Mahabharat and Kasam Se - an analogy - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

59

Views

3.6k

Users

17

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: majumdar

Rivya,

Can Bani be compared to Dhritarashtra too. A person who was completely incapable of recognising the mistakes of his/her own kith and kin?

Rgds,

Pri

feel free to call me Rivs..

Pri - I am comparing the present, and what I have been let in of the future.

My comparison is not about what, someone did in the past. The only time I brought past in was for Jigs...because this is one character who had a problem in the past that persists.

And yes if we do bring in the past, I agree Bani definitely represented Dhritirashtra/ Kunti (thanks to Dhani...Jai can also be Kunti)

Again, Pri...we are trying to compare an epic with 100+ main characters to a serial with 10 or so characters... Each one is bound to represent more than 1 people from MH given the time and situation.

Let me know if you agree..

Rivs

ronitfam thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#52
rivs dear i loved ur points and i was just wondering whether u have changed ur side and u r no more a JB despo, but with ur answer now i have full confidence that u r still a JB despo only and not going to love the scenario if AD will come between them 😉

dear till few days back i also used to be only chill but now i have changed to chilli chill 😉

chilli chill
GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: ronitfam

rivs dear i loved ur points and i was just wondering whether u have changed ur side and u r no more a JB despo, but with ur answer now i have full confidence that u r still a JB despo only and not going to love the scenario if AD will come between them 😉
Hmm...good...not that you are clear on that...😆😆😆...

Oh BTW...if AD does turn out to be good..i would not have a problem being a AD supporter alongside a JB despo...but under no circumstances he is coming between JB...😉

I had the same for Tarun...loved PS as an actor and made him the hero in my post leap FF...but the minute in the serial he turned into a skunk...I bashed him... And then when I realized his love was true as he never asked Bani to return it...I was back to liking him...lol...
dear till few days back i also used to be only chill but now i have changed to chilli chill 😉

chilli chill

hmm...chill chill is good...but let me give u a piece of advice...free of cost of course..😉... people here get worked up real fast real soon..so be careful of what u say....if u get what i mean..😛

Rivs

ronitfam thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#54
rivs dear point noted 😉 i think chilli chill is just gonna have fun and loads of fun only😉
Edited by ronitfam - 18 years ago
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: majumdar

Can I begin with my fave topic- the Dixit Purana.

Kiran was quizzing her daughters on Ramayana. She asked them what relationship did Rama have with Sita. The girls who were just back from a trip to little Pooch's house replied thus:

Bani: Brother
Pia: Boyfriend
Rano: Jeeju

Kiran who was furious gave them a thrashing and said "Itni badi ho gayee ho par Mahabharat nahin padhi"

*************************************************

Kiran was asking her daughters "Who burnt Lanka?"

Neither Bani nor Pia could answer the questions. Kiran was furious and gave them a thrashing. She turned to Rano, who smilingly replied that she had the answer. Kiran was thrilled till she heard Rano's reply:

"Mummu, Pia. Wo hee to har jagah aag lagati phirti hai"

*************************************************

Mr. Singhania had come to check on his granddaughters progress after Kiran had passed away. He asked Bani "Shiv dhanush kisne toda tha?" (Who broke Shiv's bow?)

Bani replied "Maine nahin toda Nanaji"
He gave her a thrashing. After which ND took Mr. Singhania away and said "Papaji, Bani bitiya ko mat daatiye. Woh kabhi jhoot nahin kehti hai. Jaroor Pia ki shararat hogi"

Rgds,

Pri

Pri darling,

🤣

Too good, my good, I cant stop laughing.🤣

Love

Krishna

Originally posted by: rivya

Pri...you are too funny...and I have observed that your dislike for Dixits is very deep rooted...

But honey...not to invoke arguments...my only retort is that to clap u need two hands....tali ek haath se nahi bajti...

