~ Season 3 and the judges ~ -- My Take!

52703 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Hi Everyone

Well I just happened to watch 25May's episode and may I please genuinely know why Udit Narayan have nothing to say or comment on?😕 It realli realli annoying to see FOUR judges sitting at the table and words coming out only out of two,….or actually just ONE…Anu Mallik!🤢 I cannot seem to understand why he has such a huge amount of attitude this season….he seemed chilled last two seasons…now it just seems like he wants to play "who's the BOSS here"game.

Anyways back to my point….with four judges I expected the show to have a new vibe to it….2singers, 1 composer and 1 lyricist….that's pretty kool when u think of it…but from my side, I've been let down.👎🏼 I mean Uditji hardly ever says ANYTHING….and pls I am not "picking" or "having a go" at him, I am just voicing what I think! I heard him talk maybe only 4 or 5 times in auditions and now…I think he only got to tell people whether they got selected or not!…😕Alisha is also similar…I mean come on you people are singer I'm sure u have much more to say then just "your in" "that was good" etc etc!🤢

Last 2 seasons….Farah, Sonu and Anu looked like a perfect trio, each one had something to say and different opinions, no one was boss or tried to act like one….Farah even if she was the only female judge knew how to handle contestants as well as her fellow judges😆, Alisha just seems petrified of all of them! I am aware comparison isn't good but I don't want u to see this as a comparison but just an observed difference.😊

Coming to Javedji and Anu Mallik now…..I absolutely respect Javedji and his comments make sense and are like constructive criticism 👏…Now on the other hand we have Mr. Anu Mallik who doesn't seem to be fond of Javedji or any of the other judges. He seems to be contradicting every judge's decision….for example when Alisha told the couple who stuffed to continue/start again he interrupted it , his excuse being its not in the format… well when did judges from reality shows start sticking to the format?.😕.and agin when uditji was like "aur acha ho sakta tha" he goes "bura bhi nahi tha" ...then Uditji had to flip on what he just said!😕

I though it was very disrespectful when he said "my tune was good but Javedji's lyrics were hard" and "what kind of lyrics do u write Javedji?" …. I don't exactly know if that was meant to be a joke or an insult ….seemed more of the latter to me!😡 Anu should really get a grip, this may look like I am having a go at him but I think he really needs to calm down!

On the whole the talent this year is pretty good👏!!!! Now all we need to work on is the judges!!😆

Uditji:- Needs to talk more, contribute more in decisions, provide constructive criticism as he knows singing well😃, give advice on improvements like sur, taal, laye😛 and not be the announcer of who's in and out and also needs to act more independently and voice his true opinions!😊

Alisha:- Well mostly same as Uditji and should learn to defend herself when someone contradicts her. 😊

Jevedji:- Doesn't need any improvement…..I'll just pray u survive this season with Anu Mallik!😆

Anu Mallik:- Please don't get me started!!!!!!!👎🏼

P.S. Hussain is doing a great job as host along with Mini!👏…Something consistent about the show, Aman and Mini did good work previous seasons and Hussain fits in well😃!!!!!!

Sorry if my post is offensive to anyone and if mods feel this post may hurt/offend any fans please feel free to close it!

Adios Amingos!!!! 😉

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

716

Users

7

Frequent Posters

prettyasjen thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
YOU know what well said!!!

👏

Im extremely proud of u, i agree with everything you have said. I was going to open a post myself on this matter i guess you beat me to it 😳

The only thing id like to say on this post is Anu is really starting to get annoying, he seems to have took over the whole show! 😕
139271 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ~srk_abhi_apu~

On the whole the talent this year is pretty good👏!!!! Now all we need to work on is the judges!!😆


😆😆😆so true!!!yeah i think Anu Malik is becoming a little too rude with his comments!!!
prettyasjen thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: shivgauri


😆😆😆so true!!!yeah i think Anu Malik is becoming a little too rude with his comments!!!



yh man i totally agree!
silverwing1527 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
👏
hehe.. i like this post.. more anu bashing!! 😆 just kidding.. i actually opened up a post on him too last night

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/indian-idol-6/630097/zindagi-ne

do check it out if you have a chance.. but i completely agree with you. i like the other three judges, but anu needs to tone himself down.. hes become a bitter bitter man 😆 and as for the talent on the show.. i think there are some really good singers this time. albeit.. i didnt watch II 1 and i watched the last few rounds of II 2 because of karuniya because he was dam good, but when sandeep (or watever his name is) won, i got mad cause i didnt think he was as good as karuniya and decided not to watch this season, but then i accidentally put on sony while meiyang chang was singing, and fell in love with his voice, 😃 i've been an avid viewer (and visitor to this section) ever since then. they've got some good talent with emon, meiyang, etc..
krishna4ever thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
Anu Malik has become like Simon Fuller of American Idol rude, bitter, and rediculous 😆 😡 He needs to tone it down. Javed saab needs to take control of the panel and the other two judges need to voice their individual opinions more often. 😊 I hope either Farah Khan or Sonu Nigm return to the show next season to judge.
Edited by krishna4ever - 18 years ago
kothra thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Kya karna chahiye...
ese hih chordete hau anu malik ko..koitoh chahiye 😆 😆
52703 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
Thanks prettyasjen, shivgauri, silverwing, krishna4ever, huzi and amu! 😃

Anu Mallik is getting my everyones nerves...!!!...
The only decent thing he has done this season is not making pathetic shayari's and boring us to death! 😆 😆
fr example!!!

Yeh kali kali aankhein
Yeh gore gore gaal
Gati ho tum jab aise
Ho jata hain dhamaal!
😆
at57 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
👏 Excellent post.. Spot on. The judges were really much more fun last season. I had high hopes from Alisha but she has been a great disappointment as a judge.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".