JOLLY is a better singer than ALISHA - Page 3

May be because Alisha still can't connect to Jolly and think it is unfair to other contestants. Those who think that Jolly sings better than Alisha should listen to Jolly's previous performances. Do we always support the one who sings best or do we have other yardsticks too? I think we do😃 and that's why even after singing bad some contestants still have supporters.

We here seem to get carried away with just one good rendition. Just one song doesn't matter. Let us wait and hear her for some more galas and may be by then Alisha will get comfortable with Jolly.

alisha is a grear singer...but like everyone else said she had no judging sense at all...which is getting on my nerves now...she comments on peoplez singing based on how much she can connect with them and how much she likes them and also based on their looks 😡

well alisha is ok i guess. not that great. but atleast shez a singer and has some idea about singing unlike farah khan. not that i don't like farah khan. its just that......i don't think being a coriographer farah khan was a fit to be a II judge. because II is a singing compitition , not dancing.
this year they did a good job chosing all singing related ppl to be judges. i personally think javed akhtar is the most honest judge this time in II3.

😆

Actually I liked Farah Khan better than Alisha Chinoy 😃 (I know this isn't what the thread is about).

She looked at a different aspect of the contestant's performance which is required in Indian Idol, and didn't claim to look at any other aspect either.

She looked for "Gaana dil ko nahi chuwa" or performance "ankh band karke diya" and she would say that.

Alisha looks for "Make up acha nahi kiya" or "Dress needs one more rhinestone" but says "Sur was messed up" 😕