Its the time to pay a visit to @byomkeshbakshy !!!!Go now...As in not like right now but you know what i mean!!!
🏏T20 Asia Cup 2025 India vs Pakistan, 6th Match, Group A, Dubai🏏
Bigg Boss 19: Daily Discussion Thread- 15th Sept 2025.
TRAUMA DRAMA 15.9
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 15, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread
🏏T20 Asia Cup 2025: UAE vs Oman, 7th Match, Group A, Abu Dhabi🏏
🏏T20 Asia Cup 2025: SL vs HK, 8th Match, Group B at Dubai🏏
Malla and ARS running crime list
Kaun banege PL ke Mummy and Papa?
Did Karishma deserve the best actress award for Raja Hindustani?
Anupamaa 15 Sept 2025 Written Update & Daily Discussions Thread
Conceiving of PL…
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 16, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread
Sidvi FF: Chocolate (continued)
Katrina Kaif Is Pregnant
BALH Naya Season EDT Week #14: Sept 15 to 19
Welcome Baby Boy ❤️🧿
The Armaan Poddar Unappreciation Thread
which new Bollywood movie should i watch ....
BHAJAN & DANCE 16.9
Its the time to pay a visit to @byomkeshbakshy !!!!Go now...As in not like right now but you know what i mean!!!
All the best buddy its #DetectiveByomkeshBakshy day tomm tickets are booked @itsSSR waiting to see ur magic unfold :)
Oh no BW hungama gives good reviews to almost all films 😭😭😭Originally posted by: SushitaLover23
First (and hopefully the only) poor review out...with praise for sushant so that's always good! I want to know who wrote this one though...
RATE THIS MOVIE:(0 Votes)Write Your ReviewVideo ReviewsExternal ReviewsUser ReviewsCritic ReviewDetective Byomkesh Bakshy!By Bollywood Hungama News Network, 3 Apr 2015, 23:59 hrs ISTRating: 2/5 |First things first. Leaving a handful of filmmakers, there are hardly any filmmakers who really like to 'risk' their stocks with period films. And given today's time and age, making a period film really means burning the midnight oil for nights together and getting the research right and recreating the respective era. This week's release DETECTIVE BYOMKESH BAKSHY! is one such film that belongs to the 'period' genre. Will this film actually move and shake the Box-Office windows or will it turn out to be a damp squib, let's analyze.
The film starts off with a night of November 1942 in Calcutta, with a narrative by Detective Byomkesh Bakshy (Sushant Singh Rajput). When he is busy playing in the sports room, Ajit Banerjee (Anand Tiwari) approaches him to solve the case of his missing father Bhuvan. Then, a very practical Byomkesh Bakshy tells him that he doesn't want to accept this case and gives him all the possibilities of his father to have gone missing. A very upset Ajit, then, slaps him in front of everyone. The very next moment, we see Byomkesh Bakshy taking up the case and trying to recreate all sorts of possibilities, which could lead him to cracking the case. And when Byomkesh Bakshy really gets to searching by going hammer and tongs over the case, he lands up discovering that Bhuvan had not gone missing, but had been mercilessly murdered. And then starts his journey to find the killers of Bhuvan. As and when the case progresses, he keeps on meeting various characters, who in turn, lead to various twists and turns in the film, which also includes merciless murders at regular intervals. In the meanwhile, while he is investigating the case, a very seductive Devi/ Anguri (Swastika Mukherjee) tries her level best to seduce him. As the case progresses, Byomkesh Bakshy, suddenly, chances upon a very mysterious map.
What is the mystery of the map, does Byomkesh Bakshy become successful in nabbing the culprit of Bhuvan, the reason behind his assassination and also the culprit behind the series of murders and the reason for their murders is what forms the rest of the film.
