Judges Chose people by their looks

well..he's the entertainer if you want to put it that way..but if you've seen, in the previous II's, Farah would often tell them,"your the complete package, you look great, you body language is great & your singing is okay, you can improve though"..so the point is..we wouldn't want an Idol;someone who we look up to, not to be able to control themselves themselves..

True - if judges react like this - how can we blame the normal audience

now i am thinking Sonu Nigam and Anu Malik were far more better than the current judges - especially Alisha and Udit

well maybe not judges...well maybe some judges like alisha may...but then again they did select ankita...

BUT janta surely goes 4 looks i can tell u that much!

i'm sorry...if they were based on looks then pple who aren't that good lukin and great singers (like smita, not tryin to hate her, luv her to death...but just an example) wudn't be in the show!!!

and what's wrong with boyish girls? why so discriminative? and do u have a bias against good lukin pple? cuz that offends me 😛 😆

Anu and sonu are the best judges. i thought in the first piano round that javedji is doing same as alisha and udit but today he has changed my mind. i think he is judging purely on singing. so in piano round only javedji is the best judge. i hope anu comes back as early as possible. i read somewhere that he won't be in piano round at all. that's sad.

i cant understand what judges comments after performance and what they say before elimination.

after ankitas performance javed ji given 11 out of 10
then how come she was there in his bottom 3 list.

First piano round for boys performance they all gave good comments for suhit and when asked for bottom 3 javed ji told he see's suhit in botttom 3.

yesterday's boys performance also javed aktar's comments towards rehan, parleen and anish were like , they were betaal and besur what about suhit only he found the throw was not there.

but the judges all were harsh with abhishek who sang in sur,taal and lay for not remebering 2 words. i know it's not acceptable in this stage of competition, but if they can say sweety things to suhit why cant they say it to others.

is suhit is sponsoring the show or what??

Originally posted by: music_masti

i cant understand what judges comments after performance and what they say before elimination.

after ankitas performance javed ji given 11 out of 10
then how come she was there in his bottom 3 list.

First piano round for boys performance they all gave good comments for suhit and when asked for bottom 3 javed ji told he see's suhit in botttom 3.

yesterday's boys performance also javed aktar's comments towards rehan, parleen and anish were like , they were betaal and besur what about suhit only he found the throw was not there.

but the judges all were harsh with abhishek who sang in sur,taal and lay for not remebering 2 words. i know it's not acceptable in this stage of competition, but if they can say sweety things to suhit why cant they say it to others.

is suhit is sponsoring the show or what??

Very good points 👏
I don't know about sponsoring but SONY knows they can make a lot of money, thanks to Suhit. After the show is over, will they care about him (or even the other contestants)? Nah.

To me Abhishek's Chala jata sounded like a sad song..total lack of energy.LEKIN 😆 he is WAY better than Suhit.Poor chap looked completely battered by the judges firing.