Can Abeer be a good husband ? Share your views - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

90

Views

5.6k

Users

14

Likes

193

Frequent Posters

.SSSS. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: -Amri-


I feel you, bud😊 That was completely irresponsible on his part. Not to mention, could've led to potentially tragic consequences for that girl. This is one of a few things in BD which got me wanting to wish for partial amnesia...😆

I will be frank with you- I've stopped watching the series, because I could no longer relate to Abeer and Meher's pairing. Meher, I can identify with most of the time. Sure, she has her faults too- she can be quite bull-headed herself, not to mention, a lil myopic. But at least I can see where she's coming from.

Abeer on the other hand- his recklessness and impulsiveness didn't endear himself to me and unfortunately I couldn't see any credence in his characterization anymore.
@Red Exactly.. even though today I can see Meher did some faults too... I can see where she is coming from...But for Abeer, I can't see reasons for many.. I just wish I can forget or act like as if they were never happened... or as if I had never seen them...😳

IntrovertedDame thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: sharoon3210


Yes & because of that Tayiji wanted to punish Devki by ruining Meher's life. For her, revenge is more important than the children's happiness.


So how is that Devki's fault? What can she do is Tayji is a psycho?😕 How could she anticipate that her niece will fall in love with the rich man's nephew?
Edited by -Amri- - 9 years ago
IntrovertedDame thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: .SSS.



Not just bua.. Fruit vendor was also blamed in previous comment... It was mentioned that...
Fruit vendor should be careful on road.. 😵 Kuch bhee!


All these comments come from the Abhijeet Bhattacharya school of thought- that singer who compared poor people sleeping on pavements to dogs.

I guess none of us should venture out on the roads, only the rich and the powerful should. Because in case we get hit by their cars, it's totally our fault.

I am sorry for being harsh, but I am pretty touchy about this topic🤓

BTW, May I know your name, dearie? I am Amrutha😊
Edited by -Amri- - 9 years ago
.SSSS. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: -Amri-


All these comments come from the Abhijeet Bhattacharya school of thought- that singer who compared poor people sleeping on pavements to dogs.

I guess none of us should venture out on the roads, only the rich and the powerful should. Because in case we get hit by their cars, it's totally our faults.

I am sorry for being harsh, but I am pretty touchy about this topic🤓

BTW, May I know your name, dearie? I am Amrutha😊



Oh damn! I know where these comments came from. I was already pulling my hair at that time

I am Sapna..Oh, finally I got a chance to know your name Amrutha.. how I wish I'm in a better mood now.


Edited by .SSSS. - 9 years ago
IntrovertedDame thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: .SSS.


Oh damn! I know where these comments came from. I was already pulling my hair at that time

I am Sapna..Oh, finally I got a chance to know your name Amrutha.. how I wish I'm in a better mood now.


That's okay😊 Hi Sapna!😳
cool_kriti thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#76
Hi all @sharon @mallikas @shrutiravi Thanks for keeping this post active...😆I was out of town and hence could not reply 😆I read few posts and I want to continue and say few things about the discussion here-
1) I would never try to justify Abeer's past actions but there are a few things that haunt me about his past. 😆 One thing is that I agree Abeer's actions were not justified. But if ABeer was 75% wrong, then Meher was 25% wrong too and nobody sees that. I wonder why. Meher was all the time trying to be perfect Bahu and she did not give any time for her husband.. She did not stand up and speak what she wanted. She could have easily told Taiji or Kuber that she wants to be at home to spend sometime with her husband, but she never did that which makes me think Meher was as immature as Abeer was... She could have told Taiji that she needed her money back because she needs to repay bua's loan.. She seems to be all the time trying to be perfect bahu.🥱 Being a perfect bahu is good but to that extent that you forget your husband is not good to me... Maybe thats why ABeer was against having a baby. If Meher cant spend time for her husband, how will she spend time for her baby?? AT that time also can she be in office leaving all responsibilities to ABeer ?? leaving her baby to Abeer to take care? I see that all the time Abeer is being blamed for not taking up Meher's interests.. But did Meher ever take up Abeer's interests?? I never saw her encouraging ABeer in his work or anything.. Marriage is not a one way thing...Imagine Abeer's position where everybody laughing and ridiculing him for not doing anything and on the other side even Meher would not devote any time for him...Abeer did not marry Meher to take care of his father's office... So Meher is also very much at fault here...Taali do haath se hi bhajti hai...

2) I am not blaming bua for going to court and giving evidence against Kuber's brother. I think she did the right thing and I like her character for that... SHe had the guts to do that...Only thing I dont like about bua is that she keeps influencing Meher's decision... Like she knows Meher does not like Akshat but still keeps on influencing her decisions... If Abeer can be blamed for taking decision on behalf of Meher then why not bua??

3) My point about this discussion is whether a person can be forgiven for a small fault as being immature or not... Yes you read that right - SMALL FAULT... In this world where many men treat women like an object of pleasure, in this world where marital rapes , having affairs are so prominent , a small thing like immaturity does not seem a big fault to my eyes atleast... Not something that cant be rectified... COme on... This guy only loved his wife all his life... No matter what silly reasons he left her, he came back with the same love he had for her...Thats the biggest quality... Being loyal to a single girl is so rare nowadays where breakups and divorces are so common ...A girl should thank God million times if she gets a loyal husband like Abeer... We all have flaws... We all are irresponsible/immature sometimes... Does that mean we are all bad?? Ek galti ko maafi mil sakti hai ya phir sirf zindagi bhar Sazaa...?? Every human does mistakes and learns from them like how Abeer learnt from his immaturity... Now its time that Meher forgives him...😊


Edited by cool_kriti - 9 years ago
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#77
@cool_kriti: That is what I was wondering that how come you have not posted. But it is always good to exchange views so we get to learn from each other. I agree with you that Abeer's actions cannot be justified & I said the same thing to those who bashes him. I too said the same thing. Meher didn't spend quality time with Abeer. If they had done that things would have been different. They were saying that romance is his priority. But that is only a part of it. They didn't even go for the honeymoon for Taiji. Devki bua was bold to testify against KM's brother. It is a good thing but Taiji in turn ruined Meher's life to take revenge from Devki. Even I had mentioned that even Meher was responsible for the divorce it to some extent. even if she was working, it was not a big deal for Meher to take out some time for Abeer. There is a saying that a person will always have time for the one who they love the most. Though Abeer was sent for official purpose, he came back on the same day. Yes, a lot was expected from him but it was an excuse to keep the couple away. But it did not affect the business. Abeer always had time for Meher. This shows how much he loves her. Even Meher could have taken out some time for him. She became an ideal DIL but not an ideal wife. I fully agree with you that if they had a child, Meher would leave it to Abeer & would have neglected him too. Unless, there is an understanding between the couple, it will affect the child. No child wants their parents to fight.

@mallikas: I too wish this show could have extended a bit more. Ishaan did a good job today. It was good to see Akshat blasting Meher for not being honest. I had predicted that Akshat will finally tell her to settle with Abeer & that's what happened. You said nothing is wrong if a person being in love with an ex can move on with someone else. But my dear, unfortunately, that does not work. Akshat's reason for being insecure is justified. He stood by Meher in those 8 years. He loved & accepted her despite knowing her past. But after saying yes to Akshat, she is still in love with Abeer. You gave me some examples of love triangle but If you have broken up with someone you loved & you fall for the second one, the first love becomes your past. If you see Rajnigandha starring Dinesh Thakur, Amol Palekar & Vaijentimala you will find that the heroine sticks to Amol Palekar at the end. I gave you an example of Rehna hai tere dil main in which there was a confrontation between Saif & Diya on the marriage date. In Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam, Aishwarya Rai was in love with Salman Khan but had forcefully married Ajay Devgan. He too got pissed off at Aishwarya for hiding the fact that she loves Salman. If Meher marries Akshat, he would only have her physical presence but mentally & emotionally, she would be involved with Abeer. Nobody wants only the physical presence of their spouse. They expect them to be with them with all their mind & soul along with their physical presence.
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: cool_kriti


You are wrong here...Abeer never owns any woman as a property...He did not come to herlife on his own... SHe landed herself in his life just to prove that she can sign his monthly cheque...Abeer has proved already many times that he can handle responsibilities if needed... In tunnu's case, in Meher's case , in SUman's case... In Ishaan's case... what more should he have to prove I dont understand... He pleads Meher many times saying not to punish herself and others by going away from him which is very true... Ok, According to audience if Abeer leaves Meher alone and Meher lands up marrying Akshat ...I think the audience will be happy then seeing Meher's life being spoiled... Or maybe even then Abeer would be blamed for leaving Meher alone😆😆 No offence...

Abeer is asked to move on in life and leave Meher alone... When he does exactly that by accepting Sasha he's blamed...I dont get the point... Meher bhi doodh se dhuli nahi hai...



Exactly, Poor Abeer. He is bashed everytime only because of his immaturity & impulsiveness. But even Meher is as impulsive as Abeer. Her decision to marry Akshat is also impulsive.

What was the need for Meher to come to Abeer's studio & destroy the equipments? Do you think it is a maturity on her part.

Come on, this is office. Not her home to behave like this.

You are right in saying Meher bhi doodh ki dhuli nahin hain. Even Meher is equally responsible for her divorce with Abeer. Thali toh hamesha dono haath se bajti hain.
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: malikakas


But it wasn't just about Alia wearing a short dress. Akshat knew Alia was trying to frame him. As far as Akshat knew Alia wasn't an innocent girl. She was in on a plan to destroy the life he has built for the last 8 years.

