or caring, or intelligent? She's come across as a hopeless fool who lands herself in compromising situations. First, she had a relationship with Param. Now, she'd had a relationship with his brother-in-law, Romy. I don't think it's wrong to assume that both of these relationships were likely intimate. Why seek relationships with two men from the same family? Does this situation not have a "red flag" all over it?

4. Mrs. Bhalla did have a point. Why has Sarika been pestering Romy about the baby so privately? If she shared such a friendship with Ishita (in fact, Ishita has even defended her on several occasions), then why didn't she tell her? Why didn't she tell someone in Romy's family? If Romy is treating her so poorly, shouldn't she confide in someone she can trust? Furthermore, if she doesn't want his family involved, then why did she send the pregnancy report to their house under the name 'S Bhalla'?

5. Why did she agree to meet Ashok? Have they even met before? If she was so private and secretive about the baby issue (she didn't even tell Ishita) then why is she so willing to meet with Ashok about it? How can he help her in a way that Raman or Ishita couldn't?

6. Her secretive nature rings alarm bells. I can't help but think she has ulterior motives. Does she want to marry Romy because of his family's, or more specifically, Raman's wealth? Is she really completely naive that easily falls for men? Is she truly pregnant? Why is she so secretive about things?

7. I haven't really found very many cool qualities in Sarika. Yes, at one point, she helped Romy and Ishita get Raman's presidentship back. But what else do we know about her? What are her amazing qualities that make us, as the audience, truly root for her?

8. Of course, what has happened to Sarika is completely WRONG. No one should trick a girl and get her pregnant, and then try to ditch her. That is 100% wrong. As someone who actually was really liking Romy's character, I can't help but feel really shocked and disappointed. However, I want MORE of a reason to root for Sarika. I don't want to think of her as a BECHAARI. I would love to see her act with some intelligence, honesty, and integrity.

What do you guys think? Am I being too harsh on Sarika? I would love to hear your thoughts.

Note: I am in NO WAY supporting what Romy did. I think that he needs to take responsibility for his actions. This post is more about my lack of liking for Sarika, as a character.
Edited by canadianbeauty - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

2k

Users

8

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

amrithas thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Sarika has never been a strong person true. However its not clear if she ever had any relationship with Param. All we know is he harassed her at work. The rest of it Sarika has to prove herself I agree. Though dont see why she should be like Ishita. She can just be a better version of herself. Frankly only one self righteous social worker bahu is more than what the Bhallas can handle. 😃
canadianbeauty thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: amrithas

Sarika has never been a strong person true. However its not clear if she ever had any relationship with Param. All we know is he harassed her at work. The rest of it Sarika has to prove herself I agree. Though dont see why she should be like Ishita. She can just be a better version of herself. Frankly only one self righteous social worker bahu is more than what the Bhallas can handle. 😃


LOL. I agree with you that one self-righteous bahu is more than enough for the Bhallas.

However, I do think Sarika and Param had a relationship when he was in Dubai or something?

Still, I have yet to see any redeeming qualities in Sarika.
-DeeNaa- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
All I can say is you spoke out my thoughts! I totally agree with everything!
canadianbeauty thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Malika-E-Zain

All I can say is you spoke out my thoughts! I totally agree with everything!


Phewww! I'm glad that there are some of us that think this - it's not just me! I was pretty sure that my view was in the minority, but I'm glad to see that you also agree.
ashat123 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
maybe sarika did not knew that param was married and have child...so maybe bcoz of that she did bcame frend first... or else..param s stll torturn sarika black mailn her wth her mother... u know how much ever we et help from frends...its likely to fall... and Yes...bhallas don need another jagaa jasoos...ones more than enough...
Lata_ishra thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I agree sarika needs to be more stronger and should take a stand for herself...i dnt she need not have to be like ishita,she can be herself and prove herself as gud bahu...she was not in any relationship with param as far as i know they have shown that param has harassed her in dubai for which he was fired from his job...coming to romi she shouldnt have believed him bcoz his own family members were telling that he will spoil her life but she took it lightly..even though after marriage she shouldnt have agreed for intimation until she is accepted as bhalla bahu...
fullhouse thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
I think CV's have really messed up this track and Romi's character... It is simply not possible that a family with values would have a son like Romi who shows such range of shades.. Sometimes they'll show that he doesn't respect women, then they will show him have true feelings for Sarika and then this track..

I think Aly should think a lot before doing any kind of script because with this track surely is doing no good to his career.. He is somewhere in between; neither good nor bad...He is portraying a very wierd kind of character who, with such kinds of tracks, at the end would gain no empathy from audience...

I was looking for a love story between Romi and Sarika but now its totally gone...
canadianbeauty thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: fullhouse

I think CV's have really messed up this track and Romi's character... It is simply not possible that a family with values would have a son like Romi who shows such range of shades.. Sometimes they'll show that he doesn't respect women, then they will show him have true feelings for Sarika and then this track..

I think Aly should think a lot before doing any kind of script because with this track surely is doing no good to his career.. He is somewhere in between; neither good nor bad...He is portraying a very wierd kind of character who, with such kinds of tracks, at the end would gain no empathy from audience...

I was looking for a love story between Romi and Sarika but now its totally gone...


