Porus 129: The death of Alexander?

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Folks,

No, I have not (yet!) lost it. I am not mistakenly writing Alexander instead of Puru. For death need not be only a matter of physical dissolution. It can also be the loss of a great reputation, the besmirching beyond recall of a name that resounds down the corridors of time even more than 2300 years after Alexander of Macedon's passing on to the Valhalla where, in Nordic mythology, the great heroes of the ages are honoured.

Alexander the Great.

For it is he, rather than Puru, who seemed to have died at 9:30 pm IST tonight.

When I first saw that scene, of Puru, having ended his Tarzan style roar ( the only thing he didn't do was to beat his chest like the Lord of the Jungle, in raw triumph), being reduced to a pincushion by eight arrows shot by Alexander's archers, and slumped to the ground, my heart sank right down with him. I felt sick to the pit of my stomach.

I did not think that Puru was finished. Of course Puru, the titular hero of this determinedly ahistorical saga, cannot die, and will not die.

What I thought was that the CVs had finally completed their hatchet job on Alexander, which has been in the works right from the beginning. Those of you who have read the half a dozen earlier posts that I have done in this forum, would remember the proofs I had offered to back this conclusion of mine. Tonight's denoument seemed, at first sight, to be setting the coping stone on that structure of systematic and deliberate distortion.😡

It seemed that the CVs had finally, after various preliminary attempts at painting him in various shades from light to dark grey, now managed to reduce Alexander the Great --- one of the most redoubtable warriors and commanders the world has ever known, who never lost a battle, who has never been accused, even by hostile historians, of resorting to deceit to win a battle or a war --- to an out and out villain, who had an unarmed man shot down by his archers in cold blood when he could not be checked in the arena.

Nothing could have redeemed Alexander's character after this, and as for the CVs, they had, I felt, plumbed the depths as far as script writing was concerned.

I practically decided to quit Porus from this week, for I could no longer stand such vicious character assassination of a man whose name still shines bright after more than 2 millennia

But then, almost against my will, I rewatched that scene, painful as it was. Then I realised that Alexander did not want to kill Puru, but rather to check him and immobilise him for the present.

He realises that if the gladiatorial bout is continued, Puru will emerge as the unquestioned victor, and then he will have to be set free, to wreak further havoc in Faras. The only alternative would be for Alexander to fight Puru himself, which would be beneath his dignity as the Shah-e-Faras, for he still has no idea that Puru too is of royal blood, and a crown prince to boot. Alexander would be confident of winning in such a bout (he does not reckon with the CVs!😉), but it would hardly do Macedonia's prestige any good if their king is forced to descend into the arena to keep their flag flying high.

So I think we will find that the arrows have been so fine tuned as not to hit any vital spot. Yes, it does sound unbelievable, but seeing how things go on in this script, nothing is impossible!😉

I would even hazard the guess that just as he did with the severely wounded Purushottam after the battle of the Hydaspes, now too Alexander will have Puru treated and restored to health.

He will do this so that, after having studied Puru's fighting tactics - while the Macedonian toughs were being clobbered one and all by Puru - with lynx eyed keenness, and the complete detachment of a scientist looking at a specimen in a microscope, Alexander will now want to pick his brains further about Bharat, so as to hone his fighting machine for the confrontation that lies ahead. For by now, Alexander has grown to appreciate Puru's grey cells a great deal. His highly perceptive comments during the gladiatorial encounter make this crystal clear.

It was a treat to watch him, relaxed and unruffled as his men were getting a drubbing from Puru, discuss the Bharatiya's acute intelligence, and praise him for nearly having made off with Barsine in the teeth of the Macedonian army. This is perhaps the beginning of the admiration for Purushottam that eventually made Alexander, after the very hard fought battle of the Hydaspes, give him back his kingdom, and entrust him with the overlordship of other areas as well. He not only admired Porus, but he trusted him.

A really great man can recognise, appreciate, and value another such.

To revert, Alexander also realises - for his mind is as sharp as a Toledo blade (another anachronism, for the matchless Toledo swords appear only in medieval times in Europe, not in the 4th century BC!) - that if Puru, who could easily have escaped after his attempt to take Barsine away had failed, had chosen to stay on, there was some other reason for it. That he wanted (here, Alexander's enunciation was not quite clear and I could not make out the word, but this is what could be called an educated guess) to assess the strength of the Macedonians.

Of course Alexander's intelligence service has flopped, and he has no idea that Puru's fellow musketeers are planning to sink as much of the Macedonian fleet as they can. Never mind that the so-called Macedonian man of war bears an uncanny resemblance to the ship on which Ripudaman met the Dasyu queen, and then in which Puru & Co. set sail for Faras,😆 a tinpot affair that could hardly be called seaworthy, and looks smaller than a weekender sailboat.

