Archana Discussion post! - why was it closed down?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Pranjjal

@Pranjjal

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: pallai
Yep. Lead characters doesn't mean that what they will do is idealised by others.
If we criticize manav ( when he left archana alone) then why not archana.

Quote

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

My friend Tanya always requested me to return to this forum coz she said she missed interacting with me . We had diametrically opposite viewpoints but we enjoyed the back and forth discussions . We called it the EAST WEST discussions .

Today Even the Archu fans were agreeing with us . Then WHY was that topic closed ?

What in the world does it mean that the topic had potential to get out of hand ?

This is undemocratic in totality . I object to this strongly .

I notice that only Archana praise topics are not closed down .

People should start reporting them . They should cite reason as This praise for a character who does wrong clearly has POTENTIAL to start an argument .

If someone is MISUSING report Button it is imperative that a stop is put to it .

This is sheer spite .

We never had problems earlier , I have argued back and forth with so manY Archu and Manav fans although I am not in both categories . They were healthy debates that made this forum lively .

This will turn this forum into a dead forum . Praise Archana .Any contrary opinion will be reported .

Let her encourage bigamy , marital rapes , trivialize death of babies . Simply Praise her .

What are we doing here then . So Sorry Tanya Darling...your requests touched me and I had kind of reconsidered coming back now and then but its precisely this kind of politics that made me leave . It leaves us with a bad taste in our mouth .

Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

goblue

@goblue

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Hey Pallai,

You had made a fabulous post, the observations were teekha but so correct. I can understand closing a post if a member bashing is happening, but cannot understand closing a topic for saying the candid opinions on the behaviour of the character. The CVs write the characater, how else they will take notice when what they dish out is not what viewers can digest.

Please reopen the topic mods. We want to have our voice heard.

Take care.. Anjali

Quote

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

Our voice is being stifled . We want to be heard . This is a lop sided forum . Only praise of Leads is just one side of the coin . There are many like us who are not fans of leads but have been interested in the STORY . Our perspectives need to be heard too . Just relegating us to ONE episode discussion thread is not enough .When topics like these are made ...the way pallai did today , we want to participate and voice our opinions ! Please re open the thread mods , it is a request !

Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 14 years ago

Quote

112642

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

hey, came back from work and wanted to reply to pillai's post only to find it closed. why is it that any anti-lead posts, some healthy discussion is STIFLED?? why is that any opposing thought is killed? is it a PR forum, where all views are to be heard or is it a lead praising forum...

and if any fans feel that their favs are meant to be PRAISED only, then it is my humble request to create an appreciation thread and continue there...

It is very demeaning to CLOSE down topics because you dont agree with the post or the thread creator. how is it fair to the select members who want to voice their opinions only to find out that its closed down.. its UNFAIR

to the mods:

i am VERY disappointed.. there is name-calling, swear words.. but again, some words used to express opinions shouldnt be suppressed. did you go through the POSTs before closing it down abruptly? couldnt members be asked to EDIT or just post a simple warning. if this so called bashing is against IF then isnt FAIRNESS and EQAULITY another?? by doing this, ARENT you SUPPORTING those few who BELIEVE leads are untouchable... what about US, ME who wants to discuss a show.. i dont care for archana/ankita when i talk of the SHOW as a whole..

I am really disappointed in this whole stifling of voices. it happens EVERY TIME. EVERY SINGLE TIME, posts encouraging discussions are closed down to favor those who are "reporting" these topics.. cant the scales be TIPPED in our favor as well???

phew...

coming to the show:

i find archana intolerably stupid. she is one who has NO sharam and self respect. she WILLINgLY goes to the house where her child's murderer lives.. she askes the woman who HELPED her in her hour of need to LIE for her sister. this sister who HAS attitude andn tantrum issues.. even that aside she is making a mountain out of a molehill by giving in to her sisters whims of DIVORCE to make this child legal. how BLOODY stupid... she is as they say: A BIMBO.. she has no self respect and needs manav only for "pee loon" romance.. the fact that he LEFT as he hated the Ks doesnt strike her.. her husband's pain doesnt matter. what matters is her MAIKA and her NEED to meddle.

