Rukhsana ?? - Page 3

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Megha Riya

@MeghaRiya

Beginner

Posted: 7 years ago

#21

So in the serial, if they show that Porus won, there is all possibility that they might not be wrong... right???

Quote

luckySnow

@luckySnow

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Porus haara nhi tha. It is only the Greek records which state that he lost (Arrian who wrote using the references from Megesthenese and they were both Greeks), and no one will show themselves as losers. There are multiple situational proofs which suggest that Porus couldnt have lost

This is the reason modern day historians have accepted that they can not conclude the outcome/result of that war

LolLolz bhai there are persian albanian and many other records...😃 conspiracy theorists says allaudin also lost ...maharana won against akbar etc etc

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Priya

@Priya258

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: luckySnow

LolLolz bhai there are persian albanian and many other records...😃 conspiracy theorists says allaudin also lost ...maharana won against akbar etc etc

Ab kisike pass sahi record nai h sab historians ka alag alag dawa h apna story ab kisine us time live update toh nai kiya😆bus ab makers kuch bhi dikha sakte h

Quote

FlauntPesimism

@FlauntPessimism

Viewbie

+ 10

Posted: 7 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: MeghaRiya
So in the serial, if they show that Porus won, there is all possibility that they might not be wrong... right???

Exactly even the American movies dont show Alexander winning this war, they wither show Porus having an upper hand or totally ignore the end/result of the war

Quote

FlauntPesimism

@FlauntPessimism

Viewbie

+ 10

Posted: 7 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: luckySnow

LolLolz bhai there are persian albanian and many other records...😃 conspiracy theorists says allaudin also lost ...maharana won against akbar etc etc

PLease tell me which Persian/Albanian Record says so? None of those excluding the books of Alexandria which are again Greek source. The historians are nearly in consensus that the result of the war is not known that is why even the western movies made on Alexander omits the end/result of the war.

I am not talking about the conspiracy theorists at all. They even say Prithvi Raj killed Ghori (basis the records of Prithvi Raj Raso which was written in those days), but the historians do not agree to it, nor am I claiming its truth

Quote

FlauntPesimism

@FlauntPessimism

Viewbie

+ 10

Posted: 7 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: Priya258

Ab kisike pass sahi record nai h sab historians ka alag alag dawa h apna story ab kisine us time live update toh nai kiya😆bus ab makers kuch bhi dikha sakte h

Wahi kaha maine. The only records of that war are those which are Greek, the Indian records have not given much importance to that war. I am not saying with surety that Porus had won or that Alexander had not won, I am simply saying that historians have reached a rough consensus that they do not know who won that war, because the records and circumstantial evidences hint alternative endings, and either could be true, it could also be true that the result was practically a stale mate. This is a reason that the modern day movies on Alexander (made by westerners and not Indians mind it) no longer show Alexander winning but either show Porus having an upper hand or completely ignoring the end.

Yaar forget about 2336 BC even the war of 1965 between India and Pakistan is given different endings by each country with both celebrating a victory day for the result, so how can we be so sure about what happened millenniums back!!!! People have a tendency to show themselves the winners, so you can not completely rely on what one of the parties wrote