Finally Purvi!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Tanyaz

@Tanyaz

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

Kool, many times the Cvs are trying to show something but because of their poor writing skills they end up showing things that can be interpreted in a different way ...

i don't fault you here for thinking that Purvi is trying to control Arjun or that Archana was trying to ruin Manav by doing the court case ...many must have felt that way ..I am sure you are not the only one ..

But I think that is not what the Cvs intend to show ...

Many times it has been mentioned that Purvi gave her baby to Ovi for her happiness and because she was scared that Ovi could turn into a basket case if she learns about her child's death ...

Also Purvi giving up Arjun was also shown as Purvi trying to make thinsg work out for Ovi ...it was mentioned many many times ...

Same way the writers made Manav say to Arjun that he was wrong many years ago when he fought with the chawl people ...( I am not saying that he was right or he was wrong I am just saying that the writers are confused and they are just not showing what they want to show , it is just not coming across right ) ..

The writers have goofed up many many times i nthis show but this baby donation track is their worst ever mistake ..It is simply unforgivable ..I for one cannot repsect any woman who gave up her child ...or respect a doctor who helped her to swap babies quietly in the hospital..Onir should lose his liscense ..

If a patient is very sick and in pain and the doctor takes off his life support ( even if as an act of kindness ) he will go in prison for life because what he did was wrong and unethical .

Edited by Tanyaz - 12 years ago

Quote

soapwatcher1

@soapwatcher1

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: Tanyaz
I am just horrified with the writers of this show .What are they trying to say that a woman can only be a heroine if she sacrifices and keeps killing her own desires ...
what rubbish yaar ...

First Vandita , marries the guy who tries to rape her ...

then Archana , gives up her daughters to her husband and promises to stay away ( only one year old daughters ) to prove her love for Manav ..

And now Purvi , gives up her baby for Ovi's happiness ( this is what is told to us ) ...

what kind of examples are these women ...🤢

Tanya, on the rab se sona ishq forum, there was a thread asking the writers of the show to stop portraying women in such a weak and demented fashion.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Tanyaz

@Tanyaz

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: soapwatcher1
[

Tanya, on the rab se sona ishq forum, there was a thread asking the writers of the show to stop portraying women in such a weak and demented fashion.

the writers of this show have always done that .Archana's main USP is that she sacrifices ...I still watched the show ...got angry many times , felt like giving it up , still watched it ...but when she was about to give up Soham then I also gave up the show ...

Luckily the writers had a change of heart last minute and did not go ahead with Archana giving up Soham for legal adoption...At that time TRPs were so low but still the writers did not learn their lesson and they have repeated that same nasty story again...this time Purvi actually going ahead with it ...and now they are trying to show Purvi as this wonderful person who gave up her daughter for her sister ...

Absolute bakwaas this is ..

there is a new show in Sony now at the same time slot and I read it's review ..Apparantly it is showing the heroine to be strong and not so bechari ...If this is the case then I hope that people will start watching that show instead of Pavitra Rishta ...

Maybe then the writer will learn that showing the woman as the ' bechari ' is out of fashion and doesn't sell anymore ...

Quote

Md. Ashfaqur rahman

@ashfaque2012

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: Tanyaz
the writers of this show have always done that .Archana's main USP is that she sacrifices ...I still watched the show ...got angry many times , felt like giving it up , still watched it ...but when she was about to give up Soham then I also gave up the show ...

Luckily the writers had a change of heart last minute and did not go ahead with Archana giving up Soham for legal adoption...At that time TRPs were so low but still the writers did not learn their lesson and they have repeated that same nasty story again...this time Purvi actually going ahead with it ...and now they are trying to show Purvi as this wonderful person who gave up her daughter for her sister ...

Absolute bakwaas this is ..

there is a new show in Sony now at the same time slot and I read it's review ..Apparantly it is showing the heroine to be strong and not so bechari ...If this is the case then I hope that people will start watching that show instead of Pavitra Rishta ...

Maybe then the writer will learn that showing the woman as the ' bechari ' is out of fashion and doesn't sell anymore ...

Completely Agree with U.