As far as Akshat knows Abeer is going to take pictures of him with Alia (hence the photo session remark) to tell Meher that Akshat is having an affair and Alia is going along with the lie.

Do you remember the movie Dil with Aamir Khan? Madhuri's character accuses him of rape so he shows her he is attempting to rape her to teach her a lesson for defaming his character. Aamir's character didn't treat Madhuri like a gentleman that night but that does that mean he is not a gentleman?

If Abeer and Alia are going to play these nasty games with Akshat then I don't see why Akshat can't turn the tables on them to teach both Abeer and Alia a lesson.

Akshat treated Alia like a gentleman when he first met her. He safely gave her a ride. She offered him to come up for "coffee" and he refused to fulfil in order to fulfil his responsibilities and went to pick up Ishaan.


Abeer does anything out of his impulsiveness. But even Meher is responsible for it. She challenged Abeer to prove that Akshat is characterless.

If she didn't want to believe, she could have found out for herself about Akshat. Whatever it is, Akshat's act cannot be justified as we are discussing about him being a gentleman. Akshat is not straight forward & he will show his colors to Meher after marrying her.

If Akshat was a gentleman, he would have made some excuses & avoided this scene.
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: malikakas


My friend.. But this is what I am trying to say. How does one live with that? Does Meher have to live on eggshells her whole life out of fear of what he will do next?
Meher cannot live on eggshells & fear but she can change Abeer with her love & quality time. Did she give him the top priority to make her marriage successful? Had she spent some time with him, there would have been a better understanding between the couple.

When they planned for the honeymoon, Meher gave into Taiji's superstitions & sacrificed her honeymoon. Meher didn't make any effort to remove his impulsiveness. Abeer wanted to prioritize her but she didn't give him that priority. First is her immediate family. Then comes in laws.

Akshat is not the reason Meher is saying no. Akshat is just the wall she is using to avoid succumbing to Abeer because she is afraid of Abeer's nature. Even if Akshat turns out bad it makes no difference.
That is the mistake she is making & it will be the biggest blunder in her life if she takes that step. If Akshat turns out to be bad, she will regret all her life. Because she does not love Akshat, it will ruin 4 lives. That is hers, Ishaan's, Akshat & Abeer. More than punishing Abeer she is doing that to herself & Ishaan. If she does not want to succumb, she has to face the reality & get over it. Only then she will be able to make up her mind for Akshat but she didn't do that. She is as impulsive as Abeer.

Meher is not looking for a perfect husband. All she wants is stability and reliability for Ishaan. Abeer's impulsive nature doesn't provide that. And he is hurtful when he doesn't get what he wants.
She won't get a perfect husband either as perfect man/woman do not exist. If Abeer is impulsive & hurtful, is Akshat any better? On the contrary he is insecure & psychic. She cannot take this step only for the reliability. Whenever she is with Abeer, that chomu keeps doubting her. He knows that Meher still loves Abeer to the core of her heart. Will Akshat give the same love to Ishaan if he gets his own child? A child needs both mother & father & that too real parents. Yes, Abeer didn't want the child at that time because he wanted to equip himself to give a better life to it. If you say that if that was the case, Abeer shouldn't have consummated her. But then it is a physical & emotional need which the couple wants. Meher should have consulted Abeer before conceiving. Plus it was also her duty to inform Abeer & his family that she is pregnant.

Neither Meher or Abeer are perfect. But you don't need to be perfect to make a marriage last. You need patience, and being willing to give each other the benefit of the doubt. Meher demonstrated that to me in their marriage. But Abeer did not.
Meher still falls short. She gave more priority to her in laws than her husband. In the first few days of her marriage she slept in Taiji's room instead of being with Abeer. She always got carried away by Taiji's & Kuber's words. That led to tension between the couple.

Every husband want their wife to give him more importance & Abeer is not wrong in expecting that from Meher.

Abeer made a blunder in not picking up Suman from the station. But Meher didn't assume he had a negative intention for it that he doesn't respect her family. She didn't fly off the handle and storm out of the house. She gave him a hangover drink and calmly explained why she was upset and they resolved it.
Abeer didn't know about Nisaar's intentions at that time & still does not know that he had created problems between mehbeer. Though he could not pick up his in laws he never had negative intentions. He still treats them as his own. If he has kidnapped Devki, it is the result of her hatred towards him. I don't have any ounce of sympathy towards her. She has also been responsible for Meher's condition. Taiji didn't have anything against Meher & had any problems with her but she only wanted to take revenge from Devki. Is she had not given the statement against her husband in the court, Meher's marriage would have lasted. Taiji would have brought the couple closer.

