The Sin Of Jai Walia by the creatives - Page 3

Originally posted by: m3ghna

But AP they need what Bani has become today for the story to move forward. Or atleast the story they have in mind.

Bavie/Meg, now wait and see how they butcher Bani's character, what with her being on full revenge mode and all..we are not going to be able to recognise her as our original sweet selfless Bani at all, and it wud be easier for us to address her as Durga DasGupta..

BTW Bavie-Rivs-Krishna,

Great post, very good points brought up..this is exactly what I have been thinking abt and saying for the past few days, why cud'nt Jai do anything abt/in the situation? Why did he end up so helpless?

Then when AD person came in, I consoled myself saying that he is going to be Bani's saviour sent by Jai himself, and finally Jai used his brains and did something about it..something for Bani in her helpless and traumatised situation..but alas! that doesnt seem to be the case, does it?

AP, Rivs,

Nice post.

I was so waiting for the leap but this story ain't moving nowhere even after 5 years. I am so disappointed. From whatever little has unfolded, it doesn't look good. Bani is still being used, manipulated, she is still not independent. Jai Walia is still helpless against his perpetrator. Being rude to a few powerless employees or being unkind to a kid, does not give the forum back their original RB. I would have so loved his characterization, had he been the one to completely destroy Pia. Why are the creatives saving Pia for Bani? Jai was the person most wronged by her. I don't understand.

I hate the sight of Pia ensconsed in the mansion. I hate it that everyone is helpless against her. I hate Rano's look of helplessness. I hated that teen beheno ki kahani that Rano told the kids. For what purpose? Kya pyaar yaar? Even after so much water under the bridge how can she talk about love between the three sisters? Why didn't she cut Pia out as a sister?

Above all, I hate Karuna's characterization because she is being played by a talented actress (just my opinion) who has the capability to bring out those gray shades, those moments of regret, those moments of doubt. Instead we get a flat two dimensional character. What a waste of talent all around, RK, PD, and the person who plays Karuna.

I am so sorry that the butchering continues. I don't mean to offend Jai-Bani supporters and I say this in all politeness but may be it is time to let Jani RIP.

Abha

Originally posted by: nyzbabigyal

u know i alwayz thought this is wat bani would've became when ONS was revealed - pia did her fake shooting/death scenario.. and bani and d heart wreching beach scene.. i thought that was it.. but d 'kreatives' ended up ruinin that.. so brought d same sequence bac once again... just wit a diff storyline - new character added (AD along wit krishna and twin) .. i mean now all ties r "broken".. they should've broken then but who knew wat d kreatives were thinkin😕

That's my fear "who knew wat d kreatives were thinkin" They start out with a somewhat interesting storyline and then destroy it. I hope that in the process of Bani having her revenge they don't destroy the integrity of JB ( which to a great extent has already been destroyed to move the storyline along).

I also thought this was what Bani would have become after coming out of her stupor from finding out about the ONS - but again the destructives had their own ideas. One never knows how fast the hamster powering their brain is running around the wheel.

Originally posted by: dhruvie05

BTW Bavie-Rivs-Krishna,

Great post, very good points brought up..this is exactly what I have been thinking abt and saying for the past few days, why cud'nt Jai do anything abt/in the situation? Why did he end up so helpless?

Then when AD person came in, I consoled myself saying that he is going to be Bani's saviour sent by Jai himself, and finally Jai used his brains and did something about it..something for Bani in her helpless and traumatised situation..but alas! that doesnt seem to be the case, does it?

Like you I too thought tghat Jai did a smart thing for once and senf AD ot help Bani....but we were left disappointed and had JW who was busy choicing what clothes to wear for his so called wedding to his Rpaist.

Him balming god for his own uselessness, spinlessness and guilt at not ebing able to do anything.

The creatives killed him for the Rapist.