As far as the film is concerned, even though it's a whodunit thriller, the thrill of watching a thriller gets lost midway through the film. In the name of a whodunit genre, the film goes overboard totally, thus, resulting into the film falling flat on the face. And the only person who needs to be blamed for this is the film's director Dibakar Banerjee, alongwith the film's joint writer Urmi Juvekar. It's very shocking to see a film like DETECTIVE BYOMKESH BAKSHY! suffer a low stature and that too coming from a man who gave us stellar films like SHANGHAI, LSD: LOVE, SEX AUR DHOKHA, OYE LUCKY! LUCKY OYE, and KHOSLA KA GHOSLA. The trademark 'Dibakar' touch is heavily missing in the film. While the film has a slow first half, its second half is endlessly dragged to the core. In an attempt to make a thriller, it seems that Dibakar landed up infusing too many elements, which leaves the film in a very bad taste.
As far as the performances are concerned, it's a film that clearly belongs to Sushant Singh Rajput and his antics. Even though the film rests solely on his shoulders, the haphazard script acts as a spoiler in his performance as well. But, Sushant tries his level best to escape unscathed. Anand Tiwari plays his role with ease, so does Meiyang Chang who plays his 'part' effectively. Even though Neeraj Kabi does get a meaty part in the film, there are times when his performance lands up being translated into hamming. As far as the female leads (Swastika Mukherjee and Divya Menon) are concerned, they hardly have anything to do in the film, except for appearing in crucial moments of the film and help in to move forward. The rest of the characters help in moving the film forward.
The film scores very heavily in its breath taking production value (Vandana Kataria), who is definitely a name to watch out for in this department. Even the film's music (Sneha Khanwalkar, Dibakar Banerjee, Madboy/Mink, Blek, Mode AKA, Joint Family, IJA, Peter Cat Recording Co. - PCRC) comes across with a likeability factor attached to it. The film also scores in the sound department (Allwin Rego, Sanjay Maurya) (a handful of out of sync dialogues notwithstanding). Special brownie points to the film's cinematography (Nikos Andritsakis) for making the film look visually appealing. Because of the 'entangled' script, even the film's editors (Namrata Rao, Manas Mittal) couldn't do much.
There are many factors which may make the film struggle at the Box Office. A few of them include unwanted violence (esp. in the second half), a plot that went haywire and also too much of thriller elements. Generally, any kind of murder mystery comes with a sinister motive, which gets revealed towards the end. But, in the case of DETECTIVE BYOMKESH BAKSHY!, the film gets dragged on endlessly, even after the culprit has been identified!
On the whole, DETECTIVE BYOMKESH BAKSHY! can be skipped, without any regrets.
Ratings :
As a kid, I used to be a great fan of detective based T.V series like 'Karamchand', 'Bhim Bhavani', 'Tehkikat', 'Suraag' and even 'Byomkesh Bakshy'. This fascination introduced me to the short stories based on 'Byomkesh Bakshy', 'Feluda' and 'Prof.Shonku'. The detailing and the pattern of solving the crime used to be highly engrossing. Sadly, when it came to films there were none to be found. Though we did witness films like 'Detective', 'The Perfect Murder', 'Apradhi Kaun?', 'Gumnaam', 'Kaun?Kaise?', 'Khoj', 'Plot No 5' and many more, which were mostly on lines of crime thrillers inspired by the work of Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, Maria Corelli, James Hadley Chase, Suhas Shirvalkar or Surendra Mohan Pathak. Thus, right from the announcement of 'Byomkesh Bakshy' being converted into a full-fledged feature film to it being made followed by the promo and now its release, my curiosity and expectation level was at its peak. So, lets find out whether 'Detective Byomkesh Bakshy' will finally give us an out and out proper detective film in our Hindi cinema or might be on lines of last year's debacles like 'Samrat & Co' and 'Bobby Jasoos'.
'Detective Byomkesh Bakshy' is the story of a private detective Byomkesh Bakshy (Sushant Singh Rajput), who is approached by Ajit (Anand Tiwari) to investigate the disappearance of his father. Byomkesh starts investigating the case from the lodge where Ajit's father used to stay and befriends Dr.Anukul Guha (Neeraj Kabi). The clues Byomkesh gets, leads him to an actor Anguri Devi (Swastika Mukherjee), a politician Gajanan Sikdar (Dr.Kaushik Ghosh) and a few more, along with a drug kingpin. How does Byomkesh solve this mystery is what the film is all about.
