Dear Drmsnap, while reading your opinion, I felt, I must clear some points...
Originally posted by: Drmsnap
@ Venesa. Thanks for the reply.
Respect your views. And agree to them too. I'm not defending Adi in any way , he was wrong at a lot of levels but just wanted to know why Adi was hated so much here. You did convince me to some extent , but I still don't blame him for doing the sar dhakai as gulabiya forced him and even TVS had his own selfish motive to let him do it. I never actually liked adi's character from beginning but just wanted to express my view that I don't feel he backstabbed TVS. Now lusting is a big word , you used it so simply. I think he fell in love with her after knowing the real person in her , it wasn't lust. But again he knew that his mamaji loved her and she did too , so that was eww for me but I guess that's why people say pyar Kiya nahin jata , ho jata hai 😆
For riwa , you're right I guess I missed that part because I thought TVS had kept her there , he used to go meet her , take stuff for her and if he didn't mean to why didn't he take her out after he found out about that ? In that case he did lie to sugni. And no girl , no matter how much the other person loves her would or let me say should tolerate that he lied about him being married. So for me TVS was wrong there. Still I didn't hate him.
But what he said to sugni on wedding day , nothing ever would justify that. Even if he saw her with Adi , and I think he never gave her the chance to answer not that she didn't have the answer , but any ways even if she didn't have the answer, he didn't trust her ( that's understandable under circumstances ) but what he said showed he still thought of her as a bedni Just like other thakurs ..
Same way what Adi has said about sugni in past few episodes, nothing done or said justifies that. He thought of her as a bedni too.
And I agree with you what Adi did to Amrita (though was for family but still not right ).
The only character I had much respect in the whole show was TVS but his character was assassinated long back and I don't think at this point he deserves sugni.
First of all, I think it isn't right to judge TVS's motive as Selfish. Any true lover would do the same what he did. Remember what TVS had said while taking out the cashes, "I know Sugni what you're going to do. But I will never let you ruin your life." TVS knew that Sugni,feeling cheated in love, had arranged her sardhakai out of depression, mental trauma...
Now if you love your partner so much, you can't leave him/her in such a danger just because your partner is emotionally disturbed. TVS knew that, at that time Sugni wouldn't let him do her sardhakai(he feared that she might even kill herself) & to save her, Adi's proposal was the only positive option to him. So he didn't chose that, rather he was insisted(by fate) to do that..
It's not a selfish motive for your own self, rather it's a selfish motive for the person you love...2nd, I believe that when you love a person, you mean it wholeheartedly. And you will never leave him/her unless it's for his/her betterment(in other words, you sacrifice him/her because that, you think, will make his/her life good).
Adi, in the starting episodes, has no special feeling for Amrita but then on a fine morning.being influenced by TVS's words, he decided to marry Amu & they got engaged. Well. Amu left after the failure of V-S wedding & Adi didn't go to bring her back. Fine. But the clashes started to occur when he got ready to marry Sugni. Even he didn't feel to inform the lady whom he was engaged to. And on her sudden arrival on the wedding day, he started to claim that he still love her but doing all these to save mama-mami marriage. How could he even expect his fiance to stand by him when he was going to marry another woman? Only in the name of love? Sorry. All the time he was busy to explain his helplessness.Did he ever try to understand what Amu was going through? NO. But again the paper-pieces, the photos, the tears claimed that he loves Amu. What rubbish!
Then again on a fine evening, he discovered that he loves Sugni. Even though he knew how much the two(v&s) love each other, he didn't hesitate to go close to her.
Love is not to live with your partner, but to live for your partner & let him/her live. Adi completely killed the idea if what he has with Sugni is called Love...
3rd, If you've watched those episodes you've obviously found that TVS tried many a times to tell the truth. He gathered courage many a times.But after that temple part, where Sugni told him that she would kill herself if his wife is found alive, he probably lost it out of fear of losing her.
Of course he has hidden the truth. He has done wrong. But ,at the same time, we must also admit that he has fallen victim to situation/fate and he is still paying for it.
4th, Reva had already planted the seed of doubt in his mind with the amazing proofs she had against Adini & moreover he found both Sugni & Adi in bridal attire on reaching house. That no doubt had added oil. But I also feel upset to hear something like that from TVS.
Lastly, Adi, I think, is nowhere comparable with TVS, be it decency, ,bravery, intelligence, values or treatment to others. All he knows, I've found till date, is getting angry easily, doubting, quarreling & abusing others physically. And to my knowledge, that can never define a man, forget about the hero...
Hope, I am clear with my points ...
Thank you.
Edited by M0uNi - 12 years ago