Is it fair to add two new participants

Page

Rani

@April2007

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

I don't think it is fair to add two new participants at this stage of SRGMA. It just shows that unfairness is part of most of the stuff that comes out of India.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Mia1love

@Mia1love

Rocker

Posted: 18 years ago

NO .. i think it is Fair to have ANeet and Abhijit in there. IF Mauli is inthere.. they have all the rights.. They are far better singer and have talent.. sooo why not..

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Minali The Great

@Guardian Angel

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

No I donot agree with this at all. They should have come at the beginning like Amanat did. Amanat is also a winner from Dubai. This is unfair to the contestents!!

Quote

mittijalebi

@mittijalebi

Rocker

Posted: 18 years ago

of course its not fair! they should've come at the beginning of the show not in between when most of the singers have been kicked out, so less competition for them. its dumb how they did it.

Quote

Anisha

@Cuhrazy.Anisha

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

its out rightly UNFAIR they shouldve gt direct entry in d show in d initial stages without audition like shekhar n ID sd dat would have been still reasonable fr us ...but bringing thm in at this pnt of time is totally unfair

Quote

Krishna

@snowflake0555

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 18 years ago

No it's totally unfair to all the contestants who made it into Agnipariksha. (not the onces who got the green light by 1/2 performences but like Amanat, Junaid, etc had to struggle to get this far) They should have come at the way beginning.

Edited by snowflake0555 - 18 years ago

Quote

@mermaid_QT

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

😳 why not? they are not declared winners right? Contestants who kicked out previous contestants can kick these two out as well.. These two will proceed only if they perform better than the current.. That would clearly mean they are superior to the dejected contestants.

(i am gladly kepping mauli out of thought and sight while discussing fairness here.. with her still in, nothing seems fair anyway)

Quote

vichanakya

@vichanakya

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Please bear it in mind that these two contestants are winners in Marathi and Bengali and they too have gone through all the rigmarole and come out on the top! One other thing, why do you think Marathi, Bengali or for that matter music and musicians in other Indian languages are second rate? Is hindi film music the be all and end all of Indian music? Don't you like S P Balasubramaniam, or yesudas or Chitra who have sung hindi songs as good as anybody. Did'nt you like karunya of hyderabad the famous II 2 contestant?

Quote

@mermaid_QT

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: vichanakya
Please bear it in mind that these two contestants are winners in Marathi and Bengali and they too have gone through all the rigmarole and come out on the top! One other thing, why do you think Marathi, Bengali or for that matter music and musicians in other Indian languages are second rate? Is hindi film music the be all and end all of Indian music? Don't you like S P Balasubramaniam, or yesudas or Chitra who have sung hindi songs as good as anybody. Did'nt you like karunya of hyderabad the famous II 2 contestant?

Did anyone even remotely say/ imply that in bold?? Few people are upset for losing several talented singers like Richa and Sikander while adding new contestants at an advanced step in the game. This discussion is about whether any newcomers should be added. Nobody is ridiculing / under-rating them for being regional candidates. Let us please focus on what the original poster asked. We had this discussion earlier when ekalavya candidates were added as well. That way, we can avoid controversies😳. Enjoy!
mQT

Edited by mermaid_QT - 18 years ago

Quote

Is it fair to add two new participants

Related Topics

Explore Topics