Judge Vs Judge - 1st round

• No personal attacks.
• No attacking the Judges/Hosts/Contestants
• ONLY THE 4 DEBATERS CAN COMMENT ON THE TOPIC!!
• Rest of the members can ROOT for the person who you want to win the debate but you cannot join in the debate.

editted by viewbie: please do not post ur opinion on this thread...this is a contest thread and onli the 4 debaters should be debating about this...u may share ur opinion on other threads 😊

Before starting this fun debate let me please make one thing clear that Javed Akhtar is my fav. judge but for argument sake I am supporting Anu Malik on this thread alone. So if you see me posting otherwise on regular threads, please don't get confused. 😃 I hope it is allowed. Let me know soon.

Wishing luck to Sonya, Huzi and Manisha. Thanks Buttercup and Megs for this wonderful contest. I will start posting now.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Before starting this fun debate let me please make one thing clear that Javed Akhtar is my fav. judge but for argument sake I am supporting Anu Malik on this thread alone. So if you see me posting otherwise on regular threads, please don't get confused. 😃 I hope it is allowed. Let me know soon.

Wishing luck to Sonya, Huzi and Manisha. Thanks Buttercup and Megs for this wonderful contest. I will start posting now.

Tension nai leneka Maya..

Hum yaha konse jung mein hai...Mazaa lo..aur mazaa Doo 😆

Megs - thanks 😊

Huzi - Yes. All for fun😃 but just wanted to make sure.

In reality television there is nothing called a set rules and injustice. Reality shows are anything but fair. We see wild card entries, emotional dramas, regionalism; so many things associated with such shows that either we just watch the show for the fun elements and occasional fabulous renditions or keep on arguing about the unfairness associated with the show. I am afraid but we will have more fodder for the latter.

Now coming to the main topic, Is Anu Malik's veto justified? Yes, it is.

Why? Because he is the only one with maximum experience in the show.

As we have already seen Udit Narayan, a renowned singer with 22 years of experience was flustered while judging the show for the first time. He didn't know what to say or whom to support. I can't even imagine him getting the veto power.

Alisha Chinai is a novice in judging such shows too.

The only other experienced judge is Javed Akhtar but he is not a regular. From the beginning Indian Idol producers have maintained that Javed saab is the 4 th but a guest judge. A guest judge cannot be given veto.

So when it comes to three regular judges Alisha Chinai, Udit Narayan and Anu Malik, the one with maximum experience in the show is worthy of this right.