coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
I have often noted in this forum that, any body who criticizes an actor's acting or a character, sometimes the line between criticism and bashing becomes invisible and even the good criticism gets shoved under all the angry fan comments and finally the topic has to be closed. Recently, on one of the topics of Roohani, something similar happened, I am not defending anyone, all I am suggesting is, how much ever big a fan of an actor you are, how can you overlook there low points? Even SRK, AB are great actors, they all have weak moments in their career when they get criticised, so who blames the film or film producer? all the criticism goes to the actor. Hiten is a great actor, he is marvellous in his roles, but sometimes, he becomes monotonous in his acting to, who is to blame? Ekta? no, definitely not. Its upto the actor to bring out all there is to the role. It is only human to rise and fall. Why do you great fans, get onto bashing and vehemently denying any sort of criticism if its for one of the good characters, while the criticism pours out leaps and bounds for the bad characters?? Why doesnt someone praise there great acting in a negative role? they act so well, to make us fans hate them..everyone is a good actor, no one is bad, and so is criticism. Criticism is a must for any profession, you just have to take it in the right and positive way. So, great fans of Hiten, Gauri and all the great actors, next time someone has a post criticising someone's acting or a role, please think once before you break the hell loose on them. Its not their intense to hurt us fans, its a point, which can either be duely noted or duely argued, in a rather polite manner, than be outrightly rude and deny any such thing.

My point : Don't be a blind fan, be a wise one.

Disclaimer : Just to be on the safe side, I am not claiming anyone is unwise/blind or otherwise. (Man, I have to take so much precaution)!!

I am sure of one thing, even if someone understands this post of not, people will bash me on this, all the same! So before all hell breaks loose on my head, I am sorry to who ever I have hurt! But I am only using my freedom of speech!

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

590

Users

2

Frequent Posters

adeela thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

i totally disagree with you.its not necessary every body's opnion is same if some people think or criticize hiten or gauri's acting ability its not necessary every member of this forum or every person of this world agree with their opnion.and i have notice so many times when anybody create topic against hiten or gauri and when their lovers including me defend them or said we are not agree with your opnion then they said to us you are biased ght fans are biased.its not right.and as you gave examples of sharukh and amitabh may be when their films are flop some people critize their actig but not every one because some peeple said its not their fault its film makers fault. for example shahrukh's actindg in dilse ,and ram jane both the films are flop but people appreciate his acting and another example amitab's nisahbad critics like his acting but the film is flop.

and i cant understand why you all forcing and pushing to all ght lovers you dont defend or support them .why not we defend them we all see with our eyes we all think with our brain and its not necessary eveybody's point of view is same because as i said eveybody's sees with his or her own eyes every one think with his or her brain.

Edited by adeela - 18 years ago
coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: adeela

i totally disagree with you.its not necessary every body's opnion is same if some people think or criticize hiten or gauri's acting ability its not necessary every member of this forum or every person of this world agree with their opnion.and i have notice so many times when anybody create topic against hiten or gauri and when their lovers including me defend them or said we are not agree with your opnion then they said to us you are biased ght fans are biased.its not right.and as you gave examples of sharukh and amitabh may be when their films are flop some people critize their actig but not every one because some peeple said its not their fault its film makers fault. for example shahrukh's actindg in dilse ,and ram jane both the films are flop but people appreciate his acting and another example amitab's nisahbad critics like his acting but the film is flop.

and i cant understand why you all forcing and pushing to all ght lovers you dont defend or support them .why not we defend them we all see with our eyes we all think with our brain and its not necessary eveybody's point of view is same because as i said eveybody's sees with his or her own eyes every one think with his or her brain.



Adeela, I completely understand what you mean. GHT fans should and will always defend the actors, I am not saying not to that. But its only human to make mistakes right?? No one is perfect hun. Thats all I meant, I dont mean you shouldnt defend GHT, just that may be if sometimes, they dont potray their best, the GHT fans or any fan., can and should try to take tht perspective too..you completely lost my point friend, i by no means said you should not or any fan shouldnt defend their fav actors.😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".