Exclusive feedback to Creative team of PR(pg#1 updt)

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

amrapali dubey

@amrapali_dubey

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

#11

The upcoming track where a new girl will enter n create problem for sherdha is very typical track Cvs... Plz Cvs don't ruin the charm of the show...the essence of Piyarangrezz lies in sher's obsessive love for shraddha n how he will go to any extent to protect his love...it's about how their relation evolves...as it is sherdha r going through a tough time n viewers r eagerly waiting for sherdha to b together... New entrant will prolong the track n unnecessarily stretch it...ppl myt start losing interest in the show n this will b very disheartening to see...

Plz Cvs it's a sincere request to plz warp up this track soon...let piya rangrezz not lose its charm.. Plz Cvs

Quote

Infofan

@Infofan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#12

I started watching PR because a few of my friends found Sher's characterization interesting. I usually avoid shows that are based in rural settings and although evil, devious, scheming mother-in-laws plotting to separate the main protagonists are common, I found a gun-toting 'bijiness' woman amusing enough to give PR a shot.

I caught up on the episodes from the beginning in FF mode and found Sher to be interesting as well with his one-liners and him being completely aware of the scope of his mom's evil tactics and standing up to her.

Almost all Hindi soaps butcher the leads characterization and even the story after a good build-up but that is mostly after the show has been on air for a few months.

Here in PR the CVs couldnt even wait for 30 episodes to turn the male protagonist into a dumb puppet in his mom's hands. How can a person who has grown up amid guns and bullets not be aware that a bullet wound on the arm can not kill a person who was rushed to the hospital immediately after being shot? His mama's bullet was removed without anesthesia and he is walking about, talking away yet Sher believes his mom is dying?????????

Initially I thought he was pretending to be furious with Shraddha or blaming her for his mom's condition in shock but sadly all the articles, BTS and interviews prove otherwise.

I am extremely disappointed at the turn the show has taken in the one week since I started watching the show. The latest promo of Sher breaking Shradha's mangalsutra and threatening to make her life hell is ... pukeworthy. If that is the route the show is taking..of torturing Shradha, I am not going to watch PR. There are plenty of other options on TV.

Watching the female protagonist being physically, emotionally, verbally abused and her turning into a doormat or sacrificing for the sake of the greater good of saving ... her marriage or whatever else is NOT entertaining or appealing. I dont know any of these actors and am certainly not going to watch a show because GSB looks hot in his leather jacket. Though I have to admit he was damn fine in the drunken scene last night but still its not reason enough for me to keep watching regressive, cliched tracks.

Nothing against the actors or their portrayal of their characters. My disappointment is with the CVs, the channel and PH.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Infofan

@Infofan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#13

What was the rush to get Sher and Shradha married? Per the initial promos Sher was pursuing Shradha in college. They could have spent some time on that track even if they had to eventually get them married with BD threatening Shradha and her family.

Sher could still have been pining for her and Shradha could have avoided him or keeping her interaction with him to the minimum out of fear ( before marriage). So Sher wouldnt have known she is not in love with him and they wouldnt have got to know each other much still leaving scope for future misunderstandings.

Edited by Infofan - 10 years ago

Quote

Infofan

@Infofan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#14

Thanks to Babbar Sher for providing this platform to express our thoughts. I hope the CVs do consider them.

Quote

Julie0001

@Julie0001

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#15

@ infofan, you go girl!!!!

Ha Ha I loved it. I hope the CVs read your post. It is like they had a good thing and then they turned it 180?

Why the rush? You are right. Let's just enjoy Shradda slowly falling in love. That would be the best part. Instead they make her seem like a doormat. Where is her disgust with this horrible family? THere should have been a culture difference.

I though Virat was going to be exposed slowly. In 3 days he hatched some evil master plan.

And then why was Shradda's dad and mom not happy to see her back?

AND? Why can't Shradda be smart and hatch a plan to prove herself innocent? Why does she keep apologizing? Didn't she lead some campaign in India. Lordy!

Quote

CatcherInTheRye

@CatcherInTheRye

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#16

Stab me someone stab me...🤣...m happy with the whole track...i don't want Shradha and Sher to do chooci koo soon...m njoyin Sher's angst ...he being anguish...Shradha needs to give him some time..and understand him well...she needs to make a strong base for their relation...so that it becomes fevicol ka jod..😆..which is unbreakable...i find Sher's action justified...ad i don't find Shradha a doormat...whatever she is doing is all according to her will now..none has forced her this time...so m loving this roothna manana...*sadistic pleasure*

Edited by BabbaR_SheR - 10 years ago

Quote

Infofan

@Infofan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Julie0001
@ infofan, you go girl!!!!