Quote

bhallarox

@bhallarox

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Hi Kool Di, you and Tanya Di are both very sweet people, and having opposite views is perfectly great, I agree with both of you though. Kool Di, our voices should be heard too, we are glad you are back with us over here, we missed talking to you, I always loved your opinions😊

Edited by bhallarox - 14 years ago

Quote

bhallarox

@bhallarox

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

I agree, Archana was selfish today, her behavior todward Madhuri was not right, she only cares for her sister.😡

As I mentioned before, Archana should not be at the house where Manjusha was, if something happened to my baby because of someone, I would not want to visit them ever, and if it was family then I would probably stay away from them for some time but Manjusha has committed so many mistakes and is not regretting AT ALL, and yet Archana went to that house very willingly. I loved Manav for ignoring Vinod, who would not be, I want to see Manav telling Archana to cut relations with her maternal home (except for Sulo and Mano) and Archana obeying him, these Ks have crossed the limit. What childish, immature behavior of Vaishali today.

Quote

Tanyaz

@Tanyaz

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

I hope a peaceful solution comes out here ..I want both the members and the mods happy ...

I don't like confrontations ...just like everyone to have a good time in the forum , that is the main reason most of us come here ...at least that is why I come here ...

I want to see everyone enjoy , all the members ( with or against the leads ) and also the moderators because they do so much to keep the forum in good shape ...

Diplomatic answer , I know but this is truly what I feel ...

This is why hopefully eevrything sorts out nicely ...

Edited by Tanyaz - 14 years ago

Quote

bhallarox

@bhallarox

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: Tanyaz
I hope a peaceful solution comes out here ..I want both the members and the mods happy ...
I don't like confrontations ...just like everyone to have a good time in the forum , that is the main reason most of us come here ...at least that is why I come here ...

I want to see everyone enjoy , all the members ( with or against the leads ) and also the moderators because they do so much to keep the forum in good shape ...

Diplomatic answer , I know but this is truly what I feel ...

This is why hopefully eevrything sorts out nicely ...

Exactly Tanya Di, agree with every single word you said, but I really liked the bold part in what you said, to tell you the truth, I am not a big fan of debating, and I come here to have fun and interact with the members, and you are very right, let's maintain peace on our forum😊

Quote

pallai

@pallai

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: bhallarox

Exactly Tanya Di, agree with every single word you said, but I really liked the bold part in what you said, to tell you the truth, I am not a big fan of debating, and I come here to have fun and interact with the members, and you are very right, let's maintain peace on our forum😊

Tanya and Bhalla ,

I understand what your point is.. but this is another thing i want to mention.. anytime we question the mod , it is taken as disturbing peace of the forum. i am not pin pointing u and ur current post..

but i am talking from my past experience...

what we are trying to achieve here is not to disturb forum's peace . why would we want to do that?

most of us like me have been here since PR started and longer... tanya u might not be knowing but u were one of the first person with whom i have interacted with on PR forum. I respect u and ur posts. although we are hve different views i have always taken care never to hurt the sentiments any member.

we are just having a discussion with the MODS as to why no warnings or chance is given to certain posts and why they are immediately closed down without even mentioning it to the thread opener? i think twice before posting something on PR and even restrained doing so in past month or so...

Also why there even has to be a segregation? i see the story and my views and opinions keep changing as the story develops.. i dnt bash any character always or in support of another...

i have criticized savita aai for her earlier abuse of archu but after seeing how much she has paid for it and how her son left her when she needed him ther most my view have changed..

i have constantly written post about archana behaviour which i find immature and i see no growth in her character since the time the serial has started... why am i being labeled a archana basher for this?

when we are demand manav's chracter to be changed or made stronger ...why not for archana cos many of us dnot find her flawless... and we cannt deny that Cvs dnt read these topics.. they do.. otherwise sushant wld not be still in PR.

we should always encourage all sorts of posts which am sure u too agree and have always wanted too. and no we are not trying to break peace of the forum... not at all..we love PR forum as much as any1 else.. otherwise we wouldnt be sticking arnd for more than 2 years...

Edited by pallai - 14 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Archana Discussion post! - why was it closed down? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics