Kool's Commentary : Sep 16 PR - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

135

Views

8.4k

Users

32

Likes

500

Frequent Posters

tarantulla_p thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

I hope this serial flops. Why show social issues if you cannot handle them well??? These CV's made a mockery of every social issue- dowry, DIL harassment, domestic abuse, marital rape, premarital sex, and now this labour issue.

Do they really think audience are so foolish???? Do they think we will be impressed if just the name of the social issue is mentioned??? Do they think we don't read newpapers and don't have any thinking??? Rather than seeing such nonsense, we better see those kitchen politics shows or mushy mills and boons stories. At least they don't make fun of social issues.

I hope some social organisation SLAMS Ekta's company.



So true, Why bring up social issues if you cant really show them correctly? I think they have a checklist of things that they want to run through to say yep we addressed that - without really addressing anything. My biggest problem is their assumption of audience('s lack of) intelligence...I know the Indian audience like a lot of escapist cinema but this is downright crazy, this is neither escapist, not cinema (too freaking long) and haardly entertaining.
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

I hope this serial flops. Why show social issues if you cannot handle them well??? These CV's made a mockery of every social issue- dowry, DIL harassment, domestic abuse, marital rape, premarital sex, and now this labour issue.

Do they really think audience are so foolish???? Do they think we will be impressed if just the name of the social issue is mentioned??? Do they think we don't read newpapers and don't have any thinking??? Rather than seeing such nonsense, we better see those kitchen politics shows or mushy mills and boons stories. At least they don't make fun of social issues.

I hope some social organisation SLAMS Ekta's company.

Yes they DO think audience is foolish , Ekta said so in KJs interview by sugarcoating the bitter pill . We dont do these serials for the elite , she said ....meaning middleclass audience are DUFFERS .
SaffyFlower thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

I hope this serial flops. Why show social issues if you cannot handle them well??? These CV's made a mockery of every social issue- dowry, DIL harassment, domestic abuse, marital rape, premarital sex, and now this labour issue.

Do they really think audience are so foolish???? Do they think we will be impressed if just the name of the social issue is mentioned??? Do they think we don't read newpapers and don't have any thinking??? Rather than seeing such nonsense, we better see those kitchen politics shows or mushy mills and boons stories. At least they don't make fun of social issues.

I hope some social organisation SLAMS Ekta's company.

