Why are we getting so hyper with Bani?

majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Over the weekend there has been a fair bit of criticism against Bani for agreeing to marry Adbhoot. Now I am not defending her decision to marry Adbhoot. In my opinion that decision is neither right nor wrong, just her prerogative as a woman to chose her own life. But the reasons for which she has decided to consent to the marriage is completely WRONG.

Let us look at things from Bani's POV, her own sister and her own hubby conspired to put her behind bars. Her loved ones, Rano, Maasi, Dadi, Adi all abandoned her to her fate. Five years she is back and no one has expressed any sorrow for her sufferings, no one has even bothered asking her how she has lived all these years, her tormentor Pia is enjoying the pleasures of life. So what conclusion can she draw? And if she looks elsewhere for support, how's she to blame?

Yes, there is a reason behind her loved one's behaviour (although many would disagree) but no one has bothered conveying that to her, but is Bani to blame for that? Agreed both JB are being watched and it is difficult for them to have a tete-a-tete and even if they do Bani may choose not to believe JW and I won't blame her if she doesn't. But what about the others- Rano, Adi, Dadi can't they just slip out to meet her at Bhoot Bangla or assuming that they can't meet her there wait for her in ambush outside Bangla,stalk her maybe and speak to her in an unguarded moment. Surely they have the resources to do that. So if they have failed, is Bani wrong in believing that she has been abandoned by her own? If that is the case, what is wrong if she wants to move on? Why are we expecting her to remain faithful to her marriage when her hubby has just handed her a card proclaiming his marriage to her tormentor? Just because we love RK-PD chemistry is that it? Don't get me worng, I will always be a JB despo but it is JW (or his family) who has to make the first move now. And the good thing is now that the head of JB despos (Raashi) is back in WM, things may just start happening.

Another argument that has been made is that she will lose the children. That is no argument at all. When did she make the decision to marry AD? AFTER JW handed a card proclaiming the JP marriage. Now (from Bani's POV) if both JW and Bani are married to different persons, how is Bani's right to children any less than JW? Yes it wud be a diff issue if she was married but JW not. But from her POV she wud be marrying only after JP do.

Besides the issue is legally she is DDG now, not Bani and whether JP are married or not and whether AB are not, she is a non-entity legally as far as the children are concerned. She has no access to the kids, till she is Bani Walia, not DDG and if she is BW she is immediately behind bars. So the real issue now is proving BW innocent, not of expediting or preventing either AB/JW-DDGmarriage.

Now finally coming back to the decision. Yes, Bani needs to know the truth b4 making her decision but if she does not know the truth that is not HER fault. And hence she has the right to make her decision based on the best available info. And we can't criticise her for marrying Adbhoot. But yes her decision to marry AD is for all the wrong reasons. She is marrying him for staisfying the whims and fancies of the Moti Mom. It is ridiculous for a woman who has behind her one messed up marriage ( a marriage which she entered into for a wrong reasons) to enter into another marriage again for a wrong reason.

Rgds,

Priyanka

Created

Last reply

Replies

70

Views

3.2k

Users

17

Frequent Posters

ovaltine thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Pri
thank you for this wonderful post. Couldn't agree more. Just a question, has Pia tapped all the phone lines too, mobile and land lines? She really knows the power of money 😉 .
I want her to marry whomever she chooses but this time for the right reasons.
majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Oval,

(I want her to marry whomever she chooses but this time for the right reasons. )

And whoever marries her, should tell her the whole TRUTH. And in turn she too shud be truthful:

What are her real feelings towards JW (shud she marry someone else)?
Whether she wud continue to give more importance to BJBB activities or to her married life?

Rgds,

Prri
InduD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

I agree with you dear…she has all reasons to move on…But as you said, it is her reasons to get married to AD that is not right and she is totally wrong in making such a decision. That is what we are all against; at least that is what I am against.

Of all ppl why AD? She knows that he has some past but she does not know what exactly it is. She knows that she wants her children but she cant get them unless she is gonna be with JW or prove herself innocent, so instead of trying to get her children back which is her only desires in life and her only reason to live all these days, she decided to marry AD – for what?…again and again she is making the same old mistake – Live for other and not think about herself. She took that decision in anger for JW not out of love for AD, she took the decision to satisfy AD's MIL not to mend HER life and live it…That is what bothers me a lot. That is why we are hyper over her.😆😆

Edited by Je_aime - 18 years ago
aashyagh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
Pri, good thoughts and its right too! Yes the reason for her to accept the marriage is the most irritating thing happened! Didnt she decide that she doesnt want to get married again at all in life? She said that she doesnt believe in love and marriage anymore, then why get into the same thing for the sake of that Moti mom's happiness! If she was ready to accept this relationship whole heartedly, its ok for her to move on in life, but she is doing it for all wrong reasons! She realises when she starts giving pravachan to that anjaan girl that she also should sacrifice her life for the people who gave so much for her! If she gets married, wont her goal to destroy Pia and JW will take a backseat, because she will have a family to concentrate on and if she still chooses to destroy Pia and JW at any cost will only make her family take a back seat which is not a good sign, as she is again failing on relationships miserably!
InduD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: majumdar

Oval,

(I want her to marry whomever she chooses but this time for the right reasons. )

And whoever marries her, should tell her the whole TRUTH. And in turn she too shud be truthful:

What are her real feelings towards JW (shud she marry someone else)?
Whether she wud continue to give more importance to BJBB activities or to her married life?

Rgds,

Prri



Totally agree she should tell what is JW's position in her life and if she would go back to him anyday if she comes that he might, he might just be innocent...

About BJBB activities, since the guy is in love, he better accept the things that come together...you know its a package...😆
Edited by Je_aime - 18 years ago
aashyagh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Of all ppl who AD? She knows that he has some past
***Meena dont worry about that, Bani will find out with her jasoosi about the past after her marriage! After all this is her fav hobby 😉 😆
who am i??? thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
Pri...

Not getting hyper hun,but showing her agreeing just gav a feeling that the love story has been tainted. The essence of JB relationship for me is that they dont let anyone else enter their mind.
This issue i dont hold against bani but on creatives,from bani's POV she is entitled to move ahead and make a life of her own,but it sounds rather strange that this women who came back after 5yrs to avenge and for her kids is shown doing nothing in that line but here stands and talks abt moving ahead.
But as viewer i know both sides so is it necessary to show bani like that,first she rejects and in temple makes a decission but after littlebashan she goes back to AD and announces she is ready for it as she has decided to move ahead in life,the way this has been handled was huge let down
Above all this one thing will be hanging over her head thruout her life...will she be able to forget this??if craetives will slip it,then no problem but will bani be able to forgiv herself ya all this is to make AD mahaan as his avenger/mentor,lover ...angles failed.If this a game to garner symphathy votes for him then dy failed big time as i hav bigger contestants like JW and BW in this race with R-Trio also added to list


EcliPSe_2010 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ovaltine

Pri
thank you for this wonderful post. Couldn't agree more. Just a question,
has Pia tapped all the phone lines too, mobile and land lines? She really
knows the power of money 😉 .
I want her to marry whomever she chooses but this time for the right
reasons.



Pri
Good post...Agree with Oval..I want Bani to marry whomever she chooses
but this time for the right reasons...
sun29 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
ash then she will drop AD like a hot potato and run back to her ram... 😉
btw ekta kapoor is in turkey and will visit all famous locations so any one in turkey do not miss this golden oppurtunity to give her a piece of our collective minds 😡

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".