My Review: Seventh Episode

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Benzaiten

@Minionite

Channel Moderator

+ 43

Posted: 10 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: style14

Karan: I did not like his act. I agreed with the 2 reds given. This transitions were bad and also he looked stiff while performing. Sanam said in Xtreme reality, while dancing one should know where the poles in his props were situated without looking, Karan was constantly looking up for his props and seemed like his legs were slipping while performing. Guess he needed more practice to get the hang of it.

@ Bold: I was going to point that out after watching XR. Karan was really looking at all times where his next pole was and I guess that did take away from the act because instead of looking straight and moving smoothly parts of his moves were rough.

Quote

Benzaiten

@Minionite

Channel Moderator

+ 43

Posted: 10 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: peachesnplums
Thanks for the review Shreya, liked your take on the episode :)

I think our pet peeve, calling it Tent of Shame - was a post production after thought (a bad idea, may I add, CVs 👎🏼)

@ Bold: I guess they realized that as well and that's why it suddenly became the Mirror Room.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

with_an_idea

@with_an_idea

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

#13

Guys just wana say I'm impressed at the clarity of thought of everyone here and the fact that we're not arguing like on most other panels and threads on this forum. Keep it up and a pat on our backs for being civilised about things.👏

Quote

Benzaiten

@Minionite

Channel Moderator

+ 43

Posted: 10 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: with_an_idea
Guys just wana say I'm impressed at the clarity of thought of everyone here and the fact that we're not arguing like on most other panels and threads on this forum. Keep it up and a pat on our backs for being civilised about things.👏

Here we're all in agreement with each other over most things and that's why there is no arguments. 😊

Quote

with_an_idea

@with_an_idea

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

#15

^^ That could be true coz everyone's agreed on Shantani being a lousy contestant, but everyone has a slightly different take on the other performances. So far no ones jumping down others throats for pointing out mistakes of their favs.

Quote

Benzaiten

@Minionite

Channel Moderator

+ 43

Posted: 10 years ago

#16

^ But even then most of our opinions don't vary as much as they would usually. We all usually do agree for example that one contestant performed well or another contestant deserved this red card. The variance lies in the extremes. For example I might think Karan didn't deserve 2 red cards, but you think he did. We both agree that his performance wasn't good or there was something missing, but we vary there. Same with who we think deserves best performer of the week or other such stuff. I might say Amar was better than Rithvik this week, whereas you might say Rithvik was better than Amar. At the end of it all we both are agreeing that both were good.

Also I think it has to do with everyone in the forum as well. If in the beginning we had all decided to remain divided in our groups then the fights were bound to happen, but even though we have separate ATs we comment on each other's topics and it creates a healthy discussion.

Quote

nature-beauty

@nature-beauty

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#17

nice review

and now here is my take

well i will start with Kunwar as he is my favourite

man mark my words u were outstanding, every pose of yours was just outstanding and brilliant.The way u were smiling throughout the act it made me melt like ice.The last part where u were given a dare by Akshay and u accepted it that is more commendable.you definitely deserved two Greens and that too haq se.

one thing which made me disappointed was why didnt Akshay say AK IS OK for Kunwar.

well this doesn't matter as long as he and his fans and the lovers of Dance like the performance infact it matters the least.

but sometimes such small things kind of motivate the contestants which this tym is not done by Akshay for Kunwar.

I'm really upset about it with Akshay this time.

Emili- girl u r one of the strongest contender for all the boys out there.It was fab this was my second fav performance.

Rithvik- being a non dancer his aerial act was really very good and he deserved 2 greens for his attempt with the prop.well done.keep up the spirit.

Sayantani- ab inke baarein main kya batao i dont want to waste much of my time she defnitely deserved 2 reds pata nahin phirse ek green mila.this i didnt like at all.

here i want specially mention that always sayantani keeps criticizing kunwar but this time he said about sayantani which i dont know y but i kind of agree with it.i was upset when she said that Kunwar is confused between being an actor or dancer. now it proved that he a dancer and an actor too. I hope she got a reality check this time.no harsh feelings for sayantani but her behaviour made me to write all these for her.

Karan - well it was quite nice but it was looking a bit clumsy and also he was offbeat sometimes but he deserved one green atleast. All the best for ur future acts Karan.

so for me Kunwar was the best performer and Emilie was the second best in the episode.

Quote

with_an_idea

@with_an_idea

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: KhotaSikaShreya
^ But even then most of our opinions don't vary as much as they would usually. We all usually do agree for example that one contestant performed well or another contestant deserved this red card. The variance lies in the extremes. For example I might think Karan didn't deserve 2 red cards, but you think he did. We both agree that his performance wasn't good or there was something missing, but we vary there. Same with who we think deserves best performer of the week or other such stuff. I might say Amar was better than Rithvik this week, whereas you might say Rithvik was better than Amar. At the end of it all we both are agreeing that both were good.

Also I think it has to do with everyone in the forum as well. If in the beginning we had all decided to remain divided in our groups then the fights were bound to happen, but even though we have separate ATs we comment on each other's topics and it creates a healthy discussion.

Have you usually seen JDJ or other reality show threads? They're beserk, no point of even trying to write something.

Quote

Benzaiten

@Minionite

Channel Moderator

+ 43

Posted: 10 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: with_an_idea
Have you usually seen JDJ or other reality show threads? They're beserk, no point of even trying to write something.

Yep I have. That's why I make a point to usually stay out of reality show forums. I'm still wondering how I joined this one. 😆