For every yin, there is a yang. for every east, there is a west. for every Dixit, there is Walia. For every Pia, there is a Jigs. And for every Bani there is a Jai.

Rivs

Rivs darling,

Superbly put dear😃. It indeed takes two hands to clap😉😆. And loved the whole ying yang, thing.👏

Love

Krishna

vardhani thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#56
Hey rivya,

Thanx for your comments.it was really nice of you to reply.well what you said also makes sense to me.but you know ekta mai, she can turn the table anytime.but i strongly feel for

AD -KRISHNA [currently] and later AD -SHAKUNI [he is in fact shakuni after watching episode of 30th april].

BANI- ARJUN.

We can go on speculating but we will eventually fail to come to a logical conclusion.

Currently the serial is dragging.once JW and BW/DD come face to face it will be fun.

in the infamous AD'S words : KS is surely ANOKHA, ADBHUT,AKALPIT,et al. JAI MAHA KAAL.[so very wiered to even write how can that man speak such pure hindi words without even laughing, whenever i listen to his monologe i am in splits].

God bless.

dhani




GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: sun29



rivs maayi has a knack of butchering everyone and everything in the name of TRPs

I know sajani...she is weird man...

u are always welcome dear 😊

thanks honey...
Pia – Duryodhana


rivs compared to pia duryodhan seems a saint
u maybe right abt her coz she has come up with mohras and saazish we never fathom her capable of.....but i have a gut feeling that there is a shakuni who is holding the strings and directing pia the duryodhan..on her own she is useless other than a decorative item 🤢 ...but duryodhan was not evil more grey and this character redefines evilness ..she is mentally sick
rivs to bani she is the sister who is always at fault but still her sister, so does bani see the enemy in her is the question

Hmm...well in fact duryodhan was not really that bad...it was just that he fought against the winners and the historians (basically the winners family) will only glorify the winners...same happened to Ravan...

I agree...there has to be a shakuni somewhere...someone who is helping Pia...

Yudhisthir never saw an enemy in Duryodhan...but they still fought...so u never know...I think in this battle Bani will fight Pia...


Jigs – Ashwathama

till the property fiasco the situation cld be similar ....but again later with the exit of ashwini they lost as to what shld be done with jigs hence there was incompleteness in their dealing with the track....and from a possessive sister and mother she has been reduced to the regular vamp
i wld not be suprised if the mastermind behind the KW killing and rest was jigs herself as u put it and her son was a mere pawn...still that woman has not learnt after loosing her sons
hmm... its possible thats why I put Jigs in this spot...of ashwathama...

Ashwathama was a great warrior...his biggest crime was using his power on an unborn...and he lost his most valuable possesion for this crime...

Karuna – Yuyutsu/ Shakuni

karunas role is as confusing as the character itself and yes for a very silly reason she took a volteface ...do not have much idea abt the former but she as shakuni seems highly unlikely but with the destructives u never know...we still have to know what exactly happened that it took 20 yrs for mother daughter to patch up ...or they planning to show that she eloped and thats that 😕 ...but her liasion with pia and jigs hardly making sense....

I will send u my theory once i have had a chance to put it to paper...

AD - Krishna

rivs agreed krishna was the one who guided or influenced arjun and AD is the krishna in bani's life at present who is making very sure indeed that she does not sidetrack from her mission ...but what is his personal vendetta that he had to use bani against the rest....and being an influential person why wait for 20 yrs ....yes here also whoever starts the war or are involved the grand master will be AD who as krishna wld want to urge an end result

I see him as Krishna only for the time being...not in the future...
AD – Shakuni

this seems even more likely if AD waited 20 yrs for revenge and he is not fighting the battle at the front line but rather laying out the whole war with pawns,moves, weapons..and he too wants to destroy the walia family

My only problem here is...if AD is indeed the Shakuni...why did he trick Pia like this...there has to be more to it...thats why I put karuna as Shakuni...Karuna is the face of Shakuni and AD is the brain of Shakuni...

