ALISHA - Partial Judge - Page 2

alisha ka dimaag aaadha hi hai....toh partial hi hogi na... 😕 😡 i wish she gets replaced with farah

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU. I HAVE NO RESPECT LEFT FOR HER. THE JOB OF A JUDGE IS TO BE IMPARTIAL. She is not fit for the job at all.

Originally posted by: amiyas

Alisha is absolutely disappointing. I dont understand her leaning towards Suhit. This guy has only attitude and ZERO ability to sing., Still for Alisha he is "THE HEAVY METAL ROCKER". The guy cant sing to save his life and b'coz of him good singers have been evicted. Prashant sang so well and still Aisha felt that Prashant sang the weakest whereas Suhit's singing awas atrocious that day. I fail to understand what is Alish's agenda here. I feel that she is too enamoured by atttude,social standing, and looks. She has been contantly targeting contestents who are weak on the above counts, i.e. Smita, Prashant Rehan.An advice for Alisha - GROW UP - there is more to life than just outward appearance and materiality. STOP being a "MATERIAL GIRL".

Alisha never complimented Suhit on his singing...in fact she has crticized him.
Shes a good judge as in her judgments but she is biased. thats all. 😛

I feel that she is too enamoured by atttude,social standing, and looks. She has been contantly targeting contestents who are weak on the above counts, i.e. Smita, Prashant Rehan.
An advice for Alisha - GROW UP - there is more to life than just outward appearance and materiality. STOP being a "MATERIAL GIRL".


this is my first reply to any post concerning indian idol, & m 100% agree with Amiyas.. she's so biased in every statement she made, I think they should replace her with someone who's objective in his/her judgement.

well, i like her....but u have to hand it to her...she stands by her opinions, no matter how much everyone else doesn't like them!

I agree with the observation - Alisha seems to have this focus on looks - Suhit is not a singer and always choosing him above other singers does cause the real talent to wonder - Are you really looking for Singers or not? These people have been given the honor of being the Judge and they should be able to recognize the "singing talent". I feel the other three judges are doing better job than Alisha Chenai..

We all have already seen what happens to these idols in a year or so. They disappear in thin air - as fast as they appear...I bet no one heard of Sandeep (Indian Idol II) besides hearing the snippets on Sony TV.

In Indian Idol we should be looking for someone who can carry on for long after getting this initial push - someone like Shreya Ghoshal - all the other reality contest winners are like "do din to chandni phir andheri raat".... You will get quality talent only when you thrive for talent or encourage talent...