Meher may have approached the money topic hastily but Abeer just assumed the worst thinking she wants him to be a lap dog etc. He didn't give her the benefit of the doubt. She could've felt hurt that he thought the worst of her but she put aside her emotions and focussed on his. He throws her out of Nissar's house and says horrible things at her birthday party. But she took accountability for how her actions upset him and tried to fix things by quitting her job. KM's tried to instigate her against Abeer by saying its his male ego but she didn't let him. She put herself in Abeer's shoes and tried to understand what he was saying. Even after he left she tried to call him, but everyone has a limit.
Abeer was upset as he had taken so much of pains to celebrate her birthday in a grand way. It really shows how much he loves Meher. But she got carried away by her in laws words & disrespected his love. Any husband will get upset. Leaving the job was never a solution for fixing up things. Abeer never wanted her to do that. All he wanted from her is the quality time but she was doing office work at home.

When he wanted to take her for dinner, she sat to make the presentation only because Kuber told her. She never gave him the top priority. More than Abeer, Kuber & Taiji are her husbands.

But their entire marriage Abeer didn't try to understand where she was coming from. The night when Abeer tried to reconcile - she clearly said to him you have no sorry or guilt or concern but he didn't address that. He just tried to manipulate her by getting drunk. Trying to manipulate someone by saying you are going to harm yourself because they aren't giving you what you want is emotional abuse. Have you heard of borderline personality disorder? This is how people with that behave.
The problem with Abeer is that he was unable to express his guilt. Meher was ready to stay even after Abeer went to Singapore but it was Kuber & Taiji who kicked her out. If he had got drunk, she should have dropped him to his place & went back but she chose to spend a night with him.

If Abeer had truly felt guilt for leaving he never would've hated Meher for 8 years even if she took alimony because he would've understood that this actions also hurt her. And certainly he wouldn't have tried to make it seem like he was an innocent victim in her schemes when she came back.

Abeer got manipulated by Kuber & Taiji that is why he was hating her for 8 years. Though Abeer left her, he did not want divorce. She could have sorted out the differences with him instead of proceeding with the divorce.

And that's my problem now-- he wants a second chance but he can't be bothered to think about Meher's point of view. He was ready to fight with her again when Appendix held him back because she wasn't immediately giving in to his demands. Fighting with her screwed up their marriage the first time. Why does he need Appendix to explain to him. Hasn't he thought about his end of what went wrong in their marriage? It wasn't just the Singapore thing.
I feel that Abeer deserves a second chance. First thing is that Meher has not really forgotten Abeer. She still loves him to the core.

Second thing is that she does not have the same feelings for Akshat & it will affect 4 lives because of the step which she is taking. Abeer does think from her view point & he wants to rectify the blunders he made in the past. Whatever has happened has happened & it cannot be brought back or undone. Abeer is from a super rich family & does not know anything about life like Dev or whosoever it is. If Appendix is explaining him what is wrong in that? He is far better than that creepy Nisaar in every way.

Abeer doesn't stop and think that other people have reasons for their actions that he may not understand. If Meher is saying no to giving Tunnu money-- he didn't respect it and look what happened. That money he gave Tunnu helped him become a gambler. They wouldn't have lost the house if he hadn't interfered. Suman told Abeer don't use your personal money but he didn't respect that and look what happened. Meher ended up in an accident because she was so distracted by what KM said to her.

Abeer never has bad intentions but he has a long way to go.
Abeer didn't know that Tunnu wanted money to gamble. Tunnu had manipulated both Abeer & Meher. He took Meher's signatures to pledge the house out of deceit. He let Abeer down when he has been sincere to him. If Abeer knew what was Tunnu upto, he wouldn't have given him the money. When Tunnu went to commit suicide, only at that time Abeer got to know that he was gambling & didn't tell Meher to protect him from her wrath. Where was Akshat at that time when the house was at stake? There is a fault from Meher's side for this kind of situation to arise. Did Meher ever try to check her brother's whereabouts & control him? No one knew that Tunnu wanted to gamble. Suman told Abeer not to use his personal money but Abeer had a high regard for her & didn't want her to pledge her jewellery as he treated her as his own mother. Meher knew Kuber's mentality & also gave him a fitting reply. She should have immediately removed that from her mind.



Abeer has done more good than bad despite being impulsive & immature. No mistake is so grave that is is punishable for life. Abeer is not God. He has made a lot of blunders. However, Meher also has her share of her mistakes. You always need 2 hands to clap. Whatever it is, Akshat was not there when Meher was in a critical condition after her accident.

It was Abeer who took more care of Meher than Suman & Devki. Abeer is a deserving candidate & should be given a second chance. But Meher is dwelling too much in her past.

She cannot see anything beyond that.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".