So I am going to possess my soul in patience, and wait for the game plan of the CVs for Alexander to unfold tomorrow. It was significant that the precap had nothing about Puru; they mean to spring the surprise on us tomorrow. Only it will be no surprise!

For once, I enjoyed the Paurava Rashta segment too. Malay is adorable, and I was delighted that without any more twists and turns, Anusuya reached the throne hall with Malay in tow, and halted Kanishka's yuvarajyabhishek. She will now, hopefully, realise her utter folly, and that of Raja Bamni, in not only forgiving the vicious Shivdutt, but of restoring him to his old position of power and prestige. This time around, Bamni will not only have him locked up again, but he will throw away the key!

I shall look forward to hearing your takes on what I have discussed above, ahead of what should be the revelation tomorrow night.

Finally, my usual request: if you liked this post, please do remember to hit the Like button.


Shyamala Aunty/ Di
Edited by sashashyam - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

3.2k

Users

9

Likes

62

Frequent Posters

ananda29 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Man down.
The fandom of Alexander here is happy happy happy and rejoicing.
Their god is most intelligent has killed the brown monkey, who is so arrogant ( he looked for that) standing up there and boasting about indians... who he.
All hail to the greeks. persians mongols, brits etc...🥳
Let us go to india now and kill all those fools - the brown monkeys.
Great is Alexander and he shall prevail forever👏
Edited by ananda29 - 7 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
My dear Ananda,

I don't think you can have read my post at all. How can anyone be happy about the denoument tonight? In any case, this is not the real Alexander, he has never been that, and if what I have foreseen in my post turns out not to be correct, I shall give up on this serial.

Don't get so angry - it will make you ill - and do take a look at my post if you feel like it.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: ananda29

Man down.

The fandom of Alexander here is happy happy happy and rejoicing.
Their god is most intelligent has killed the brown monkey, who is so arrogant ( he looked for that) standing up there and boasting about indians... who he.
All hail to the greeks. persians mongols, brits etc...🥳
Let us go to india now and kill all those fools - the brown monkeys.
Great is Alexander and he shall prevail forever👏

486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Aunty I am keeping my fingers crossed that your prediction turns true and Alexander is merely playing a trick to understand Puru's fighting techniques and assess his skills.He doesn't intend to kill Puru but just immobilise him for a while and will prolly provide treatment for him.
If this doesn't come true then we all will have to resign to the fact that Swastik has indeed turned the lion into a wolf

TBH kroor,magroor,jallad,haivaan is one thing.But attacking in a tournament behind the back is simply cowardly and Alexander is anything but that.
It simply goes against everything his character has stood for till now even in Swastik's version.
Everything said and done,Alexander is NOT Darius.

Meanwhile Puru's Musketeers/Power Rangers/Teletubbies are doing their job well.
Just hoping that they don't get caught🤣

PR part was too good.Malay is such a cutie pie and got to see Anusuya in her fighter mode after a long time
Now I just hope that Dumbomini believes Malay and Anusuya in the precap _/\_
If he doesn't trust them then laanat hai uss par.

Last but not the least,couldn't they edit Puru's gorilla roar?🤢It was ridiculous tbh.
Moreover my dad was watching it with me today and after Puru finished the dhulayi in Round 2 or Round 3,Dad was like,'Ab yeh zaroor dialogue maarega'😆

And Puru did give a short speech after that😆😆


486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
BTW I noticed something during the fight.
When Puru defeated the second warrior,he was about to kill that guy in the heat of the moment.But then the guy folded hands and Puru stared at Alexander before sparing him.
It was as if he had become cautious that Alexander was watching him and was back on his guard.

Otherwise bloodlust is something which almost every warrior posseses.Alexander had assessed the psyche of a warrior aptly.In a battle or a fight to death tournament you cannot control your instincts to kill the enemy.

Puru and Alexander both were right in their own places.Also they do share a strange equation.I mean Sony Puru and Sony Alex.
And no this not the secret PorAnder shipper in me speaking.😆

As much as he denies it Alexander is fascinated and impressed by Puru.He was watching him keenly.Also during the fight Puru was staring at Alex from time to time.These two get into each other's skins.

velvetscarf thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Thanks for this Shyamala (I'm not young enough to call you Auntie) 😊
Interesting - I must admit I have got bored with Puru's heroics. Somehow he's been made quite unconvincing and boring while Alexander is still interesting despite the character assasination performed on him.
Jingoistic nationalism for a time when the nations we defend did not exist is puerile & so very shallow. Would we really have the courage to die for our countries?


inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
Hi Aunty,
You are absolutely right about Alexander's reputation. No one has ever accused him of using underhanded means to win a war. It is totally against his concept of honor and self-respect. The incident with Arrhidaeus sealed that for us. His name is of utmost importance and he will not resort to cheap tactics to outdo Puru at the expense of his name.

