Why did Aditya/Sameer marry Shikha? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Jannat786

Exactly I so agree.

Also what doesn't make sense is that the baby is Aditya's and not Madhus

If Aditya was the son of Mahanto Jagannath then it would make sense that Madhu didn't want a child but he needed an heir so they got someone to give birth to his child.

BUt here the baby needs to be Madhus so instead of getting Aditya to father the child , they could've gotten anybody child because the baby doesn't even have Madhus blood anyway.

They should have rather shown Aditya as the jangannath son then and not son in law.

Weird

I have recently started watching the show and haven't reached very far.

Originally posted by: Zeeliciousxo

I've been wondering this since day one, because in the show the reason behind why Aditya/Sameer married Shikha is not convincing. So he wanted a baby. Why did he spend so much money and time and effort in making a girl fall in love with him, marry him, and give birth to his baby when he could have just - along with Madhu - hired a surrogate mother? If he and Madhu had used a surrogate mother the baby would also have actually been Madhu's as well (Madhu's egg and Aditya's sperm). Or, if anything, they could have adopted a baby. What was the point in tricking an innocent girl and using her??

I mean, if Aditya/Sameer and Madhu had actually been poor, it would have made sense for Aditya to have used Shikha. Clearly if they're poor they can't afford a surrogate mother neither can they afford to adopt a child. So of course Aditya/Sameer would have no choice but to trick a girl into marrying him in order to have a child. But that is not the case here. So where is the logic?!?!?

I know this drama is "inspired" by a real life story, but c'mon, just because it's foundation is based on a real life story doesn't mean the cvs can twist all the details. I'm sure in real life the husband was poor...because if he was rich he would have just used a surrogate mother. Unless he was just stupid. But I doubt it.

Please, share your thoughts.

😊 @Zeeliciousxo thank god, i go you becaz from 1st day i try to expose this true thingd here..but anyone didn't catch my logic.Actually this show making virendrha own dramatic way without any logic..full drama is dreammy ,never will heaven in real.they are just waste a one of gorgeous pair #VikAish...

where is #Ekta maiya.. She need that type of best combination like vikaish her well storied show.i don't know a best pair can't establish just for stupid story

super duper irritating illogical show ...[][]Neeraj said that neeraj is Sameer's classmate[][]now madhurima told that madhu was in same college with Adi;/samairaa as his classmate[][][]then why madurima didn't know neeraj a single time ???[][]2nd---[]who is playing Avinash ? super irritating baby say zayadha noker lagti hai???[]they should heir a new one as samairaa's dad ?[][]already expose their is noting in this show except revarage as dreammy (Bollywood way) way which is Impossible in real ?[][]1.Same face > Any single man can't fool to love same looking girl and his dad is similar looking tooo :p
[B2.making incomplete story: noo identify of sameer ?? is he came frm middle class then how can he read with madurima's college? [][]3.Neeraj (Show pitch) ki galat information:-- samairaa give money doctor assistant for helping him but neeraj told that he spend money for her surgery and he told they got all money from adi then they hadn't any financial problem after surgery then why shikha got tense for money when Ajay blackmailing her and neeraj told he will manage[][]Waste show just watch it for a best couple #VikAish... I thought that all thriller show is full of suspence and secret ,in end main truth is coming but this show called thilller but their wasn't one inch thilller in this ,this show's story was it's promo nothing more than...[][][]common story like Hindi movie "Keh kahna" and #Khun bhari mang[][]At last []Show pitch will take shika's hand (like Kay kahna)[]and[]Aditya will go/die/jail (no suspense in last ) just very sad want to cry that spoiled a awesome super best couple #VikAish

Originally posted by: Jannat786

Exactly I so agree.

Also what doesn't make sense is that the baby is Aditya's and not Madhus

If Aditya was the son of Mahanto Jagannath then it would make sense that Madhu didn't want a child but he needed an heir so they got someone to give birth to his child.