JW – Dhritarashtra

if we go by the current scenario or rather after ONS jai has been the most manipulated whoever be it pia,jigs ,sahil,and rivs rather than his love a combination of his guilt trip plus his father's deed plus his love for bani made him incapable of taking a stand at all....his relations made him a weak man...yes he is the dhritarashtra...and i wld even compare bani with dhritatashtra for the same points hold for her ..jai and bani have been the most exploited by everyone..sometime they allowed to be sometime they did'nt but still were used and used for everyone's agenda

Yes Sajani...I think I told someone else that too...Bani was Dhritarashtra...but today she is not...atleast not yet...today JW is Dhritarashtra...

the fact is everyones role will change over time...
JW – Bhima

i wld give my fingers and toes if indeed muna is the bhima who actually will fight his battle and not resign to fate...if the manipulated becomes the manipulator that wld be a treat...a confrontation 😊yes in that one department he is bhima always act and much later think

Hmm...chalo someone sees some positivity in this one...lol

The reason I want to use this analogy for Jai is because, there is a lot of potential with this character. And if the creatives decide, Jai can be the ultimate hero of this war, even though Bani may be in the front line.


and this we have been shouting and pleading and crying but destructives have selective hearing 😡

Someday they will hear...I am not going to quit and give up...period...

rivs rano can be the krishna who will guide bani to her true enemies that is the three witches, for AD as per the present scenario the only target is jai walia...but rano can help bani when again she is trapped by the infamous pravachanns ..what better updesd that is vinaash of pia ..plus arunima is a brilliant actress who shld get her due now,she shld be brought to the front...rest can be spectators as usual

Yes Rano can be the Krishna once AD's real motives are unveiled...
Let me know your thoughts and ideas.


hope i made sense sorry yaar my gyaan of mahabharat is from what i use to watch on television in the earlier days ..my knowledge on hindu mythology is quite limited..thanx for an elaborate view into each character with their traits 😊

Its still good honey...and if u need more info on particular characters try google and wiki...both will give u tons to read up on the characters..

Rivs

Manasi_16 thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Enthusiast Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 18 years ago
#58
Fabulus post Rivs..& thanx for PMing me the link...I have gone thru the entire topic but I need to get my thoughts sorted coz I'm not a regular watcher of KS...so to draw any analogy I need to refresh my brain of all the things I know of the story. But will post my thoughts by tomm 😊
GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: vardhani

Hey rivya,

Thanx for your comments.it was really nice of you to reply.well what you said also makes sense to me.but you know ekta mai, she can turn the table anytime.but i strongly feel for

AD -KRISHNA [currently] and later AD -SHAKUNI [he is in fact shakuni after watching episode of 30th april].

BANI- ARJUN.

We can go on speculating but we will eventually fail to come to a logical conclusion.

Currently the serial is dragging.once JW and BW/DD come face to face it will be fun.

in the infamous AD'S words : KS is surely ANOKHA, ADBHUT,AKALPIT,et al. JAI MAHA KAAL.[so very wiered to even write how can that man speak such pure hindi words without even laughing, whenever i listen to his monologe i am in splits].

God bless.

dhani

Hey Dhani...thanks for ur input...i wish you to continue giving your inputs in my other posts too...

Frankly am not here to bash Jai or Bani or AD for that matter...I just want to compare and contrast them to see how the serial would shape...and to find some logic in this otherwise illogical ensemble of people and random dialogues...lol...

I am glad there was someone here to discuss fun stuff with me...
Rivs

GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Manasi_16

Fabulus post Rivs..& thanx for PMing me the link...I have gone thru the entire topic but I need to get my thoughts sorted coz I'm not a regular watcher of KS...so to draw any analogy I need to refresh my brain of all the things I know of the story. But will post my thoughts by tomm 😊

Thanks Manasi...am waiting for ur points..

Rivs

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".