I know you'll say I'm being overly-optimistic about the CVs plans for Alexander but something tells me it might not be as bad as it seems. I am willing to be patient a bit longer. 😉 No matter how frustrating the past few episodes have been, I still believe this showdown is meant to lay the tracks for the ultimate battle. Both Alexander and Puru are trying to better understand each other's mindset.

Alexander, true to character, lion in the bushes, is still watching his prey very carefully. His eyes, the windows to his soul, say it all - he's got something major up his Persian sleeves. There is a reason we see so many close-ups of him. We're supposed to try to guess what is going on in that marvellous brain of his. Olympia is beginning to fret - her fear of losing her son because of the High Priestess' words is clouding her judgment. Otherwise, she would have understood right away what Alexander's game is. They are two bodies, one soul after all.

He reassures Olympia very calmly and is fully confident of his plan, which he doesn't seem to want to share with Hephaestion or her. Either it's to build suspense or it's because he's got a few chess moves figured out in his head and will pick one based on the outcome of Puru's gladiator exhibition, instead of jumping the gun. His body language shows that he is in total control of the situation and can aptly handle whatever comes his way. I must say, I don't like seeing Olympia like this all worried and lacking her usual fire. Have faith, my lady. Your son is the king of the jungle.

Alexander thinks Puru is here to learn more about Darius, and all this time he hasn't taken his eyes off Barsine, even though she thinks he's focused completely on Puru. This is the same warrior who noticed the mud on Faroos' shoes when casually walking past him in the evening. He told Barsine earlier that he was not looking to get answers from her anymore, but that may have been just to make her lower her guard.

At least we know one thing about Barsine: she's a very last minute person. Just like in Paurav Rashtra during the battle, here too she will make a move. Alexander saw the way she suddenly got up from her seat and this is the first time he's seen her do anything! He didn't put the sword on the other side of his chair for no reason. He's egging her on to do something and break her silence. I doubt she'll get far because Alexander would be expecting something and would be prepared for whatever it might be. Besides, she's standing too far from Olympia. There's no way she can get to her with both Alexander and Hephaestion there. We know she can use a sword but I don't think she's athletic enough to bypass Alexander even in his robes. 😆

If, by some miracle, she manages to do something drastic, Alexander will no longer consider her a mouse and may be more interested in this side of her. Maybe this is the "character development" we've all been wanting to see in her to make her a good fit for Alexander, someone he could actually fall for. Though my personal preference is for them to continue to have a formal and very platonic relationship as I pray and hope for Roxana to appear in the near future.

There is no way Alexander would order Puru to be killed. He's playing with his new toy and is more intrigued by Puru's thought process than the physical strength he displays in the arena. He's referred to Puru's intelligence a few times already. Unlike Hephaestion and Olympias, he's not shocked by Puru's performance in the arena. The more fighters he takes down, the more Alexander seems to be ticking mental boxes in terms of how correct his assessment of Puru has been so far. He even says out loud that he now understands how Puru thinks. Most importantly, he says towards the end of the episode that wars are won by using the brain and not brawn.

It's easy for Puru to lecture Alexander, but when it comes to survival, we do see his animal instinct come out. He would have speared the horse riders if they hadn't begged for mercy. He couldn't go against what he had preached in public earlier about the difference between Indians and Macedonians. Alexander wants to know how far Puru can be pushed before he drops his self-righteous behavior and ends up on the same plane as Alexander, as two fierce warriors.

I am also wondering if this is the extent to which he wants to push Barsine to get a reaction seeing her "lover" fatally wounded (if he does indeed still think they are lovers). He is impressed that Puru managed to sneak past his guards to get to Barsine, and if we continue on the lovers theory, then he knows this man will go to any lengths to protect near and dear ones or even just to fulfill a promise. He wants to continue to learn more about Puru's abilities and is probably thinking that if a regular person is this skilled, then what about the Indian army generals he's planning to meet and defeat in battle. Puru is currently his intriguing lab rat, if you like.😃 Killing Puru would be Alexander's loss, not gain.

I am pretty sure Alexander has something else in mind for both Barsine and Puru. He said he's four steps ahead of others, and the arrows being fired at Puru, if indeed that does happen, are just one or two out of the four steps. (I have to say that the CGI is very poor quality when showing arrows piercing Puru's body but I'll try and ignore this for now. 😆)

And let's not forget the most important thing:
Jiska Bhaarat se koi naata hai, woh shakhs Alexander ko bohot bhaata hai. 😉
Aur hum jaantein hain ke jo Alexander ko bhaata hai, woh unka bohot acchhe se khayal rakhta hai! 😆

For a change, I found the Paurav Rashtra bits interesting.