The story is as we know, based on the fictional characters created by Sharadindu Bandyopadhyay and has been brilliantly transformed into the big screen by Dibakar Banerjee and Urmi Juvekar. Right from the first scene of the film the movie is set on its right course without wandering even for a minute into the unwanted territories. Every scene is important and full of detailing with the script of the film. There are no sidetracks to dilute the flow of the film. However, the slow narrative pattern might not go well with the normal cine-goers, but is apt for such type of slow detective genre, which gradually grows on you with every scene of the film. There are some great scenes like the whole credit title sequence followed by Sushant meeting Neeraj Kabi in the guesthouse, Sushant-Anand Tiwari being followed in the streets of Kolkata, the whole opium track followed by Sushant-Swastika scenes, the revelation towards the finale followed by graphic based end credits. Nevertheless, more than the scenes, what makes 'Detective Byomkesh Bakshy', is the minute detailing attached to the film. It has one of the finest artworks in our Hindi cinema, the brilliant set up of Kolkata from the early 40's era is something worth watching for sure. The makers and the setup (trams, posters, newspapers, hoardings, transportation, costume, magazines, accessories, etc) transform you into the world of 1942. The movie might not appeal to the people who need spoon-feeding and who are die hard lovers of escapist cinema, as there is a lot of things happening in the film, leaving not a single breathing space for such type of cine-goers. Nikos Andritsakis's cinematography is outstanding, as the sets and whole feel of the film looks real and believable.
Music is good, but fails to gel with the flow of the film. It is more international, thus misses the connect with the film. 'Jaanam' is brilliantly presented. The background music is outstanding and does full justice to the feel of the film.
Director Dibakar Banerjee gives us probably the true dark detective film with 'Detective Byomkesh Bakshy'. He will satisfy all his fans and all those who love to see artistic films or are big admirers of proper detective films. His vision and detailing enhances the film to international standards and sets up a benchmark for Indian cinema. He might not be as real or simple in comparison with the films made by Satyajit Ray, Ritupo*no Ghosh, Anjan Dutt, Manju Dey and few more Bengali film makers, but has his own unique style and matches up to the true level of this genre. How we wished he would have presented it in a bit moderate manner in order to appeal the normal cine-lovers. In addition, the finale part should have been hard-hitting rather than being simple and creative.
Sushant Singh Rajput is cute and charming. He adds the much-needed innocence to his character with help of his pure smile and soft dialogue delivery. He might not be as appealing as Rajit Kapoor (from Byomkesh Bakshy T.V series), but will still set its own identity. Neeraj Kabi is brilliant in his role. Anand Tiwari is good and adds up as a good support to the lead character. Swastika Mukherjee looks charming and does her part with total grace. Meiyang Chang and Divya Menon needed more detailing.
Dum??? Well, the movie has all the dum needed for a dark and slowly enthralling detective based film. It is one of the good films we have recently witnessed in our Hindi cinema. Though, the masala film lovers will be highly disappointed with this movie as they might find it slow, boring and will fail to understand the plot line of the film. As for all those who love reading good detective stories, 'Detective Byomkesh Baksh is an arty case of mystery, which is worth solving for sure.
Star Cast- Sushant Singh Rajput, Anand Tiwari, Swastika Mukherjee, Divya Menon, Neeraj Kabi
by Rajat Srivastav
written on April 2, 2015 - 5 pm EST.
Duel of Wits- Detective Byomkesh Bakshy
It is indeed a duel of wits between the story teller and the viewer. The story teller succeeds in keeping the viewer glued and guessing all the time. An envelope of silence is maintained in the auditorium and that is clear triumph for this gripping whodunit murder mystery.
The clever screenplay boasts of snappy twists and sharp turns and does not get dreary save for a few minutes during the build-up. It can still pass off as a near-perfect whodunit, the climax might face some flak though. However one will definitely admit that keeping the suspense till the very end does require a genius effort. To top it up, thrills are served seasoned with wits and subtlety
Subtle charm and witty nuances make Byomkesh the character he is and Dibakar , Aditya Chopra and Sushant bring the character to life perfectly draped . The tale of mystery transcends into a larger than life chain of events and that what makes the case a bite more than simple Byomkesh, can actually chew !
