Javed vs Alisha/ Anu....Real or farce

Javed Akhtar is known as an intelligent, thinking litereteur who has sensitivity. But on II3, when it comes to Suhit, he is acting totally different to his perceived image. He is subjective, vitriolic, demeaning. So. is it that Javed Akhtar genuinely feels the way he is expressing or is it a farce, sponsored by SONY to stir up a controversy. Consider following facts:

1.All other 3 judges arn't agreeing with Javed Akhtar in Suhit's case.

2. Javed Akhtar is questioning Suhit's Sur, when singer and music composer judges find little or no fault there.

3. Javed Akhtar is even questioning intelligence of public voting for Suhit. Thus he is becoming one man army against public+all judges just in case of Suhit.

4. In yesterday's episode, Anu Malik asked Suhit to sing the Antara again. Javed Akhtar could find no fault with Suhit's sur at all. This portion was edited by the channel.(Have got this info from someone present in the studios-am so sure abt it that i wud like to challenge anybody to contradict it).

👏 javed ji spoke his mind out..hes not the only one who finds suhit besura..or questions the publics intelligence for bringing him back..there r many others who do 😊

Anybody who knows little about music will find him off-sur and off-key.Today also behcara orchestra was running behind him...
Javed is more staright-forward coz he doesnt want another qazi.

Udit cannot speak..he wud say yes or not to what alisha or anu says..

anu is scared to go against alisha once more..

alisha cant let go off suhit..

javed is left aside..so he speaks his mind freely

Suhit did go out of sur and JAs comments were for his first performance.....maybe second time he did't go out of sur...
just becos majority agrees on something it doesn't mean they are right...but i think JA was little harsh when he said Suhit can never sing...

Alisha is mad but Javed Jee is OK he know how to judge even he sits wth Alisha the old lady

Alisha hasnt given any sane comment as yet. In Suhit's own case, on friday, she says his performance is fabulous and on saturday, she says janta saved him despite giving a weak performance.... this, imagine, she is saying for her favourite contestant, imagine what she would do for others.

Udit - wonder what image he is living upto... when he speaks, the pearls of wisdom which fall are too much for us to bear...

Annu has been mostly good, everyone is entitled to a bad hair day 😉 he has been entertaining, he has been mostly truthful, he is biased (which seems to be the order for most judges this year), but not as bad as others... so its more a case of "a shade better than another, therefore slightly better"...

Javed Saab has by and far been the best... conducted himself with great dignity and spoken the truth... Everyones been asking why is he so harsh on Suhit, is it Channel sponsored?... Maybe .. May not be.. But I feel the harshness is accentuated becuase of the frustrations of sitting with co judges whose thoughts seem diametrically opposite to his. If a line is off sur, it is off sur, it really matters not who is the name or face behind the voice... but here, some faces get away with off sur, while others pay the price of poor popularity.

i still remember wen none of da judges didnt like shifa's sinigng it was only anu who didnt find any fault frm shifa's singing.. nd dat time in dis forum evry body was in Anu's side 😕 😆

Originally posted by: s.priya

Udit - wonder what image he is living upto... when he speaks, the pearls of wisdom which fall are too much for us to bear...

🤣🤣🤣

Priceless!

Originally posted by: s.priya

Annu has been mostly good, everyone is entitled to a bad hair day 😉 he has been entertaining, he has been mostly truthful

😆

I presume you have a soft corner for Anu ji?

Anyways, for me, Javed Saheb is the only authentic judge on II 3. Anu has his plus points when compared to 'madly-in-love-with-suhit' Alisha or 'I-dont-have-a-back-bone' Udit ji but he tends to go overboard with his opinions, likes and dislikes where as Javed Ji never fails to voice the truth i.e. , in this case, 'the Besura pan of suhit'. I'm with Javed Sir on this one.

Javed saab has always been quite honest in his appraisals even when he was a judge in Fame Gurukul... I guess thats why he was made a judge in II3...for the frankness