HAYSTACK in a wrap RR ARTICLE GR8 mag

DiyaS

@DiyaS

Stunner

36

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

Balanced review, but I feel they wrote it a couple of weeks back. The lead characters both have layers, they are not the typical heroic hero and weeping heroine ... while Tarun Khanna's Tejawat is all black, he has played it with a suavity and polish.

Also no mention of Ananya Khare 😲 she has been very good the last couple of weeks, and different from her usual stereotyped vamp roles.

I feel they have been a bit unfair to Ashish, he is doing very well as Rudra.

I'm very happy to see what they say about Sanaya ... media has been uniformly consistent in praise of her portrayal of this role which is a very challenging one for any actress, and is completely out of her comfort zone. Well done, Sanaya! 👏

But they seem to be reviewing RR more against BW movies than against other TV shows, which in itself is huge praise. Hope the CVs keep the story consistent, and the BSD background well in place, that is what makes this different from other shows.

9

Reply

Quote

damn

@Deus_Vult

Rocker

28

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

TFS,

very good review , both negative and positive points about the show and loved what they said about sanaya😳

but dont like the title 😳it reminds me of the title of a post by barf aadmi😳

4

Reply

Quote

Guinea

@Guinea

Inactive

34

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: rockystar22
TFS,
very good review , both negative and positive points about the show and loved what they said about sanaya😳
but dont like the title 😳it reminds me of the title of a post by barf aadmi😳

Rockyjaan , you are too cute 😆 What are you doing in the forum ...exams must be abt 10 days away ...

1

Reply

Quote

Putija

@PutijaChalhov

Trailblazer

40

+ 8

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

This is a good review I think written before Ashish or Ananya really had much to do Its a feb issue of GR8 must have reviewed the show till mid Jan so does not cover the show upto date as many of the members predicted ,on the face of it it is good review may be bit biased against Ashish but still a good one of the show which I have read so far gives good vibes .

Thanks all for reading commenting and liking the article so gives me some satisfaction for going through the effort of scanning posting it here and sharing with all RRIANS😃.

4

Reply

Quote

Aruni.

@Aruni.

Dazzler

24

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

TFS! Really nice appreciative words about Sanaya!

Hope the negative things pointed out in the show will prove themselves wrong in the writer's eyes in the future...

2

Reply

Quote

showviewer

@showviewer

Rocker

27

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

Thank you for posting. Quite an extensive review. Anyway, most of what I wanted to say has already been addressed by others here. Hope writers keep a tight grip on the story and script and keep this as a journey of Rudra AND Paro. The layers of the leads and other actors are slowly unfolding as the story progresses.

Edited by showviewer - 12 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

Gargi

@sweet_gargi

Dazzler

23

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#17

The review is a good one and also is quite acceptable. But the title in an effort to seem catchy, has been made a negative and misleading one. Haystack in a wrap!!...Common u are deducing a freshly born concept to a mere "Emptiness inside a present wrap!" That is ridiculous and very biased. That's what I totally disagreed. The TRP thing has made everyone go crazy. Since the show has come up with only decent n steady TRP's and not a great sky-rocketing boost in the TRP chart you come up to give ur expert comments to make the directors n everyone nervous about its future fate.

Alright I agree on the positive sides, that the show was more excellent in terms of cinematography and action sequence and every technical aspect that common viewers don't know in its initial episodes, and in your negative review about its very dejavu type scenes where some things looks illogical or very cliched but my dear Critic, when has Indian show done great when they have showed logic or extraordinary genuine scenes? That's the way India soaps work because India shows cater to a group of people and it depends on their response that a show will run in the long run.

I think as the story progresses about Thakur and the arms smuggling issue, the story will get interesting and till then we should be quiet about it

1

Reply

Quote