Will avoid giving away even remote hints to the tale. However still need to highlight the detailing in the recreation of Kolkatta ..oops Calcutta of 1942, the rampant opium smuggling, the struggle for freedom and amidst that a story full of deceit, intrigue, mystery, lust and suspense. The different cards will keep unfolding as you sink in-
Sushant Singh Rajput has assured himself of a character which can be recreated multiple times without losing its brilliance. Yash Raj has created yet another franchisee and Dibakar Banerjee's portfolio expands into newer, undiscovered genres.
With a charming, endearing, flirtatious, witty, composed and brilliant portrayal, Sushant lives Byomkesh and gives Bollywood a detective next-door. Swastika Mukherjee has a commanding screen presence as Anguri Devi. Anand Tiwari is an able side-kick and slips in effortlessly. The antagonist is definitely an actor to watch out! All others are up to the demands of the screenplay.
Mystery movie lovers will relish it. Minor blemishes do not rob the movie of its dexterity. Overall a movie not to be missed.
Your choices in terms of films have not exactly been conventional. Is that a conscious move?
There are two reasons why we make films. First one being escapist films. There is nothing wrong in that because our lives are so monotonous that we want to associate ourselves with all those larger than life characters we would want to be but can't. The second reason we make films is to show all that is happening around us. I get fascinated by the first aspect of film-making because my idea of being in this industry is very different from everyone else. When I was in college, I used to find it very difficult to interact with people. So, I joined Shaimak's (Davar) dancing school and I did theatre with Barry John. It was then that I realised I can play all these characters and say so many things I always wanted to say, do all that I wanted to do and affect people. That was the reason I chose this profession over engineering. Till the time I am shooting for the film it's personal and selfish. Once I am done with the movie is when I think about the audience and the possible outcome. It is not a deliberate attempt to not do conventional films. I am not against anyone. It's just that I haven't been excited about roles like that.
Were you apprehensive of taking up a biopic since it would be pressurising to live up to the original person - in this case Byomkesh Bakshi?
I think all the characters that I played in films or theatre existed in my head. Whether it's Byomkesh or the next biopic (on Mahendra Singh Dhoni) that I am doing, the idea of those people exists in my head. I have those visual references and that's why I can see it, feel it and portray it. So everytime I portray any character it's equally complicated, challenging and fascinating. Just because somebody exists or existed, it doesn't make a difference. Learning the way one talks or behaves or his mannerisms are very easy things to do. And I don't know why we get very excited about things like 'Oh this actor didn't eat for two days or that he didn't sleep for five days.' The complicated thing to do is to stop the momentum of your own pattern of thinking.
You play a detective in this film. Did you always have that inquisitive streak in you?
I think, everybody does. Right now, I am thinking about the kind of person you are. At the same time, I want to know what you think of me as well. I have spied on people but I am not going to take names.
Is there anybody you consult before you take up a film?
No. It is completely my call. Cent percent. And I cannot put a finger on it as to why I chose this role. When you read the script of the film, you know whether the film has struck a chord with you or no. It is then that you come up with all the logical, possible explanations like the banner, the co-star, the director -- as to why you would want to do the film.
In one of our most intense On-Record @ Caf sessions in recent times, Dibakar took over the conversation " romanticising about Kolkata of the 1940s, talking about rebuilding it in the city of today, revealing why, for the film, he chose indie musicians over mainstream ones, and why he can't make commercial money-spinners " even as lead actor Sushant Singh Rajput chipped in with his take on method acting', and why becoming your character' as an actor is really a myth.
Sushant, what is it like to be promoting one film while working on another?
SUSHANT: I haven't started shooting for Dhoni yet. We are doing test shoots right now, and will start a few weeks after we are done promoting this film. I have been practising a lot of cricket as well as everything else [to get into character].
Dibakar, you must have grown
up reading Byomkesh. At what point did you realise that you wanted to make the film?
