Alka does it again...

Yet another female contestant, yet again the same remark... I think we have given her benefit of doubt way too many times... After the wonderful performance on Namak Ishq Da by Neeta, Alka said she found the singing very average😕 There certainly is something wrong here...

I totally agree that there is something wrong. I like Alka Yagnik's singing very much and I also know that she is really able to appreciate good singing. Having said that, however, I believe that at times she is not fair. I still do not understand why she marked down the girl in Indore who sang "Tumhari adaaon pe mein waari waari"

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Yet another female contestant, yet again the same remark... I think we have given her benefit of doubt way too many times... After the wonderful performance on Namak Ishq Da by Neeta, Alka said she found the singing very average😕 There certainly is something wrong here...

Yup Yup Yup.....There is some problem here😃

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Yet another female contestant, yet again the same remark... I think we have given her benefit of doubt way too many times... After the wonderful performance on Namak Ishq Da by Neeta, Alka said she found the singing very average😕 There certainly is something wrong here...

Even I found her singing average..... She was off surs many a times

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

Even I found her singing average..... She was off surs many a times

off sur 😕 i wouldnt agree there... i can uderstand if u say she cud have had more energy and expressions in the song, but i dont remember if she went off sur for even a moment... actually the original song has been sung so brilliantly that probably her performance looked lacking expressions a bit...but certainly not average singing for me...😛

Originally posted by: smallwonder

off sur 😕 i wouldnt agree there... i can uderstand if u say she cud have had more energy and expressions in the song, but i dont remember if she went off sur for even a moment... actually the original song has been sung so brilliantly that probably her performance looked lacking expressions a bit...but certainly not average singing for me...😛

Its your opinion but I concur with Alka.... 😊

Originally posted by: smallwonder

off sur 😕 i wouldnt agree there... i can uderstand if u say she cud have had more energy and expressions in the song, but i dont remember if she went off sur for even a moment... actually the original song has been sung so brilliantly that probably her performance looked lacking expressions a bit...but certainly not average singing for me...😛

I have nt heard this song...... She has different voice..... She sang good...... But I think she must have been off sur many times..... though overall impact was good because of choice of song......

She is good...... Above Average.... 👍🏼

She picked up on the song really well 👏

This are my exact description while hearing to her live.... 😊

Aisha Sayed sang namak ishq da in II3 today.
I haven't seen Neeta's performance yet though.
But I'm not surprised with Alka's comments. Whats new?

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Aisha Sayed sang namak ishq da in II3 today.
I haven't seen Neeta's performance yet though.
But I'm not surprised with Alka's comments. Whats new?

i heard both... i think aisha was better 😊 although aisha sang just the mukhda whereas neeta sang the antara as well - both were good...

Alka always has a problem with the female contestants, especially the ones who sound a bit like her. 😆