Ankita-Naren Appreciation thread # 5 - Page 48

Created

Last reply

Replies

494

Views

56.7k

Users

29

Likes

843

Frequent Posters

naava thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Tanyaz



Explained it beautifully Naava , I am going to miss such discussions now that the show is over ...
Definitely if Naren and Ankita ended up together then it was more because of her than him ...I just wish the show was given more time to show Naren truly repenting and making himself worthy of Ankita's love ..


Thanks Tanya... and i definitely agree with you. Naren needed to truly repent to Ankita - which we didn't see happen. Hopefully it was due to the rush to finish the show. I wish we could have seen such a scene. (we'll just have to write it into our "What would have happened if" scenarios. ๐Ÿ˜†
Tanyaz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
One more thing I would like to say ...
I can accept that a woman loved a man so much that she forgave him for going to another woman and dumping her ,,,,he felt bad about this so she forgave him but I just cannot understand how a woman can love a man who labelled her a woman of wrong character ..
Because that is what Naren did when he convinced the world that Ankita's baby was of Shashank's ( her brother in law ) and that also a baby conceived when she was married to another man ..

I just cannot understand how on earth could Ankita go on to love a man who said this about her ????
I mean that was really crossing the line ...
naava thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Tanyaz

One more thing I would like to say ...

I can accept that a woman loved a man so much that she forgave him for going to another woman and dumping her ,,,,he felt bad about this so she forgave him but I just cannot understand how a woman can love a man who labelled her a woman of wrong character ..
Because that is what Naren did when he convinced the world that Ankita's baby was of Shashank's ( her brother in law ) and that also a baby conceived when she was married to another man ..

I just cannot understand how on earth could Ankita go on to love a man who said this about her ????
I mean that was really crossing the line ...


You do have a point. But if i remember, (and i could be remembering it all wrong), he thought she was in love with Shashank because Ankita told him she was, and Ankita told him that they (Naren and her) were never intimate. So, i don't know what he was supposed to think. The baby didn't come out of the sky. She clearly was pregnant, and she supposedly didn't have sex with him (Naren), told him she loved Shanshank, so i guess he thought she just was really in love with Shanshank and it just happened. I dont' think he thought it through as to timing, when they were married, when Shasahank got married etc. And Ankita told him it wasn't his child (Naren's) but someone whom she loved.

I don't think he thought it was wrong, or characterless, just an unfortunate happening. That's something different. It was Pari who made it into a "characterless" thing to make Ankita look bad.

But actually Ankita labelled herself as a wrong character if that's what it looked like. I have always maintained that whole thing was kind of her own fault.

Guess if we learned anything from PR it should be to ALWAYS TELL THE TRUTH AND NOT HIDE THINGS. ๐Ÿ˜†

But like i said, maybe i don't remember the whole scenario.


sushkita931 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
I was watching 'shaadi ka side effect ' saw ashi is there.she may be 2.5years old that time
vision22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: sushkita931

I was watching 'shaadi ka side effect ' saw ashi is there.she may be 2.5years old that time


I saw that tooo!! she looked so adorable with her curly hair..
Tanyaz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: naava


You do have a point. But if i remember, (and i could be remembering it all wrong), he thought she was in love with Shashank because Ankita told him she was, and Ankita told him that they (Naren and her) were never intimate. So, i don't know what he was supposed to think.




She said that she was in love with Shashank before she got married to Naren and before Shashank was married to her sister ...

What Naren assumed was that Ankita while still married to him had an affair with her married brother in law . That is one UGLY thing to think even if Ankita had said that once she and Shashank were interested in each other ...I mean to think that Ankita while she is a married woman , had an affair with her sister's husband ...that is the worst ever characetr assassination.
And he knew that Ankita married him because of her siblings ...so how can a girl like that cheat her sister in this manner ...

Naren was way out of line .Infact it was not Pari but Naren who planted this gossip in everyone's mind ...
Ankita should have never forgiven him for this .

I would have preferred if she had said that she is marrying him for her daughter's sake as Aashi will not live without her dad but otherwise she only loved the insane Naren and not this cured one ..

I would have liked this much better ..

Edited by Tanyaz - 11 years ago
CricktFan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Everey one thinks that Introducing Aahana as Pari And after making Naren normal they have butchered his character are reasons of downfall of this show but butchering of Ankita's character is also responsible downfall of this show . Before Making naren normal Ankita had a fighting attitude . We had seen her bravness after mansi was raped and first time when raunaq physically abused her . but after making Naren normal ankita became weak I dont know but where Ankta's fighting attitude gone that time . she wasnt weak before naren become normal . she had lot of selfconfidence but she lost her self esttem and her confidence after naren becoming normal .
Edited by CricktFan - 11 years ago
naava thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Tanyaz


She said that she was in love with Shashank before she got married to Naren and before Shashank was married to her sister ...

What Naren assumed was that Ankita while still married to him had an affair with her married brother in law . That is one UGLY thing to think even if Ankita had said that once she and Shashank were interested in each other ...I mean to think that Ankita while she is a married woman , had an affair with her sister's husband ...that is the worst ever characetr assassination.
And he knew that Ankita married him because of her siblings ...so how can a girl like that cheat her sister in this manner ...

Naren was way out of line .Infact it was not Pari but Naren who planted this gossip in everyone's mind ...
Ankita should have never forgiven him for this .

I would have preferred if she had said that she is marrying him for her daughter's sake as Aashi will not live without her dad but otherwise she only loved the insane Naren and not this cured one ..

I would have liked this much better ..


๐Ÿ˜† here we are still discussing Naren!๐Ÿ˜† Ok, the way you write it, it does sound terrible. But I have a question then. If Ankita told him it wasnt' his child, but someone else she loved, where was he supposed to think the baby came from? Whether it was Shashank or a new lover, she herself made it look like she had an affair. To me that was Ankita's fault. Don't you think she should have told him it was theirs? I suppose he could have and should have just kept quiet and said, well, she loved someone but not tried to guess or name him.

I keep trying to put myself in Naren's shoes. He wakes up one day and sees Ahana that he has been in love with. Then he is told he is already married to someone else but she's a gold digger. That person asks him to try to remember their marriage but then says no, they are right, i did it only for money and we were never intimate. He would have had to be a clairvoyant to say oh no Ankita you are lying. Naren was afraid to lose Ahana, and didn't know of this Ankita thing. It must have been really confusing.

Granted he could have been more gentlemanly...he was rude. ...but Ankita's expecting him just to somehow know the truth wasn't fair either.

Regardless, it hurt her very deeply, and Naren needed to realize that in the end and beg her forgiveness...on that part we at least agree. (i think.haha)

Maybe they can do a very short sequel and clear up all these issues with no closure. ๐Ÿ˜†
Tanyaz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago

๐Ÿ˜† here we are still discussing Naren!๐Ÿ˜† Ok, the way you write it, it does sound terrible. But I have a question then. If Ankita told him it wasnt' his child, but someone else she loved, where was he supposed to think the baby came from? Whether it was Shashank or a new lover, she herself made it look like she had an affair. To me that was Ankita's fault. Don't you think she should have told him it was theirs? I suppose he could have and should have just kept quiet and said, well, she loved someone but not tried to guess or name him.

I keep trying to put myself in Naren's shoes. He wakes up one day and sees Ahana that he has been in love with. Then he is told he is already married to someone else but she's a gold digger. That person asks him to try to remember their marriage but then says no, they are right, i did it only for money and we were never intimate. He would have had to be a clairvoyant to say oh no Ankita you are lying. Naren was afraid to lose Ahana, and didn't know of this Ankita thing. It must have been really confusing.

Granted he could have been more gentlemanly...he was rude. ...but Ankita's expecting him just to somehow know the truth wasn't fair either.

Regardless, it hurt her very deeply, and Naren needed to realize that in the end and beg her forgiveness...on that part we at least agree. (i think.haha)

Maybe they can do a very short sequel and clear up all these issues with no closure. ๐Ÿ˜†


No no, I don't want to discuss Naren , It is very clear in my mind what kind of a person he is .
he was a selfless and a very fair person when he was mentally unstable but when he got cured we saw the real Naren Karmarkar who I felt was a very selfish and an insensitive human being ..
The only saving grace in his life was his daughter Aashi and he was a happy man in the end because of her .
he loved Pari a lot but soon after marrying her he realized that his dream girl was nothing like what he had imagined and he lived a horrible life with Pari , tried his best to make things work but when Ashi's life was put in danger , he could not take it anymore ...
I liked his reaction a lot better in Aashi's kidnapping than Ankita's reaction ...

I wanted to discuss Ankita here becasuse she is someone I cannot understand ...I do not know how a woman can love a man who labelled her characterless and who dumped her as bad as Naren did .

I would liked it a lot more had Ankita said in the end that she will marry Naren because of her daughter as she can never take the place of a father in Aashi's life and so she will give Naren one more chance ...

That's what I would have preferred ...but anyways , it is now a closed chapter as the show is over .
Tanyaz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: CricktFan

Everey one thinks that Introducing Aahana as Pari And after making Naren normal they have butchered his character are reasons of downfall of this show but butchering of Ankita's character is also responsible downfall of this show . Before Making naren normal Ankita had a fighting attitude . We had seen her bravness after mansi was raped and first time when raunaq physically abused her . but after making Naren normal ankita became weak I dont know but where Ankta's fighting attitude gone that time . she wasnt weak before naren become normal . she had lot of selfconfidence but she lost her self esttem and her confidence after naren becoming normal .



That's what I meant ..
I wish there was more time to show that Ankita only forgave Naren after he proved that he was worthy of her love because the guy she married in the end was not even 2 % worthy of either her or either Aashi ...
Edited by Tanyaz - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".