Your take on NEW Aditya Singh - Page 3

Poll

Are you liking the new adi(Nandish)

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

4.6k

Users

22

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Sweet_Krishna

I watched last few episodes, Nandish is gradually fitting into the shoes of Aditya.Those who have watched him in Uttaran should come out of the mindset that he would look good only as loving husband or son role. It is a good opportunity for him to break that image of Veer because I think he has the potential.An actor should be able to play diverse roles and display diverse emotions rather than being stereotyped.

I feel he is dooing a good job. We should not jump the gun but give him bit more time.He has started consolidating himself in this show.
Anuj was good too but I could see in this forum people being very critical of him. Let us not start the similar thing about Nandish and let him prove his acting prowess. For this we need to be little patient 😊 rather than judging him from the very first day.

I have to disagree here. Please do not take offense to my post, but no actor should be given any patience. When you set foot on stage it is a professional environment and either you know how to act or you don't. This is not a school where you learn. Either an actor knows how to act, or they don't. I don't understand why people are of the mindset that an actor can learn while on a show. If they have not learned in a classroom setting, then what are they doing on a television show in front of millions of people? Acting is one of the fields that is subject to critism and feedback and only an arrogant actor will consider he or she is doesn't need it or should not pay attention.
If Nandesh is doing a good job, he deserves praise, but here, a majority of people don't appreicate him in the role. It is because we have become accustomed to seeing Anuj in the part. While he might have not been the strongest actor, we were appreciated him in the role and it suited him. His decision to leave might have been an attempt on the part of the CVs to find another actor whom they thought might appeal to the audience as the lead...they might have thought, let me get an actor who is popular so we can push for the Adi-Sugni jodi.
Bringing in actor who was in the number 1 show of Colors might actually have worked, but this shows that audiences are easily swayed by who is playing a part rather than who is the actor. A lot of new fans have joined ths how perhaps pushing for the jodi of Sugni and Aditya rather than having watched the show from the start.
Edited by Laila2009 - 13 years ago
Sweet_Krishna thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Laila2009

I have to disagree here. Please do not take offense to my post, but no actor should be given any patience. When you set foot on stage it is a professional environment and either you know how to act or you don't. This is not a school where you learn. Either an actor knows how to act, or they don't. I don't understand why people are of the mindset that an actor can learn while on a show. If they have not learned in a classroom setting, then what are they doing on a television show in front of millions of people? Acting is one of the fields that is subject to critism and feedback and only an arrogant actor will consider he or she is doesn't need it or should not pay attention.

If Nandesh is doing a good job, he deserves praise, but here, a majority of people don't appreicate him in the role. It is because we have become accustomed to seeing Anuj in the part. While he might have not been the strongest actor, we were appreciated him in the role and it suited him. His decision to leave might have been an attempt on the part of the CVs to find another actor whom they thought might appeal to the audience as the lead...they might have thought, let me get an actor who is popular so we can push for the Adi-Sugni jodi.
Bringing in actor who was in the number 1 show of Colors might actually have worked, but this shows that audiences are easily swayed by who is playing a part rather than who is the actor. A lot of new fans have joined ths how perhaps pushing for the jodi of Sugni and Aditya rather than having watched the show from the start.

Laila,I am not offeneded 😃 .But let me tell you I have watched the show from the start and I follow the updates here too.I am not baised towards Nandish because, I have watched Uttaran too from day 1, however not following it seriously after the current leap.I have found him as a good actor; again that is my perception which might not conform to your or what you call majority thinking in this forum.Finally when someone else steps into other actor's shoes he/she brings with him his/her own way of doing things. Anuj cannot be Nandish and vice-versa.So we need to think from that POV too.
By the way as I said earlier, I found Anuj too a convincing actor though people here were comparing him with a seasoned one like Varun Badola without realising that his character and his part and his dialogues were being sketched out by the writer. I donot know why he had to be replaced in the first place. May be audience criticised his acting or he was being continuously relegated to the background inspite of being promised to a meatier role by the channel as he claimed or date problems as producers told or for TRPs sake.Who knows the inside story??
As far as Aditya Sugni or Vikram Sugni pair is concerned, I am not bothered because I do not believe in such pairings or chemistry. I like to watch a serial for content and creativity.
Moreover if fans are pushing for Aditya Sugni, then wasn't this being propagated by the show makers in the beginning?
Saviosaraff thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23
Yes Pyar-Ishk this thought came to my mind too when i first saw Nandish. TJs son would have been more suitable for the role. TJ, TVS, Gulb & Sug make you sit at the edge with their performances. TJ & TVS are true Thakur material. But Adi's peformance is 👎🏼, maybe a bit of Gul and Sug may rub on him and improve his performance.
Saviosaraff thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24
Sweet_Krishna I have never been a Varun Badola fan infact i never used to watch his serials coz i never liked his appearance. this is the first show i watched of his and his performance was awesome. Sugni is a newcomer but her acting skills have had everyone going crazy over her, infact it made even a seasoned actor like Varun compliment her. So Nandish needing time to get into the character is just out of the question. Either he can act the role or he cannot it is for the audience if they want to accept him as a Thakur based on his performance in PSH or as a candy boy in Uttaran.
stephhh thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
wow 62% hating new Aditya aka Nandish...
stephhh thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: XAiShBaBy08X