Bavie, I think the whole idea was to bring on a new avataar of Bani. The only way the avataar was going to come about was with destruction of Bani as a sister, wife, bahu mother etc. All relationships had to break for her. Although she knew about the ONS etc she still helped Pia citing she could not turn her back on her blood even if they gave her pain , the same dialogue for her husband.
It is a dumb scenario, a lion king so helpless. Its pathetic. There is no semblance of continuation of the characters. They are just adjusted to suite the scene.
Many think that Bani will forgive Jai on finding out the truth, but will she? There is always this possibility that deep down she whould ask why he couldn't let her know even by his eyes, she would have known? I doubt she will be 100% convinced.
Note that during her Banigiri days, she did hurt him emotionally but also remember during those days, he never admitted that he loved her just that he shared a soulful relationship. Now the situation is different, they love one another and have even renewed their vows for 7 lives.
She will wonder how come he couldn't speak with his eyes?

if Jai had managed to convey his majboori even once Bani would have happily handed over her babies to him and stayed in the MA for 50 years. But then the story would not move and there would be no revenge and Durga Dasgupta, would there?
Somali

I join hands with you to save Jai Walia from the destrutive Creatives.Ekta and her group are responsible for what they put out in a public forum, this show has crossed all human boundaries, it is as if their team has no regard for the Family unit, it is truly disgusting what they have done to the innocent. hope that you are successful in your journey for justice with this new twist they call a leap, for me I just see this leap as the same nonsense,

Originally posted by: ovaltine

Bavie, I think the whole idea was to bring on a new avataar of Bani. The only way the avataar was going to come about was with destruction of Bani as a sister, wife, bahu mother etc. All relationships had to break for her. Although she knew about the ONS etc she still helped Pia citing she could not turn her back on her blood even if they gave her pain , the same dialogue for her husband.
It is a dumb scenario, a lion king so helpless. Its pathetic. There is no semblance of continuation of the characters. They are just adjusted to suite the scene.

Many think that Bani will forgive Jai on finding out the truth, but will she? There is always this possibility that deep down she whould ask why he couldn't let her know even by his eyes, she would have known? I doubt she will be 100% convinced.

Note that during her Banigiri days, she did hurt him emotionally but also remember during those days, he never admitted that he loved her just that he shared a soulful relationship. Now the situation is different, they love one another and have even renewed their vows for 7 lives.
She will wonder how come he couldn't speak with his eyes?

So completley agreew ith you dear 100%. What she did duing the alimony fiasco time and what Jai did now was completely different.

There was no decleration of love betwen them then but now there was with a remarriage in the manfir.

So will this new Bani forgive him so easily...I donot think so.

great post guys.completeley agree with you.
Destructives are butchring Jai's character after from PR raj.but after ONS he never recovered.I alwayse felt that JW was always gulity infront of Bani .They never shared a fare relationship.At first PR raj,then ONS.and now sahil;s murder case.
Jai walia used to a strong character.but after ONS where is JW?
How could JW forgive himself for ONS,fathering 2 sisters kid at a same time and now this.
This is really hard to undersatand that Jai did nothing to save Bani.and blackmailed by repto and sent his pregnant baby to MS and the scene of him snatching babies from bani ,is very ruthless.how can ever destruvtives defend this?How can be repto has more brain then JW.
Jai also knew that he can do something for Bani but he didn't do anything.Now after bani's death ,he is again RB but will this help.i found him again helpless ,gulity.
.When pia elpoed with pushkar then he made bani's life miserable but now wat did he do with jigs,karuna,and pia .why does he not get rid from these 3 bithces .is he still helpless infront of them.Why do he not make their life miserable?
He just being rude his employee and mausi?is this right to being rude to them?Is right to being workholic and making money raather then to take care of their kids.kids needed him or money.
Jai should be reedemmed now but how and how many things?
ONS and Pia's kid were a fact for whole life.how can he redeemed from them?
watever he did with Bani ,how can this be justified?

I think the butchring will be continues .right now its jai and after him its Bani durga das gupta .because she is not taking her revenge .she is just puppet of AD and taking revenge for AD.