I believe Anusuya's growing attachment to Malay, even before knowing he was sent by Puru, is because she missed out on Puru's childhood. Seeing this boy triggers the feelings of lost opportunity of nurturing her son as he was growing up. Of course, once Malay tells her about Puru, her connection to her son is reconfirmed. She's even more determined to save his amaanat because Puru sent him to his family with the faith that they will look after the boy as one of their own. There is no way she will let Puru down. She was unable to save Puru and herself from persecution by Shivdutt many years ago, but she's wiser and shrewder now. Bamni will hear the truth this time.

Bamni is actually listening to his heart and can feel something's wrong with Anusuya. Besides, she's the one who convinced him to crown Kanishk as his heir, so why would she not want to be at the ceremony? He's learned from his mistakes so he is going to believe Anusuya and halt the proceedings, declaring that he'll wait for Puru's return. No one suspects Kanishk of anything so all eyes will be on Shivdutt who I expect will be punished or ostracized for trying to execute Malay. In any case, Kanishk will be enraged at missing out on being crown prince again and this will drive him to do something behind the scenes to harm Bamni. 😡

Puru will have to return home and take his rightful place either by force or by tactic before Kanishk makes things worse. I smell a Bamni assassination coming on and I just hope Puru will get to see him before his death. Experiencing this tragedy is the only way for him to mature and become a true leader so that he can eventually lead his army into battle. It was King Porus that battled with Alexander, not Prince Porus.

Sigh... I would be sad to see Bamni go now that he is just starting to really live properly, but I guess this is the circle of life.
Edited by inlieu - 7 years ago
inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: LawlessLawyer

Aunty I am keeping my fingers crossed that your prediction turns true and Alexander is merely playing a trick to understand Puru's fighting techniques and assess his skills.He doesn't intend to kill Puru but just immobilise him for a while and will prolly provide treatment for him.

If this doesn't come true then we all will have to resign to the fact that Swastik has indeed turned the lion into a wolf

TBH kroor,magroor,jallad,haivaan is one thing.But attacking in a tournament behind the back is simply cowardly and Alexander is anything but that.
It simply goes against everything his character has stood for till now even in Swastik's version.

Totally agree. They would be undoing all the hard work they put into his character growth that won us over.

Everything said and done,Alexander is NOT Darius.

Meanwhile Puru's Musketeers/Power Rangers/Teletubbies are doing their job well.
Just hoping that they don't get caught🤣

PR part was too good.Malay is such a cutie pie and got to see Anusuya in her fighter mode after a long time
Now I just hope that Dumbomini believes Malay and Anusuya in the precap _/\_
If he doesn't trust them then laanat hai uss par.

I think this time he will. Seeing her with a sword in his hand, possibly dripping with blood should confirm to him that his instinct about her being in trouble was right.
Last but not the least,couldn't they edit Puru's gorilla roar?🤢It was ridiculous tbh.

I think it's because of the conversation they had earlier about who's the lion, and Puru was roaring to show he was. 😆

Moreover my dad was watching it with me today and after Puru finished the dhulayi in Round 2 or Round 3,Dad was like,'Ab yeh zaroor dialogue maarega'😆

And Puru did give a short speech after that😆😆
If I didn't know better, I'd think Alexander had the archers take him down to spare the crowd more lectures.

Edited by inlieu - 7 years ago
inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: velvetscarf

Thanks for this Shyamala (I'm not young enough to call you Auntie) 😊

Interesting - I must admit I have got bored with Puru's heroics. Somehow he's been made quite unconvincing and boring while Alexander is still interesting despite the character assasination performed on him.
Jingoistic nationalism for a time when the nations we defend did not exist is puerile & so very shallow. Would we really have the courage to die for our countries?



I guess the makers are doing this for TRPs, which is such a shame considering the richness of historic material that can be used to great effect in this show.
inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: LawlessLawyer

BTW I noticed something during the fight.

When Puru defeated the second warrior,he was about to kill that guy in the heat of the moment.But then the guy folded hands and Puru stared at Alexander before sparing him.
It was as if he had become cautious that Alexander was watching him and was back on his guard.

Hey! I noticed this too, glad I'm not the only one. It shows that Puru is not superhuman.

Otherwise bloodlust is something which almost every warrior posseses.Alexander had assessed the psyche of a warrior aptly.In a battle or a fight to death tournament you cannot control your instincts to kill the enemy.

Puru and Alexander both were right in their own places.Also they do share a strange equation.I mean Sony Puru and Sony Alex.
And no this not the secret PorAnder shipper in me speaking.😆

🤣

As much as he denies it Alexander is fascinated and impressed by Puru.He was watching him keenly.Also during the fight Puru was staring at Alex from time to time.These two get into each other's skins.
We're all annoyed about the distortion of history showing these guys come face to face in Persia, but they could have done so much with the script to show the building tension and cat and mouse games.
It's such a shame they didn't develop this angle instead of these ridiculous slow-motion fight sequences!

Edited by inlieu - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".