I COMPLETELY agree with you! The CVs have totally and stupidly demolished Romy's character. There's a difference between being a complex person (like Raman) and being a total contradiction - like Romy has become.

Just when the audience begins to feel like they've grasped Romy as a character, the creatives do something like this and totally flip everything on its head. What a joke! Clearly Romy isn't supposed to be crazy or bipolar - so why have they totally tainted him?

I think the problem is that Aly is such a likeable person, and he comes across as a really geniuine person on screen too! As a result, the majority of YHM fans have developed a soft spot for Romy. Most of us want to root for Romy! So when the CVs do something like this track, it totally upsets and confuses the audience. How can Romy be so likeable and loveable in one moment and then a total monster the next?

I think this also may be another reason why this track, and Sarika annoy me.
sappushivu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: canadianbeauty

Hello my IF friends!

Now, I know this topic may be controversial, but I really wanted to express my thoughts. I didn't mind Sarika at first. I was totally in favor of her, and felt bad that she'd also been a victim of Param's dirty ways. However, over time, I've lost a lot of sympathy and patience for her character, partly because I don't really understand her or her motivations.

I know Romy is to blame for a lot of what's happening, BUT Sarika also has a role to play. I also don't really see her being a great Bahu for the Bhalla family. If you compare her character to Ishita, they are not very alike.

Here are the reasons for my viewpoint:

1. When the Param thing happened, instead of being a strong and assertive young woman, Sarika decided to take no action, and helped put the blame on Ishita. Yes, she was being blackmailed by Param, but I didn't see any ounce of her having any integrity in this situation. She only stood up and told the truth when Raman promised to support her.

2. She received countless warnings about Romy - from Raman and Ishita. It's not as if she was a naive and totally innocent girl being lured into his clutches. She willingly took part in everything with him. At one point, she went to farmhouse alone with him and there was a lot of drama because of this. At the farmhouse, when she was framed with Romy, she didn't take this situation as a warning that she should probably keep her distance from him and the Bhallas. She clearly knew, at this point, that no one supported her relationship with him. In fact, Raman even told her, in very clear terms.

3. She is supposed to be a strong, caring, and intelligent woman, who takes care of her mother. Then why haven't we witnessed any scenes of her being strong, or caring, or intelligent? She's come across as a hopeless fool who lands herself in compromising situations. First, she had a relationship with Param. Now, she'd had a relationship with his brother-in-law, Romy. I don't think it's wrong to assume that both of these relationships were likely intimate. Why seek relationships with two men from the same family? Does this situation not have a "red flag" all over it?

4. Mrs. Bhalla did have a point. Why has Sarika been pestering Romy about the baby so privately? If she shared such a friendship with Ishita (in fact, Ishita has even defended her on several occasions), then why didn't she tell her? Why didn't she tell someone in Romy's family? If Romy is treating her so poorly, shouldn't she confide in someone she can trust? Furthermore, if she doesn't want his family involved, then why did she send the pregnancy report to their house under the name 'S Bhalla'?

5. Why did she agree to meet Ashok? Have they even met before? If she was so private and secretive about the baby issue (she didn't even tell Ishita) then why is she so willing to meet with Ashok about it? How can he help her in a way that Raman or Ishita couldn't?

6. Her secretive nature rings alarm bells. I can't help but think she has ulterior motives. Does she want to marry Romy because of his family's, or more specifically, Raman's wealth? Is she really completely naive that easily falls for men? Is she truly pregnant? Why is she so secretive about things?

7. I haven't really found very many cool qualities in Sarika. Yes, at one point, she helped Romy and Ishita get Raman's presidentship back. But what else do we know about her? What are her amazing qualities that make us, as the audience, truly root for her?

8. Of course, what has happened to Sarika is completely WRONG. No one should trick a girl and get her pregnant, and then try to ditch her. That is 100% wrong. As someone who actually was really liking Romy's character, I can't help but feel really shocked and disappointed. However, I want MORE of a reason to root for Sarika. I don't want to think of her as a BECHAARI. I would love to see her act with some intelligence, honesty, and integrity.

What do you guys think? Am I being too harsh on Sarika? I would love to hear your thoughts.

Note: I am in NO WAY supporting what Romy did. I think that he needs to take responsibility for his actions. This post is more about my lack of liking for Sarika, as a character.



Totally agree with all your points..agreed Romi is wrong ...but what was she thnking all the time...its not that she was totally fooled by him n his family..everyone warned her...n still she went ahead with d relation..so y does she deserve any kind of sympathy..watever she did was at her own risk...no one in his family told her that they wld make her the bahu of the bhalla household...she believed Romi blindly to an extent of being phyisically intimate with him ..and now when he isnt ready to accept the kid or her..she goes around blaming the family and accusing them of using her n putting a price on her n all the crap...what ever happened to her was coz of her own stupidness..she wasnt raped or forced into this relation...she did it on her own will inspite of the warnings..and yeah..as u said..even i feel she has an ulterior motive...she willingly fell into the trap so that she cld make Romi commit to her n then get married into a rich family ...i aint liking her charachter at all.. n i don see a reason y Ishra shld support her..there is a difference between being forced n molested..and willingly sleeping with someone n getting pregnant...

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan · 11 months ago

Exclusive:; Harshad Chopda and Shivangi Joshi likely to play leads The Sony TV show produced by Balaji Telefilms has seen major developments...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".