DIBAKAR: When I was 12-13. I didn't know that it was a movie that I wanted to make. Every Bong (Bengali) household has shelves full of Byomkesh books, and you would be told not to read them before you turn 16. By that time, I had graduated to Nick Carter and James Hadley Chase. I read Byomkesh thinking I'd find something salacious. But what I found was something that captivated me forever. Those who have read Byomkesh will tell you that the sense and time of Kolkata, along with the imagery and movement of the stories is unparalleled.
In terms of the language too?
DIBAKAR: Language was the part that I didn't think of adapting immediately. Sharadindu's (Bandyopadhyay; author and creator of Byomkesh) Bengali is shadhu (orthodox), and I didn't have any issue penetrating that. When you read Sharadindu, you actually forget the writing. It's so brilliant that the image becomes paramount " the dark alleys of Kolkata, and the characters who are so Indian, yet universal. The crime and the clues are so original and so Indian. That's what caught me by surprise. I wanted to make something that brought out the adventurous imagery that Sharadindu had in his Byomkesh.
Which of his stories have you
explored in the film?
DIBAKAR: I won't tell you, as then, you will look for the villain in the film. It will take away the joy of the familiar and the joy of the shock.
Did you ever think of adapting it in a modern setting?
DIBAKAR: No. Setting it up in mid-century Kolkata became the feel for me. There is something about that era in which Byomkesh is a young detective. I don't think a detective story today works as successfully as it did in the past. Today, there are no whodunits as we already know "who's done it". Crime scenes hardly have the secret of the criminal. The question is, how to bring the criminal to justice.
How much was Sharadindu inspired by the western concept of a detective?
DIBAKAR: Essentially, the concept of a detective is western. I don't think he was inspired at all; he just absorbed it. Sharadindu reinvented it; his Byomkesh and his assistant are completely Indian and that's the genius. That's something that needs to be seen; the fact that how Indian Byomkesh was and how Indian he made him, without any jingoism. Yet, these are all universal characters, who are as evil, sensuous and dark as can be.
Sushant, how was it working on this project?
SUSHANT: It wasn't easy. For almost 150 days, I only researched. I used to have long conversations with Dibakar, visit Kolkata often, and have conversations with random people on the road there. That's how a week before we started shooting, we were sure of what we are not supposed to do. DIBAKAR: Like Uttam Kumar's Chiriyakhana (1967) by Satyajit Ray.
SUSHANT: Yes, that's the only Byomkesh film that Dibakar showed me. And when I saw it, he particularly told me that this is something that I'm not supposed to do.
DIBAKAR: Not because I don't like it. It's quite nice actually. But when you see Uttam Kumar as Byomkesh, you see a seasoned detective in his prime. But our Byomkesh is first the character Byomkesh, and then the detective. He's first the man with all his eccentricities, flaws, weaknesses, and he's a rookie Byomkesh. He's just out of college, and unsure of himself. He's learning, making mistakes, yet he is up against his biggest nemesis.
Were you aware of Byomkesh before Dibakar introduced you to the character?
SUSHANT: Of course, I knew who he was. I hadn't read anything, but I had memories of the Doordarshan show. I remember the track that used to play and the subtle mannerisms of the character. So, I had some idea, but Dibakar very particularly told me not to watch anything while I was shooting for the film.
Did you consider a Bengali actor as the lead?
DIBAKAR: If he could speak Hindi flawlessly and had a huge fan following, I would have. And if he was a good actor, a good looker, about 26-27 years old, and known in the Hindi film world as an upcoming movie star, then I would have taken him.
Was Sushant your first choice?
DIBAKAR: Out of the crop of the upcoming actors, who will hopefully become the reigning stars of tomorrow, yes. I was looking for somebody who understood the art of understatement, because I don't think a detective is a rational creature; he's a logical creature. There is some clinical precision to how a detective probably behaves. I found Sushant acted naturally in Pavitra Rishta. It was a TV show, but I saw him actually giving subtle takes. It's very easy to look and sound good in a well-mounted accomplished film like Kai Po Che! (2013) or PK (2014), or it is very easy to look dishy, where you are acting to the fantasy of today's youth. But it's not easy to be subtle in a TV show, day after day. In every episode that I watched, whenever Sushant was doing a scene, it was more natural. We had a long chat about how he did that. And he told me his dukhra (sad story). He told me, I was about to be thrown off...'