Ha Ha I loved it. I hope the CVs read your post. It is like they had a good thing and then they turned it 180?

Why the rush? You are right. Let's just enjoy Shradda slowly falling in love. That would be the best part. Instead they make her seem like a doormat. Where is her disgust with this horrible family? THere should have been a culture difference.

I though Virat was going to be exposed slowly. In 3 days he hatched some evil master plan.

And then why was Shradda's dad and mom not happy to see her back?

AND? Why can't Shradda be smart and hatch a plan to prove herself innocent? Why does she keep apologizing? Didn't she lead some campaign in India. Lordy!

Jules, welcome to the forum. Its funny that I get to welcome you here.😆

I started watching last week I believe, took a couple days to catch up on previous episodes and by the time I was done catching up and beginning to understand the story and characters, the whole direction of the story changed. WTH. They couldnt sustain a logical plot beyond 30 episodes??

I just realized the PH is Sphere origins, the Balika Vadhu folks and the ones who screwed up SC and Kumud. Satyanaash. I dont have much hope from PR now.

Oh well, I will watch for a bit and decide later. Its not like BD is holding a gun to my kaan patti 😆

Till then I can rant away on this thread unless Babbar Sher throws me out😉

Quote

Infofan

@Infofan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#18

When Sher picked up the yellow saree that Shraddha dropped while packing, couldnt it have reminded him of his mom's devious games and her history with Shraddha? Couldnt that have raised some doubts about this whole scenario in the man who had brains till episode 30?

Quote

CatcherInTheRye

@CatcherInTheRye

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: Infofan

Jules, welcome to the forum. Its funny that I get to welcome you here.😆

I started watching last week I believe, took a couple days to catch up on previous episodes and by the time I was done catching up and beginning to understand the story and characters, the whole direction of the story changed. WTH. They couldnt sustain a logical plot beyond 30 episodes??

I just realized the PH is Sphere origins, the Balika Vadhu folks and the ones who screwed up SC and Kumud. Satyanaash. I dont have much hope from PR now.

Oh well, I will watch for a bit and decide later. Its not like BD is holding a gun to my kaan patti 😆

Till then I can rant away on this thread unless Babbar Sher throws me out😉

Dear Infofan

Why you think that show has lost the logical plot??

As if they will drag the same thing then too we ll complain...if they are bringing some twists...we complain then too...they started with a bad guy falling for a girl..and proposing her...which ultimately lead to rejection and the pressurized marriage...and after that whole track is going on that basis i think...some masal is the need of the show...its not any Pak show which will end in 20-30 epis..after all Indian soap it is😆...but m hppy that they are not dragging anything as other soaps do...SC was a thingy which Bansali sir tried but could not get along that...don't know what happened to that😆...vese i always love your quote in the signature box...from the day one i saw you in Zindagi forum😉

but just a friendly suggestion...just wait and watch...i hope PR won't disappoint u like SC or BV😛

Why would i throw you out🤣??

Thread is about feedback and suggestions...so you can give them freely...but please...refrain from bashing...so that it doesn't get closed🤣

Quote

angelpureness

@angelpureness

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#20

@ info fan

I saw or analysed the scenes differently. I don't recall all dialogues, but I do recall what my views were in the scene. I could be wrong.

The yellow sari scene, I thought it reminded Sher how deviant his mum is and can be, and also reminded him how helpless Shradha is.

I get this feeling, that he knows his mum is playing a game. I think he wants to find out for himself what is going on. I felt there was a huge hint when he let panditji go.

Another was when Shradha had first helped first escape by informing him that Sher was on his way, then the second attempt on his mum's life. He yelled at her about lack of trust. His reason to break the marriage was trust.

When he dropped her to her parents, I thought it was more for her benefit, yes he is hurting, but I think he is distancing himself coz of his mum's deviousness, coz time and again he has told her to stop her games. When he was at her parents, he said, I know what you want to say when you don't say it. That got me thinking that he must have read confusion.

When he broke her mangalsutra, he flipped about virat. I think him pursuing virat is because of Shradha. He can hardly scream... How dare you take my woman... He hence the tune is how dare you try to kill my mum.

Don't give up on his intelligence yet. He is feeling betrayed, jealous, heart broken... Hence is not that bothered with the game his mum is playing.

Gosh it is quite a ramble... Blame the sleepless night. Hope there is some sense in what I have written.