Most faithfull movie?

Poll

Which film is the most faithfull to its source book ?

Login To Vote

CoerCorash

@CoerCorash

Inactive

6

Posted: 10 years ago

#1

I think first & last two films (DH Part 1&2) were faithfull to book.

Edited by CoerCorash - 10 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

983175

Suspended

Posted: 10 years ago

#2

Originally posted by: CoerCorash
I think first & last two films (DH Part 1&2) were faithfull to book.

My thoughts precisely.. I too think the first & last two movies were the most faithful ones to the book..

(Half blood prince was the least faithful in my opinion..)

Reply

Quote

Avie

@Avie

Dazzler

21

Posted: 10 years ago

#3

First and Second definitely..

Order of the Phoenix was miles away from the book.. And that actually was my favourite book..

2

Reply

Quote

CoerCorash

@CoerCorash

Inactive

6

Posted: 10 years ago

#4

HBP looks like a fill up. Till than Last book was released so they knew everything needed in terms of story. But what the makers did was they took out action made it a black & white movie. Almost every scene was dark.

2

Reply

Quote

Avie

@Avie

Dazzler

21

Posted: 10 years ago

#5

Originally posted by: CoerCorash
HBP looks like a fill up. Till than Last book was released so they knew everything needed in terms of story. But what the makers did was they took out action made it a black & white movie. Almost every scene was dark.

Well thats because a greater part of the book had Voldemort's childhood described which shown in black and white made sense.. But why include scenes you don't need.. The attack on the Burrow.. Not needed at all.. And why didn't the death eaters kill them.. Instead they choose to burn the house.. Much of the originality was lost shooting this..

1

Reply

Quote

983175

Suspended

Posted: 10 years ago

#6

Originally posted by: pinks2911

Well thats because a greater part of the book had Voldemort's childhood described which shown in black and white made sense.. But why include scenes you don't need.. The attack on the Burrow.. Not needed at all.. And why didn't the death eaters kill them.. Instead they choose to burn the house.. Much of the originality was lost shooting this..

Yup..and i was not happy with HBP film..😔

1

Reply

Quote

Avie

@Avie

Dazzler

21

Posted: 10 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: Quixotic5

Yup..and i was not happy with HBP film..😔

I too wasn't.. They could have showed what actually was in the book.. And it would have done well..Rather they showed what wasn't.. 😕

1

Reply

Quote

Avie

@Avie

Dazzler

21

Posted: 10 years ago

#8

Originally posted by: CoerCorash
Yeah that was stupid.

Totally😕

1

Reply

Quote

later ;)

@QuietlyLoud

Voyager

19

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#9

It's Chamber of Secrets,according to me. Less scenes were omitted and least deviated from the book

First two movies are the most faithful ones because those books were only half the size of other books in the series so they were easily adapted into movies.

1

Reply

Quote

CoerCorash

@CoerCorash

Inactive

6

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

It all started with Prisonar of Azkaban. It ommitted a lot of stuff.It's Never told in the movie that james potter was animagus and many more things. It actually became a plothole.

Reply

Quote

Most faithfull movie?

Poll

Related Topics

Explore Topics