I still think it's strange that Anuj left. Aditya's character is just now getting to be important.


I definitely don't think Nandish is suited as the role of a modern thakur. I agree with some of you and think his voice is just too soft. There is no power in his voice or stance.

I actually didn't like that Anuj, in the beginning, was going to the be the main lead...but then I saw that he did a good job. I wish he hadn't left. He also looked better with Sugni...when compared to Nandish.



maybe cvs decided to make aditya role important after anuj left the show...
Gewels thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27
Anuj leaving was probably a wake-up call 4 them. I also think they were surprised how much support he has-in my opinion he suited the role of Aditya to the T. The new TAS just doesn't cut it-sorry. IMO they should go cap in hand & beg Anuj to come back.
jakther7 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#28
i always wanted to this replacement but still i m not satisfied with this New change i wanted to see someone who is very handsome & hott, becoz i think now Lead hero & also his pair with the heroine is very much important to gain more audience ,sorry i know comparison is not allowed in IF, but i want to give one example about it,instead of weak story line now Arnav Khushi is the most popular jodi in the TV & also their show is popular, i think it's only becoz of their jodi, but PSH has very strong story line but till it's not as popular as other show, & i think it's only becoz of their lacking chemistry be2en Lead pairs, I like Sugni-TVS pair, but i really don't think it's attracted people so much specially the young generation , That's why in stead of being more strong story lines PSH is still not is Top ten in TRP chat , sorry no offense it's only personal opinion .
Gewels thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: jakther

i always wanted to this replacement but still i m not satisfied with this New change i wanted to see someone who is very handsome & hott, becoz i think now Lead hero & also his pair with the heroine is very much important to gain more audience ,sorry i know comparison is not allowed in IF, but i want to give one example about it,instead of weak story line now Arnav Khushi is the most popular jodi in the TV & also their show is popular, i think it's only becoz of their jodi, but PSH has very strong story line but till it's not as popular as other show, & i think it's only becoz of their lacking chemistry be2en Lead pairs, I like Sugni-TVS pair, but i really don't think it's attracted people so much specially the young generation , That's why in stead of being more strong story lines PSH is still not is Top ten in TRP chat , sorry no offense it's only personal opinion .

Ur post reminds me of that saying 'Be carefull what u wish 4; it might just come true' You raise a good point-who is this show appealing to? It would b interesting to know the audience 4 PSH. I agree with u- Sugvi didn't look 2 good together IMO. AS looked far more likely with her, & i don't know/think cv's had much time to replace AS, which is maybe why they came up with Nandish. He is a good actor, but not as TAS. He looks & sounds so soft i could mould him like clay in my hands. Cv's didn't really handle the role of TAS properly, & paid 4 it.
ek_nai_paheli thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
Sorry, but I am not at all happy with the new Aditya... he is far too different from the original character, he does not suit the character and neither is his acting, and even his voice comes out as very weak where as Anuj had a great voice to go with his character. I wish the CVs had chosen someone a little younger (Nandish looks older for this role), and someone more suitable. This has taken away from the character and the interest of people. This Aditya is way too weak compared to the original. I hope they do something soon to improve this character. No offence to Nandish, but the people who choose the replacements, should make sure they have the right person to fit the role. Many times they bring in replacements, and they actually work (like Manav in Pavitra Risha). Hiten is not Sushant, but he is doing a great job and it was so easy to accept him. In fact I like Hiten better than Sushant. Please CVs it would be great to see a younger and more aggressive character in this role.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".