Quote

Romana17

@Romana17

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

#25

its going to be like the old times where purvi is working in arjun's office and then once again they will fall in love with each other

Quote

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#26

Tanya it is not i or some who see it that way it is the way facts r presented

A woman pulling her husband in court and trying to ruin him will be seen that way only in society

A woman cold bloodedly giving up her child within minutes of it being born will be looked at this way only

Sure fans of the actor or actress will defend her loyally but in their heart they know she or he has done wrong

Even CVs know it , they laugh all the way as they write these twists and turns ...they bank on the fandom and the initial hook bas

bache seperation ka track daal dete hai , do bhai pyaar karte hai ek hi ladki se ka track daal dete hai ...bache adlabadli ka track daal dete hai ...they know very well that heroines r doing damn wrong so they put sensible dialogues in the mouths of villains and present arguments ...sometimes they use villains to make or break couples

it is not poor script writing it is cocky script writing banking on chemistry of the couple and fandom bas

in Sasural Simar Ka the heroine traded her baby with criminals for a life for the parivaar which btw she made bhikaari by tricking into signing away property

even fans know that this is wrong but its loyalty to their idol bas

This serial has crossed limits in moral boundaries ...what they r calculating on is the good looks of the actors and the so called initial chemistry bas

trust me they laugh at their own stories have u seen the SBB segments😆😆

SW , thats exactly the thing ...i don't believe she was one of a couple in love who conceived in love ...she is quite quite incapable of that emotion ...it was only foolish Arjun who truly loved her . As far as bhiksha is concerned , yup it can be comprehended this way too . And if Ovi has got bhiksha from Purvi ...first rule of bhiksha is , never ever ask it back , so no question of her demanding child after changing her mind .

Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 12 years ago

Quote

missbeezee

@missbeezee

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#27

Hi juz wanted to mention tht purvi is not a saint but neither is ovi. Yes ovi is a loving mum to pari but it was TOTALLY wrong of her to leave pari on the bed alone. Its normal for anyone even myself to go hysterical to see a baby alone on the bed. Yes infants do fall off the bed. My 3 month baby has fallen off n believe m i was not far frm him. It happened in a split second. So it was totally correct of purvi to carry the baby up. Even my mom would hav shred me to pieces...nyway my boy is fine now but the unbearable torture i went thru was enough to never leave him alone. Just wanted to share my experience ... 😊

Quote

soapwatcher1

@soapwatcher1

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#28

Kools, going solely by the portrayal of Purvi as I understand from your posts, she is not righteous at all so she is not bound by the dharmic definition of bhiksha, she can give and take as she pleases. 😉 She may as well be hanged for a sheep as a lamb, just saying 😃

Quote

Tanyaz

@Tanyaz

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#29

Kool, I still think that it is a matter of interpretation ..

Sometimes the writers are not able to show some story lines very correctly .They try to make everyone look good and in that way they mess up the track ...

You know how much I hate what Purvi has done ( give up Pari ) bu tthe writers have again and again said ( from Onir ) that she did this so that Ovi would get happiness...

same way Manav has said twice i nthe show that Archana did the right thing by standing up for the chawl people .Once he told this to savita and years later to Arjun ...anyways ...my thinking is different from the Cvs ..Of course I am Archana's fan but I try to think about the show as well...and I felt that many times the plots are written verey weak ..

when Archana was about to give up Soham then I abused her i njust about every post ...being a fan does not mean that one becomes blind ...I don't think most of the fans are that blind and of course most of us are someone 's fan and that is why we watch the show ...

Now when you say Sharavni did the right thing by never looking back ...for me that was the worst thing she has ever done ..As I said , it is just a matter of interpretation. For me Archana did wrong by letting go of her daughters when they were one and these Cvs were trying to say again and again that she did this to please Manav ...I don't buy that at all...

If this is love , then love can go to hell...

Also Archana would not fight back injustice from savita and told Manav not to answer back his mother ... according to the writer she id this out of love for Manav but I just cannot see it this way ...I think it is just poor writing ...

I do understand what you are trying to say ...

I guess it is no point thinking so much about this show anymore ..I honestly think it will not last for long now ...But it is always fun to interact with your friends about it ...

Edited by Tanyaz - 12 years ago

Quote

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#30

You mean to say SW that she gives bhiksha and demands it back as she pleases just as she treats those who she 'loves' horribly

😆😆😆

well thats a new low , and i actually agree with u 😆 yup Purvi can do that

Tanya i am not saying whether what Shravani did was right or wrong

i am saying about truly giving up

That fact alone .

Mothers who give up their babies for adoption do exactly this , they walk away for the baby's ultimate good and never look back .But just as they r showing Arjun eyeing Purvi when she is dancing with her husband or ARVI eyelocking with each other during poojas they are perfectly capable of showing giving child up , then making mamta issues and asking it back ...yup ...very possible . The TRPs increase with the shock value , however disgusting it is .

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Finally Purvi! - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics