!!Pavitra Rishta Banner Contest Winner!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: Ashlaika

But this is the NEW banner? Where are the NEW cast and characters that were mandatory according to the rules?

Naren, Prashant, Mansi and others?

Can the MODs say why the mandatory characters arent prominent or not even there.

I guess rules are all subjective on this forum :) :D. (further more, they didnt even tell us why the contest was taken down in the 1st place).

Thanks to everyone who participated, I hope at least you were sent a PM saying why/how ur time and effort were spent and if taken into consideration.

If u r not aware then let me tell u .. voting round 1 started in this forum but we saw foulplay happening with grps voting for their favs and on further innvestigation we found out advertising going on too and so the forum was informed during round 1 that due to foulplay , we r closing it here and rest voting will happen in DT section .. so the forum was made aware of it and that time no questioned were asked

rest this banenr won with DT voting in its favour ...

Last but not least I feel one should appreciate the winner here rather than finding faults in her work ... the winner choosen too is a neutral candidate and dont belong to any fan grp of the show

Originally posted by: jyoti06

If u r not aware then let me tell u .. voting round 1 started in this forum but we saw foulplay happening with grps voting for their favs and on further innvestigation we found out advertising going on too and so the forum was informed during round 1 that due to foulplay , we r closing it here and rest voting will happen in DT section .. so the forum was made aware of it and that time no questioned were asked

rest this banenr won with DT voting in its favour ...

Last but not least I feel one should appreciate the winner here rather than finding faults in her work ... the winner choosen too is a neutral candidate and dont belong to any fan grp of the show

Jyothi,

Thank you for your response.

1. I appreciate the 1st paragraph and note the reason.

2. I have no issue with the DT voting subjectively

3. I know the winner is neutral, that is not an issue and the banner is very nice. I did appreciate the banner in my 1st post and I always appreciate the hard work and creativity of others since I dont have any. BUT - I also appreciate fair play and transparency, hence asked for some.

Last but not least, you havent informed us why the MANDATORY characters were left out. I specifically recall there was a big uproar pertaining to certain characters that left the show being left out of the banner last time and this time, the NEW and CURRENT characters arent even on the banner and thats acceptable?

Like I said,... the rules seem to be very subjective and blows with the wind in this forum.

Anyway, thank you for taking the time to reply.

according to the rules all the characters are incorporated in the banners. there was no clause in the forum that said i have to give prominence to certain characters except leads which i have already. i respect the DT decision but i would also like to tell you if you guys need any changes in the banner i am ready to do it. and if my banner does not have any particular character i am ready to sacrifice my win.

Congrats and sorry to winner that you have to celebrate your victory like this.

Last time also banner was selected by DT because it came to light that foul was played, yet no one cried when winner banner was chose which had few characters missing. Rules is indeed subjective!!

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3398967

suggestion to DT never annouce banner contest ;)

I think we should just be calm and ask the DT to ask the winner to rectify the banner... i totally understand the sentiments of the fan and hopefully something will be worked out soon. having said that we should just inform the DTs calmly instead of reeling it up. It is not something that cannot be rectified. Blaming is easy but giving suggestions how to solve it are always appreciated.

Koeli Appy and Starry Phoenix.. The banners are lovely!! Congratulations!!

congratulations !! Koeli Appy and Starry Phoenix... fabulous awesome banners..!!!👍🏼👏 👏

Originally posted by: Ashlaika

Jyothi,

Thank you for your response.

1. I appreciate the 1st paragraph and note the reason.

2. I have no issue with the DT voting subjectively

3. I know the winner is neutral, that is not an issue and the banner is very nice. I did appreciate the banner in my 1st post and I always appreciate the hard work and creativity of others since I dont have any. BUT - I also appreciate fair play and transparency, hence asked for some.

Last but not least, you havent informed us why the MANDATORY characters were left out. I specifically recall there was a big uproar pertaining to certain characters that left the show being left out of the banner last time and this time, the NEW and CURRENT characters arent even on the banner and thats acceptable?

Like I said,... the rules seem to be very subjective and blows with the wind in this forum.

Anyway, thank you for taking the time to reply.

Can u tell which characters r missing ... as far as I see all r included .. I mean the main ones ..

PR is a long running shows with 100s of old and new characters .. our winner only tried to fit them all into one as this probably could b last banner with show ending soon ... so the banner consists of a mix of both old and new characters

@ -Koeli_Appy-: Its a real shame that members of this forum are unable to appreciate the hard work gone into making this banner. I think you have done a brilliant job.

Koeli Appy pls dont feel bad u have made brilliant banner.. Ppl need to appreciate hardwork 😛 As i am zero in creativity i rather appreciate ppl with creativity