BUt here the baby needs to be Madhus so instead of getting Aditya to father the child , they could've gotten anybody child because the baby doesn't even have Madhus blood anyway.

They should have rather shown Aditya as the jangannath son then and not son in law.

Weird

@Jannat786 you are 100%% right ... if they show that shape,it would show some logical..now it look like stupid 1000% illogical show where spoiling a perfect couple #VikAish

We've already debated it quite a few times in the past also. We know the whole reason is illogical. There is nothing we can do it and just try to enjoy the show despite the flaws.

Originally posted by: AnotherAdmirer

I have recently started watching the show and haven't reached very far.

From what I gather..

Adoption would have meant the kid was not related to either of the two and adoption leads to many formalities which would blow the cover they have build for their parents. Also many issues play out for eg. visits from the orphanage, the dna, or observable traits like features..

Coming to Surrogacy, again the legal formalities would have to be filed, a whole legal procedure would have to be done. It gets documented. I don't know if it's that easy to keep it a secret. At times the court gives the lady who carried the baby certain rights as well.

For Aditya and Madhu it's clear that they want to keep it all a secret and a hushed up matter, which it would have been had Shikha died. Any clue of legal procedures would be under the scan by their parents I suppose.

Particularly it comes to intentions, when the intention is to deceit, when the mind is evil, In this case deceit parents and evil is the greed for money, crime takes place.

And 'logic'. No crime has logic in it. There is greed, evil, desire, arrogance, ignorance. Madhu and Aditya are not good people. They are not embodied with goodness and wisdom of any sorts..

Originally posted by: VikAish9

😊 @Zeeliciousxo thank god, i go you becaz from 1st day i try to expose this true thingd here..but anyone didn't catch my logic.Actually this show making virendrha own dramatic way without any logic..full drama is dreammy ,never will heaven in real.they are just waste a one of gorgeous pair #VikAish...

where is #Ekta maiya.. She need that type of best combination like vikaish her well storied show.i don't know a best pair can't establish just for stupid story

super duper irritating illogical show ...[][]Neeraj said that neeraj is Sameer's classmate[][]now madhurima told that madhu was in same college with Adi;/samairaa as his classmate[][][]then why madurima didn't know neeraj a single time ???[][]2nd---[]who is playing Avinash ? super irritating baby say zayadha noker lagti hai???[]they should heir a new one as samairaa's dad ?[][]already expose their is noting in this show except revarage as dreammy (Bollywood way) way which is Impossible in real ?[][]1.Same face > Any single man can't fool to love same looking girl and his dad is similar looking tooo :p
[B2.making incomplete story: noo identify of sameer ?? is he came frm middle class then how can he read with madurima's college? [][]3.Neeraj (Show pitch) ki galat information:-- samairaa give money doctor assistant for helping him but neeraj told that he spend money for her surgery and he told they got all money from adi then they hadn't any financial problem after surgery then why shikha got tense for money when Ajay blackmailing her and neeraj told he will manage[][]Waste show just watch it for a best couple #VikAish... I thought that all thriller show is full of suspence and secret ,in end main truth is coming but this show called thilller but their wasn't one inch thilller in this ,this show's story was it's promo nothing more than...[][][]common story like Hindi movie "Keh kahna" and #Khun bhari mang[][]At last []Show pitch will take shika's hand (like Kay kahna)[]and[]Aditya will go/die/jail (no suspense in last ) just very sad want to cry that spoiled a awesome super best couple #VikAish

Agree with you...

I agree with your points.

Originally posted by: prc_fan1

I agree with your points.

But having said that, the show since episode 1 made it clear that this is Shikha's story. Its a story from her POV. It was a smart move by the CVs because now they do not need to justify Aditya's actions. Notice that till now, there have been hints that Aditya did not have an amazing life before Maddy but they've never dwelled into it further because the story is not meant to be neutral. They've constantly been highlighting the injustice he's done to her & are not trying to justify why he did what he did. It is a story from Shikha's POV so it makes sense for the CVs to not bring up his reasons.