Unresolved Issues in Mahabharat: Some things, we will never know

amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Mahabharat is one great epic, that was probably written 5000 years ago. Ever since, it's birth, it has undergone several modifications and transitions. Many things have been interpolated into it, many things have been altered. Today, after 5000 years, it stands as a long, modified, poem, hiding within its bosom, thousands of ancient secrets and puzzles, most of which will never be solved.

Mahabharat, is one long poem, built on many, many stories, intricately connected to one another, with thousands of symbolic representations, controversial events, anomalies, thus giving us an insight to our civilization, thousands of years ago. The most intriguing part of this epic, is that, every character, every event, and every situation can be seen from various perspectives. This enigmatic nature of this epic lends to it a mysterious appeal, thus making it even more beautiful.

Yet, this enigmatic nature has also given way to various arguments, debates, controversies, which have been going on, for some centuries or more now, without arriving at any conclusion.

Who was the greater warrior? Karna or Arjun.

Who was Arjun's most favourite wife?

Did the Pandavas, Draupadi, Kauravas really exist, or are they simply creations of Ved Vyas?

Was Lord Krishna a strategist or God Incarnate?

Was Duryodhan really that bad?

Were the Panadavs, Draupadi and Karna really children of Gods?

Did the war really take place?

Was Abhimanyu really 16 years old?

There are many, many more questions, which are yet to be answered.

Well, the first question is probably the most explosive topic, about Mahabharat, and many , many debates have been fought on this issue. Yet this remains unresolved.

Or, may be that's what Ved Vyas wanted too.

Ved Vyas, being the genius, that he was, had cleverly balanced the victories and defeats of these two heroes...So, that no one can ever find out for sure, who was the greater one, or so is my understanding.

We, may argue, with as much force, as we want, trying to prove that our favourite is the better one, yet we will never get clarity. This debate will go on for an eternity, yet we will never know the truth.

So, I guess, it is easier as well as politically correct, to accept that both were great in their own ways. Equally.

For the last couple of decades, or centuries for that matter, many scholars have evolved, trying to solve some of these puzzles. Yet, all of these questions remain unanswered...

We take birth, grow up, learn about Mahabharat, debate on our favourite characters, and gradually perish...

And yet, these questions remain unanswered...We go on arguing, and arguing, and yet, the truth remains hidden.

And gradually with the passage of time, some more false facts, start clinging to the existing facts of the epic, and gradually become part of people's common perception of the epic...

E.g. Andha Ka Putra Andha comment...

This cycle has been going on for thousands of years now, thus covering in the process, the actual truth, under layers and layers of distortions...

What is this story actually about?

Yes, it is the story of 2 sets of cousins fighting over land...

It is the story of a woman, who faced immense pain and insult, for being bold and beautiful...

It is the story of an abandoned child, fighting his way through the harshness of the society...

It is also a story of God, coming down on earth to teach humans, the greatest lessons of our life

Today, Mahabharat is at a certain stage, that it is difficult to identify, what is true, and what is not. And the distortions have blurred the story to such an extent, that all this boils down to one question:

Did Mahabhrat really happen?

We may see this whole story, in whichever way we want to...We may see the whole scenario through the eyes of whichever character we feel like...

But the secrets remain hidden, and they remain so, somewhere, between the lines...

Then what are the answers to those questions? And what is the truth?

The truth is, "We don't know the truth."

Amrita
Thought of writing on something, and came up, with this abstract piece. Sorry, if it was too abstract.
Hope, u all will like it, and please, no arguments on controversial topics.
Edited by amritat - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

13.3k

Users

17

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Thanks...😊
997935 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
All I can say is MB is such a brilliant piece of literature that we are still debating over it...😊
bheegi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
I agree with Bharti

As they say- ismein kuch tho bast hai, air jo ismein nahin wo kahin nahin

Even after 5000 years, we're all ready to debate, discuss and fight about the various tracks, characters and messages imparted by this great epic

All I can say is Ved Vyas and his other co poets who've contributed were geniuses and great visionaries...people like them are only born once in 5000 years.

Very few stories can boast of characters that can both be seen as heroes and anti heroes depending on the perspective...at least I've never read any story like that.
Edited by bheegi - 11 years ago
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Brilliant post Amrita!! 👏

I've always regarded Vyasa to be the greatest story-teller of all time (even if MB is a poem).

The fact that his work sparks off so many vibrant discussions even 5000 years after it was first written, only speaks volumes of the complexity of the MB.

Oh...and IMHO Ganapati bappa needs to be acknowledged too...😊
riti4u thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Nice post Amrita 😊

Mahabharat is really captivating work ..whether fiction or not.. but it certainly has so many hidden things to be explored , debated and researched. There are learnings which are useful in present context of society.. Isnt it really strange that 5000 years ago the problems existing in society...common emotional bondages existing in humans still exist as much as then... Pick up any story from vast reserve of Mahabharat...You will find a reference in modern age ..
Yes there are some questions which are unanswered... Some ifs and buts... Some what if this would have happened or not... who is greater and who is not... I believe Mahabharat is more than these unanswered questions.. as it gives answers to many unasked questions as well...if we just figure out the right questions..😊
Edited by riti4u - 11 years ago
cherryberry293 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Good post Amrita. Even I always some of the questions related to this epic.
Regarding the Pandavas, Kauravas and whole story as creation... there are evidences available which state it isn't a fiction. And even if I consider it as a fiction, then its the best fiction story ever written in the history of mankind.

Well to add in above list, I have 2 questions:

Was there any need to hide Karna's true identity from Pandavas? Would it have been really affected adversly to Arjuna's bravery??

I don't think so... if they fought against Bheeshma and Dron who were their idols and Pandavas worshiped them... then I am sure Karna's truth would have made any difference... As this war was above personal revenges... it was for Dharma... and all those who failed with Dharmas got punished.

MS-meghasharma thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
superb post
mb has been written like a thriller by ved vyas where he i suppose on purpose left some things like an open ending type,ppl can conclude from that what they want to. he has refrained himself from answering all such trick questions
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: -bharti

All I can say is MB is such a brilliant piece of literature that we are still debating over it...😊

Yes, indeed Mahabharat is the work of a genius...
Thanks for commenting. 😊
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: bheegi

I agree with Bharti


As they say- ismein kuch tho bast hai, air jo ismein nahin wo kahin nahin

Even after 5000 years, we're all ready to debate, discuss and fight about the various tracks, characters and messages imparted by this great epic

All I can say is Ved Vyas and his other co poets who've contributed were geniuses and great visionaries...people like them are only born once in 5000 years.

Very few stories can boast of characters that can both be seen as heroes and anti heroes depending on the perspective...at least I've never read any story like that.

Yes, Bheegi...Ved Vyas was a genius...
Even after so many years, we would do anything to prove our favourite is the best...
Like I do with Draupadi...😉
Did she really exist? If she did, then is she hearing me from heaven? Maybe she is.
I hope she is. 😊
We all get attached to some character, or the other, personally.
And that is how, Mahabharat remains, the greatest epic in the world. Even today. 👏
Thanks for commenting. 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".