Yeh Hosla- Prashant or Amanat ?

Prashant was awesome today 👏 , but I think Amanat (Saregamapa)was better 👏👏👏

. What do you guys think ?Not comparing both (Amanat is trained and Prashant is natural, both are good), only want to know whose rendition of this song did you liked the most?

prashant was better..i admire him for singing..he was much worried abt his accent while singing..he did great..and voice quality was greatttttttttt. he is not classical trained singer..so what...amit, chang arent classical singer aswell...we heard tuff anuji saying u will come in top 3..without some quality he might not have said that..he could have said that to everyone out there but why he..he is natural...saadgi is always perfect..

prashant was great for someone with practically no training 👏 but i liked amanats more 😛

i liked both but amanat ali from srgmp a tee bit better,but both rockeddd

prashant rocked and love his smile 😉

I admire Prashant and his singing ALOT! he'z one of the bests,according to me. but today he was hesitating too much. I didnt liek his todayz singing tht much & compared to Amanat...Amanat was btr.

don't compare them i mean amanat is a trained singer .. he sings much much better than prashant and his yeh honsla was better too 😊

Originally posted by: bhavinfan12

i like prashant but there is no comparision here. original was 100 times better.

i think here they are talking about amanat ali from SRGMP not shafqat amanat ali khan the original singer.

...i thought amanat was better. that may be due to his ease with pronounciation?! prashant seems to struggle with that😛

amanat has more sur (trained singer) but prashant's voice is much better.. 50/50

For me, Prashant sang the song much better than Amanat. He's the next Indian Idol.