Episode Discussion Thread # 1 - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

293

Views

24.5k

Users

25

Likes

598

Frequent Posters

CatcherInTheRye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: BrenySana

I agree wit U BS! I really don't wanna hate this show.. After dat BD bullet incident I wasn't expecting this another irrelevant track..,I thought the cvs knew their mistake n thought would try to end it but I was wrong..I'm really annoyed to see this stupidity of emphasising on this new entry called Rani,,even if this idea of bringing this new girl was not required I was actually looking forward to it but from her entry itself I got so irritated..,all those ridiculous pointing guns at each other thing just doesn't make sense! Clearly she doesn't know how to act,the character she's playing is like the younger version of BD(not exactly) which should be Bold n Daring but she actually seems so desperate actually luks like she's imitating n doesn't come natural at all..it was so hard to watch! dat whole point she did with Sher including the Kiss was so reckless I couldn't understand anything..even she made Sher look so bad, I don't like Sher's behavior from dat point like why is he giving so important to her...
Really I loved the concept of this show,From the promo itself had a lot of expectations...but even at this point, I'm still waiting for the cvs to make it worth watching

Breny...yeah...bringing Rani was out of way...but after today's epi...we can understand a bit that she din't come in herself but is brought by Pandey n co. And Sher dealing with her ws also not irrelevant...bearing her is also not out of way...but bearing Shradha's insult is not ok for me🤢
And tomm. epi gonna more shocking...now the question arises to my mind is will Shradha trust Sher or not...now this is the question...but he won't come...m sure😳
now one more thing which is striking my mind is...after watching today's video clip...if Rani will accuse Sher..then how she is still there in his house...will he tolerate and accept that he did something like that with her???...lets see..how this unveils😊
Julie0001 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#32
@ peaches

Hello dear! I just wanted to say that I agree.
As many have said what was appealing here is that Sher is intelligent. I also like that he is funny and childish.

I know you disliked the revolver game but I wonder if it fits Sher's destructive tendencies. He is immature and appears not to have a direction in life. Shraddha is that moral compass. I kind of felt that having lost her he feels life is worthless.

But execution of scenes needs to be better. Where is the slow build up and storytelling? Why is he childishly gleeful that she is jealous because of a kiss. But in his eyes she is a murderer? This needs to be fixed fast.

The characters are lovely and have potential. There is a real sweetness here.

But they are becoming caricatures here. Shradda is a dutiful nag. Doesn't she know that Sher is morally ambiguous? What is all this business of protecting his morality? She chases after him so he does nothing immoral? This same man beat his brother to punish her. He is morally gray and she should have gray feelings towards him.

Sher's love at this point has bitterness in it and that is fine. His expression of love filled with hate is nice. But shouldn't he grapple with her guilt? Shouldn't he try to figure things out?

The show fell off course with too many plot twists. Instead they need character development and storytelling.
peachesandcream thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#33
@Julie
Interesting take on the revolver scene. You have made me look at it from a different angle. Certainly it could represent his immaturity. Maybe the impulsivity of youth.

Sher and Shraddha story started nicely even though it was rushed. His love for her and the desire for marriage but not under duress was nice. I liked his conflict after marriage when he came to know she was forced. He was hurt and conflicted and maybe a bit hopeful. They both committed in their own way to each other.

Virat angle had potential but was rushed through. Then the story lost focus. We did not get a clear understanding of when and how Shraddha developed feelings for Sher. Even after the misunderstanding, Sher was conflicted. He hurt her but in the process was hurt. He felt betrayed by her and had anger towards himself for being incapable of stopping his love.


The entrance of this Torture Rani has shifted the story and I don't know where it is headed. Sher has become dumb and bitter. He does not react to the kiss which is in front of his wife but reacts to the lipstick stain? He wants to touch her injured foot but just walks away after he saves her from Torture Rani?

In today's episode I can understand Sher playing along with Rani to find out what she is up to, but where is the disgust that he should feel when she comes close to him? Where is the guilt when his wife sees them?

Shraddha is the dutiful wife. The character right now is bland. The actress has improved somewhat but I feel part of the problem is that her character has not been fully developed by the writers yet.

Rani is getting too much screen time. Her expressions are OTT. The camera seems to like her bare midsection. I find her irritating and annoying.

The show started off well. The story has lots of potential. The main actors are great. I think the writers need to decide which direction they are headed and slow down and allow the characters to develop and also develop their relationships.
Edited by peachesandcream - 10 years ago
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#34

Morally grey? Jules, honey, as usual you are being too gracious. We have seen plenty of morally grey male protagonists. Even when they supposedly hated the female protagonists, there was still some level of concern for her pain, feelings and the viewers were aware of what and why the male lead was thinking or behaving in a particular manner. The male protagonist's inner conflict, his struggle with himself to suppress the love would be evident to the viewer.


I saw some potential in Gaurav, an ability to emote. But in the last few episodes none of the character's emotions are coming across. Either GSB is unhappy with the script and so is not able to convincingly emote or the writing, direction and editing sucks or it is a little bit of both.


Besides shock at seeing her in the den and anger that she showed up, I would have thought he would be a little worried, concerned and touched that she came there for him with her injured ankle putting herself in harm's way. Didnt see that, sadly.


Today, he wasnt the faintest bit uncomfortable with Rani throwing herself at him, wasnt at all concerned that Rani was insulting, disrespecting his wife. What kind of uncouth person would let the whole world know there are issues between him and his wife? Besides is befriending Rani the only way to know who is backing her?


There is no introspection, no reflection, no voice overs to clarify his thoughts or emotions to the viewers.


