Samir or Purab?

Page

antusang

@antusang

Inactive

Posted: 21 years ago

Hey guys... this has been on my mind for a while.... do we love purab or samir? cos I wonder if samir was'nt playing this role would any of us care who jassi ends up or does'nt end up with?? According to the original script BLF purab's role is'nt of much significance....if that be the case...then the directors have certainly goofed up here..they should have chosen someone less charismatic than samir for this role....purab or should I say samir has completely overshadowed the main male lead and now the directors have to alter the script...and the viewers are with samir! given this scenario...can we expect a different ending?
the directors do have an option of casting someone else as purab if they want to stick to the original story line!!! some food for thought is'nt it?
and for those of you who don't think much of samir soni....please excuse...

Quote

Frequent Posters

current

@current

Rocker

Posted: 21 years ago

I think Samir Soni was a virtual unknown before Purab but I think this role has become synonmous with him and has given his career a new lease of life.Right now difficult to say where Samir ends and Purab begins!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

manimau

@manimau

Navigator

Posted: 21 years ago

I would still go for Purab, even if it's not played by Samir. Because it's his character that has given Jassi the confidence she needed and loved her unconditionally. It's only about this show... and we all know that all the actors from this show are far different in life than the characters that they portray on the show.

May be the character would have been weaker/stronger if it was portrayed by someone else... But still it's characteristics would have been the same most probably.

Manimau

Quote

current

@current

Rocker

Posted: 21 years ago

BTW Samir is more endearing in Jassi as purab than as sheker in saakhi

Quote

antusang

@antusang

Inactive

Posted: 21 years ago

talking of samir in saakshi...I did get the feel that folks would rather have him in the neagtive role rather than not having him in the show!!!
I wonder what is it about him?? that women cutting across all age groups have started to miss their heartbeats!!! Iam sure its a little over the top but it is a fact that samir is having a huge female fan following!!!

Quote

pj04

@pj04

Inactive

Posted: 21 years ago

hi,

there something very soulful, dignified ,peaceful, reserved , charismatic and strangely sad about him. it is a rare combination and seems to drive women nuts. add purab's role to it and the impact is multiplied manyfolds.

Quote

*Anjali*

@*Anjali*

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 21 years ago

very true pj. Welcome to the forum!!!!

Quote

surnita

@surnita

Inactive

Posted: 21 years ago

😉🤢In my opinion there is something very creepy and scary about him, I just dont get this craze at all. Mind you there are still girls out there who fancy Micheal Jackson🤢

Quote

current

@current

Rocker

Posted: 21 years ago

Originally posted by: surnita

😉🤢In my opinion there is something very creepy and scary about him, I just dont get this craze at all. Mind you there are still girls out there who fancy Micheal Jackson🤢

and for some strange reason Armaan🤢 as well🤢