SUSHANT: After the first three months, the makers of the show planned to replace me as they thought I was not acting. Then TRPs started going up, so they were happy and I was safe.
Did you audition Sushant?
DIBAKAR: I did, but not as a means to choose him. I auditioned him after casting him. It was a way of figuring out how to get Sushant to become Byomkesh.
What's your take on an actor becoming the character' theory of preparation?
SUSHANT: I don't think it's possible to become your character'. As an individual, you have conflicts and similarities and dissimilarities with the character. And you are continuously working on those dissimilarities. It's like a pendulum swinging, and you can only try and get close to your character. Kevin Spacey said about Al Pacino that he used to give 40 to 50 takes, and then he walked to the director and say, "Something happened in the 19th or 20th take; just check."
DIBAKAR: Also, if you are shooting a film for two or three months, you can't have a calculated formula because Byomkesh goes through a gamut of emotions. So, Sushant walked through the streets of Kolkata, anonymously, for days, to observe the city and its people, and I started talking to him about what might have changed between then and now. For example, an average Bengali has a deep love for conversation... Sushant doesn't talk much, so we got him to start conversing. Bengalis are also obsessed with washing their hands. After they eat, they wash their hands because they don't want their hand entho' (dirty). We concentrated on such things...
How well does Kolkata today lend itself to a period film?
DIBAKAR: Cinematically, some of it. We shot the film over 66 days, out of which 28 days were in Kolkata, and the rest on our sets in Mumbai. We kind of exhausted places in Kolkata, but there were logistical problems. For example, at some places you can only shoot on weekends, which would have really extended the shoot. We went to BBD Bagh, and in one night, we changed everything that was contemporary. We got two trams from the Calcutta State Transport Corporation, and painted them in the advertising of that time.
Is this film the beginning of a potential series?
DIBAKAR: You know, you'll make me cry now. I desperately want this movie to work. I never wanted any of my other films to work as much as I want this one to, because the other ones were pretty safe movies. They were cheap films, so I knew that they'll recover their money. That doesn't mean I wasn't attached to those films, but with this one, it's slightly different. It has cost a lot more money than any of my other films. My deepest desire for this film is to get a genuine Indian icon out there, in its full Indian unconsciousness; which is not jingoistic. That, for me, is a way of celebrating who we are today. If this works with the audience, only then can we make part two.
Did you screen test Swastika Mukherjee?
DIBAKAR: Yes. We screen tested about 80 actresses from Delhi, Bengaluru, Mumbai and Kolkata. Her test was quite spectacular. But her look was completely wrong. So, I decided to go for the actor' in her and then we worked on her look for many weeks.
Sushant, you'll next start shooting for the Dhoni biopic. Is it easier to play a real-life character as compared to a fictional character?
SUSHANT: I don't think it's that simple to differentiate. The most important thing is that despite undergoing all the research, we can't play our research' in front of the camera. When the director says action', your research is not in front of you. Research just gives us the authority to believe that we have the right to be that character. When you get that feeling, it's only the first step. So, if I have to play someone who is still around and everyone has a visual reference of it, I have to take care of a few things. I know how he (Dhoni) talks, walks or plays cricket. So yes, it's an imitation of sorts, but I have to convince myself that I am not playing him; I am him. This is what I am trying to do.
Detective Byomkesh Bakshi has Sushant's old charm, some amazing twists and a sure hand at the helm by Dibankar Banerjee! Don't miss this one!
Average Critic Rating:
Cast: Sushant Singh Rajput , Swastika Mukherjee , Anand Tiwari
Director: Dibakar Banerjee
Genre: Thriller | Release Date: 03 Apr 2015
Language: Hindi
For all of you who are awaiting your dose of nostalgia with the Detective Byomkesh Bakshi (DBB) release (tomorrow, 3 April), it's just got a tad easier to immortalise the Sharadindu Bandyopadhyay's classic and the Calcutta culture in your homes.