Are INDIAN FILM CRITICS rubbish?!!!!

😒 Who do the INDIAN FILM CRITICS think they are? A sane and fun member wants to know to. 😉 We as the audience can like whatever damn film we want. Sometimes, critics like Taran Adarsh can be RUBBISH with their biased reviews. Anyway, are these critics rubbish? Please share your thoughts. 😳

A lot of the times they judge films on the basis of HW films, when they should judge them to BW standards and how Indian mentality is. However I also feel I don't get why all actors/directors/producers bash them just because their films are not appreciated.

I hate pseudo-intellectual critics like raja sen,mihir fadnavis

I was just reading the reviews Dhoom3.. I think taran adarsh giving the movie.. 4.5 star out of 5 .. That is where he lost so much credibility.. That movie was not worth 4.5..Possiblly 2 star the most and that is because of aamir .. He can do so much when the rest of the movie sucks..
So the point is some of these reviews r biased.. So not trusting their reviews..

The problem is that many of the critics judge movies by comparing them to Hollywood films (Aamir called Anupama Chopra out on that I believe), or the critics are paid critics. However, when the paid critics and the rest of the critics agree on something, that's usually when they have a very valid point about the movies.

There r 4 kind of rubbish- waste, recyclable, electronic, hazardous...😉

Critics are like any other movie goer, difference is that being a film enthusiast he have watched a lot more cinema then the audience and most of bollywood filmmaker.
Hence,His idea of film be will be different than lot of casual watcher.
Also critics job is to watch a film and tell how good he find it is, Taran adarsh and Nahta are not critics,they aree trade expert and rate film according to their Commercial success future mostly.
People shld find which critic movie taste is similar to him and follow him.

I kind of like Anupama's reviews most of the times. Especially when she bashes the commercial masalas. But she does seem to incorporate too much of "Hollywood" into her analyses. I like the way she interviews too. She really listens to her people and she's very respectful towards them no matter who's sitting in front of her.

Originally posted by: dabang4life

I was just reading the reviews Dhoom3.. I think taran adarsh giving the movie.. 4.5 star out of 5 .. That is where he lost so much credibility.. That movie was not worth 4.5..Possiblly 2 star the most and that is because of aamir .. He can do so much when the rest of the movie sucks..
So the point is some of these reviews r biased.. So not trusting their reviews..

totaly agre wid yr cmnt