A neutral opinion on Karishma

Ok i can see a lot of people or may be everyone here in the forum doesnt like Karishma and i understand that however i dont really dislike her nor do i like her .I dislike some of her actions but understand some other's.So just wanted to give my opinion about her which atleast i think is pretty neutral

1)Using mirchi
Ok so using mirchi was a little too much i agree

But in previous season also similar things or even worse has been used as Kamya even said last weekend.So yes it was something definitely wrong but i think it has been done in previous season as well

2)The abuse incident

Now Gautam abused her he was wrong and Karishma stood up against that she was right .Gautam did apologize but Karishma didn't feel it was genuine so didn't forgive him that is also fine.

Where she took the matter too far was when she asked for disqualification.Now the thing is in BB abusing has become very normal especially after last season its not a big deal anymore.SO asking for disqualification for something like this seemed a bit of a stretch since this has never happened before and Karishma who has seen previous seasons knew this.So why waste energy on something that not possible or wont happen.SO asking for disqualification for something like abusing which has become a pretty normal thing in BB seemed unnecessary she should have realized its never going to happen and let it go

3)Hiding her face in mirchi task

Hmm somehow i don't see how she is wrong here.A differnet opinion is welcome.

Since there are no rules this was their strategy to save themselves and win which the other team didnt use or think of so dont understand how she or her team was wrong here

The other team could have used the same strategy since there are no rules but they didn't

4)He continous targetting of gautam

Like i said she felt bad about what gautam said and doesn't want to forgive that is fine that's her decision but she should stop bringing it up in each and everything and stop blaming Gautam for everything

After all this is a game show on national television you do need some level of diplomacy to play it

5)Her attitude in yesterday's task

hmmm ok she was aggressive but so was everyone .Deepshikha hurt herself because all girls were pulling each other.She might have been slightly more aggressive but everyone was aggressive to some extent.I think this entire task should be disqualified

6)Throwing water at sonali

ok again might seem too much but worse things have been thrown at contestants

so to summarize i would say that i understand why most people don't like her but i think the major reason for that is that she lacks some level of diplomacy.Like i Said yes one needs to be herself or himself in the show and not fake but still you need some level of diplomacy or at least you should know how to put a stop to things.You cant say everything or anything that comes to your mind.Because at end of the day this is still a show and not one's own house so some level of control or thinking before doing or saying anything in the task is required

These people stay in house for 24 hours and we are shown just one hour in that so yes its very difficult to know what real dynamics in house are hence its very necessary that one keeps control on their emotions and actions to some extent atleast

Now see Gautam in this has been very smart he immediately apologized to Tanna whether he really felt sorry or not at least he said it and since then has been continuously trying to redeem himself .Now no matter what he truly feels for Tanna he is smart enough not do speak negatively about her openly.I think its smart play.To be in this game i think you need to be a mixture of both yourself and slight bit of control and diplomacy.I think Tanna should learn from this that little bit of smart play is required you cant just do or say anything that comes to your mind some bit of control is required like what Gautam is doing

I dont think Tanna is bad at heart but i think she needs to control her emotions and aggressiveness.Yes one needs to do his or her task sincerely which i think Tanna does but even in that sincerity you need some control and smartness one should let his her emotion rule his or her mind which Tanna does.I really dont have a favorite currently but i prefer gauatm,tanna,sonali to others because at least they are not scared and are behaving like their real self though Tanna needs to be more smarter in this

This is not a 'neutral' opinion.

Originally posted by: Sum-sessed

This is not a 'neutral' opinion.

that's ok i respect your opinion

its neutral as per me since i havent really hated on her nor i have i appreciated her for everything.I say its neutral because i have pointed out her flaws and somethings that are not really her flaws as per me.But your opinion is welcome as well

First of all hi sabhyata!!
Also i m sorry to say that i dnt agree that karishma is nt bad from heart!! If she had been good, she would have atleast after sat and sun episodes put all the gautam episode behind her!! But she is still stretching it and doesnt let go!!
Kal bhi she said things like gautam ko sir pe L ka board lagana chahiye and i hate him so much and blah blah when gautam hasnt done anything to deserve such words!!

Regarding the mirchi task, everyone was applying mirchi on the other team but karishma is being picked upon the most for the way she was bullying natasha in that task!! She was so loud and screaming on the poor girl who was just expressing herself by crying coz it must hurt!!

Also she didnt feel any bad for what gautam said as she was seen laughing after gautam abused!! Then she started crying foul!!

Originally posted by: mahn00r24

completely agree with u.

everyone has some positive as well as negative aspects and we really can't judge a person by watching them 1 hour daily. she stretched that gaali wala issue but what Gautam did was absolutely wrong but still ppl adore him just because they don't like Karishma or may be her over dramatic behavior in the previous task.

I prefer Gautam as well to some other contestants because atleast he realized his mistake and apologized what more can he do.He apologized alot something that previous season's contestants didnt do so yes for that i do appreciate him

But i also understand if Tanna doesn't wnat to forgive that is her choice and decision but ya she should stop dragging it.He apologized she doesn;t think its genuine and doesn't want to forgive its fine end of things no point dragging it.Like i said she needs control but i don't think she is all bad

But i guess her stretching of issues makes everything else about her also seem bad

Originally posted by: pieryrose

agree with some points.. but i'll never say she is a good contestant.. she is pure evil, aggressive, egoistic, stubborn, and disrespectful... one of the worst female contestants i have seen so far in BB... she is neither good at heart.. if she is good at heart, she would have forgiven from her heart about that incident, and started a fresh, with making the house become closer.. here she is trying to say she always right.. my dislike, have turned to hatred.. 🤢

hmm i wouldn't say she is a good contestant as well.

Like i said she lacks control,smart play,some level of diplomacy that makes a good contestant.I would say Gautam is a good contestant.He made mistake realized it and apologized has been in control since then,entertains plays smartly etc

But my point was that Karishma isn't bad contestant as well atleast for me .At lest she isnt trying to be miss goddy two shoes to save her self from nominations.Atleast she does her task sincerely and doesn't run away from it because of nominations

But ya she goes overboard in tasks that also i agree

Regarding her forgiving Gautam like i said she thinks its not genuine so doesn't want to forgive its fine its her decision but what she needs to do is stop dragging it or bringing it up in each and every conversation

First of all the mirchi thing...in last season...heaven's shit wasn't directly put on their faces...but just kept on the net holes of the box they were in...here...mirchi was directly put on their faces..in their eyes...and on top of it..this woman went on to shout on Natasha when she started crying because of it! Arrey uska kaam hai baithe rehna! Tumhare andar insaniyat bhi khatam ho gayi hai kya?? Kisi aankh mein mirchi daaloge...toh wo react bhi na kare? . and jab Inki baari aayi toh madam moon chhupaane lagi...