Ok I get that Momma's boy is furious with Shraddha but to stand around quietly watching someone demean, disrespect his wife is appalling. Sher is immature, irresponsible, brash, impulsive, egoistic, short tempered and lot of other things but underneath that exterior there was a good guy, sensitive, respectful and protectivein his own way, . Buy his behavior towards Shraddha in the past two episodes is just unforgivable. The last two episodes have killed the character of Sher for me. If the CVs continue like this, Sher will be remembered as one of the worst male protagonists in the history of desi soaps.

Yes, story telling and character development is required pronto to save the show.
Edited by Infofan - 10 years ago
CatcherInTheRye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: Infofan



I saw some potential in Gaurav, an ability to emote. But in the last few episodes none of the character's emotions are coming across. Either GSB is unhappy with the script and so is not able to convincingly emote or the writing, direction and editing sucks or it is a little bit of both.


Besides shock at seeing her in the den and anger that she showed up, I would have thought he would be a little worried, concerned and touched that she came there for him with her injured ankle putting herself in harm's way. Didnt see that, sadly


There is no introspection, no reflection, no voice overs to clarify his thoughts or emotions to the viewers.


Yes, story telling and character development is required pronto to save the show.

i so much agree with this Infofan...was about to post same thing...really...it seems that Gaurav is no more interested in the storyline or its something with editing......he could not emote his feelings and eprressions in last two episodes...he might not liking this sudden twist in the story...bringing Rani in🥱. But he could not get that attention from me as Sher which he used to...though following the show from kinda beginning...one can undersatnd...n can compromise a bit...but can't for long. the team neds to work on editing and story line both.
Don't know why they are in so much hush for this to bring Sherdha closer soon...yaar they could drag the story..or simply let the charachters develop a bit mature...🥱

he simply said she is my wife...and after that nothing...🥱...and in last epi..when Rani came to Haveli..shradha was having arguement with her...he was all njoying...cm'on yaar...wth🤢

really nothing...for green...i mean...nothing...kuj to ho from where we can make something that yeah they are doing this or thinking this...viewers are not able to understand their xpressions..either the actors are no more interested n feeling useless...or the editing sucks🤢
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#36
Phew finally...Sher - Shraddha scene today was not too bad, compared to what we have been getting lately.
He snapped at her when she called, a little irritable when talking to her but there was a tinge of affection in the tone. Even in the irritability there was a softness. Shraddha stumped him when she replied she kept calling him because he would not answer the phone. Sher even had a small smile when he realized Shraddha is planning something for his birthday.

Sumer and Sher interaction was cute too especially when he slipped up and told Sumer 'your bhauji' before correcting himself and called her madamji again.

These two little interactions were like a breath of fresh air, after ages.

And... for a change, Sher was aware of Rani deliberately throwing herself at him, even moved his hand from hers once. Some change from the last few days of just letting himself get mauled by her with no expression on his face.

The rest I forwarded 😆

Dear CVs - the feedback I am getting from everyone is that Rani is doing a super job of lowering the TRPs. 👍🏼
Edited by Infofan - 10 years ago
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#37
Oh yay Shraddha smiled today. 😛 It was tiring to see her cry, look disgusted or scared 😆

Tomorrow I guess she goes back to crying.
peachesandcream thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#38
I actually thought Sher was a bit too irritable with Shraddha today. I missed the affection in his face, probably because we have seen Gaurav do so much better with his expressions. I think I would like to see a little more disgust on his face when Rani is all over him.
Looking for the positives, I did like the scene with Sher and Sumer. I also liked the bonding between Shraddha, Sunheri and Gajra.

Unfortunately the presence of Torture Rani is just too overpowering and the character is being given too much screen time. She and her background music need to given a little break.
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: peachesandcream

I actually thought Sher was a bit too irritable with Shraddha today. I missed the affection in his face, probably because we have seen Gaurav do so much better with his expressions. I think I would like to see a little more disgust on his face when Rani is all over him.

Looking for the positives, I did like the scene with Sher and Sumer. I also liked the bonding between Shraddha, Sunheri and Gajra.

Unfortunately the presence of Torture Rani is just too overpowering and the character is being given too much screen time. She and her background music need to given a little break.



Agreed, Torture Rani is doing a great job of torturing us. 😆 I dont think the CVs have a story to show us hence passing time by torturing us with Rani. Its like they are just throwing characters in to create MUs between Sherdha. Like there werent enough MU already.

I was comparing his irritability today to his behavior with her yesterday. I was appalled at the way he snapped at her yesterday when she took the agarbatti to his room. He was dismissive, rude with Shraddha in the whole episode and just standing around happily watching Rani insult and demean his wife. Compared to that he was a little softer today and then the slight smile when he realizes she might be planning something for his birthday was nice too.

I maybe grasping at straws here but I noticed a little improvement in his interactions with Rani too. Atleast they showed him being aware she is upto something, deliberately trying to get close to him unlike last few days when there was no reaction or change of expression on his face when she threw herself at him.

I am not thrilled with what we saw today but did feel there was a little difference overall.
Its nice to see Sumer be given some dialogues and nice to see the bonding between the three ladies. A little positivity after ages.
Edited by Infofan - 10 years ago
cactusbutt1123 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#40
When ever virat would try to touch shraddha , she would show a strong repulsion towards him.I loved that about her,and was expecting sher to do the same but his behavier towards rani is not justified at all.

i mean yes sher you are thinking about the bigger picture but how on earth does that make sense rani and pandey are in a team to help kill your enemies and start afresh like you? lol really ? after you Ripped off Pandeys reputation in front of the world you think he'll forget it all and play partner -partner with you? lol such a sensless plot.

And sher should take back the " JO INSAAN AURATOON KI IZZAT NAHI KARTA WOH SABSE BADA DHAKKAN HAI" Dialogue because hey forget other women you don't respect your own wife.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".