Perfecto Niki
I side with GM totally on her take on the way the labor thing is shown - wat the hell is that trak for @all? It was sooo shoddily done,& I dint even watch it to feel this way😕- wat archu is hero & heroine now for savin her man's butt AGAIN😆😆 So much for givin the protaganist importance after doin satyanaash of her character like some deewani who escaped from jilted lovers jhopadpatti to land in MCP manav's jhopadpatti😆😆
Edited by SaffyFlower - 15 years ago
Anurulz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#24
i dnt understand what the creatives(?) think when they write the script of the show??first of all archu who wasnt even a matriculate ends up as a supervisor wid sum one-yr course..pray which course is this??am sitting at home wid a fricking drop after finishing MBBS...
next she has the audacity to take decisions and THN informing merely to the owner of the company..and the actual partner satish stands like a prop...yes,i want archu to take decisions bt her own life's..not of dharmu's company which she has now decided to turn bankrupt..
next,i dnt understand y and how manav-archu "rishta" which technically is non-existant,is pavitra..the two of thm are getting married to other people now for crying out loud...what frndship is this??one wid eyelocks and mental flirting??and if their spouses dnt like it (only thing normal in this show) thn they are evil..kamaal hai..the two of thm in every single episode end up embarassing the hell out of jay and family..how is tht pavitra??lets see how either of thm wud like if sum past flame walks in now and the same scenario tht is happening wid shravani and jay happens to them..
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#25
.
The Retrenching Issue was Solved MOST nonsensically by Archu in PR .It was Unprofessional , STUPID and UNBELIEVABLE to the HILT .
I think it would have looked much better had Archana come up with some number crunching and showed it in black an white that giving up on this labour force at this point would prove to be wrong for the comapny as they can lose orders .If orders do not meet dead line then the comapny loses Goodwill and that is a major asset for any company .Good will is an important asset and though Archana did not prove it by numbers , her mentioning of completing the orders on time was to me a big enough reason for the workers to be retained .....
Hence I support her on this ...
This time not because I am a fan because I do believe that she did the right thing ..Later on Dharmesh and satish shoudl sit with their accountant and make a feasability report as to what option is better for the comapany ..
I am sure they can do this in a better way ......
However , I do not know the real reason why she did it ...that is debatable ..Still...for now this problem seems solved ....
.
Dharmu came out like a Deflated air balloon . OK OK We THOUGHT ABOUT UR NOTICE < NO WORKER WILL BE RETRENCHED . And he went away with a DISPLEASED FACE .
My comments : What BS is being shown RAAM JAANE guys ! I have sTOPPED wondering about the grade of the highschoolers writing this SKIT called PR . There r so many questions here like ......
This issue was handled in a very tacky manner ...almost childish ...
Why the hell shud management cave in before BLATANT THREATS
At that point it would have looked more real if Dhamresh had said that ' My lawyers will deal with you ' .
But as I said , this is a very tacky show these days ....
The issue of The RETRENCHMENT NEED has TO DATE Not been solved but kept Hanging on a shelf by Archu .Ok this order will be completed but what about the machine that really doesnt require ten labourers ! Is Archu gonna pay them by selling her family assets every month ? Why the HELL shud Dharmu run his business this way ?
Satish and Dharmesh shoudl sit with their financial controller and make out two feasability reports ..Their's is a manufacturing company and there are reports made to compare two different scenarios in such companies ..All pros and cons are weighed , including the Goodwill of the comapny which even goes down in the balance sheet as a major Fixed asset ...
They don't just make orders liek this ...
One day one partner says ' I am throwing thse workers out , the other partner says No ...still it goes ahead ..Then human rights people come and threaten ....
Saali comes and reminds him of some pending orders and Dharmesh immediately say' Oh dear why didn't I think of this ' .....
Oh come on .. Manufacturing companies don't work like this .....😆😆😆😆
Jaywant ROCKED . He bluntly told Archu , U became a big messiah in front of labourers but what about the NUKSAAN of the company that has incurred due to this decision ? In the long run , u put company in LOSS . I dont believe in doing NAMAK HARAAMI to the Management , I think from THEIR VIEWPOINT . Our THINKING IS ON PARALLEL LINES . Not ur Fault .
I would have respected him more if he had asked her first ' On what basis has this decision been made . ' If after hearing what she had to say he still had felt that she was hurting the company , then by all means he should have said what he said .....
Jay gave KHUNNAS TO MANAAV .
I loved that part the most today ......
For Manav's sake Archu went and stood near Jay . { She doesnt want Manav to be in trouble }
whatever the reason I am glad she went and stood by Jay ...
Manav stared Lovingly .{ He always stares lovingly when THINGS GO HIS WAY }
I agree .He likes her best when she obeys orders ...
Sometimes I think that in his mind she is his little pet who just follows master's orders ....
She sided with workers only by thinking of Manav and Ajits benefit and she has indeed done namak haraami with Dharmesh .
If the orders she was talking about were worthy and the company is making more money and better reputation by retaining these workers in the current situation ... then she is not doing namak haraami ......
Archu ignored Manav when she caught Jay looking at them from a distance . { Clear cut it was shown . She wud have talked if Jay hadnt been there .} Then inspite of that clear cut message that JAY doesnt like this liason . Manav purposefully went on his own [ not even sending Savita mind u ] to Karanjkar home to invite them for HIS WEDDING
I hope Jaywant keeps this strict behaviour with her .It is very good for her and very good for them ....
I just do not understand why manav had to go to give this invitation ..It just is not getting to me ...What kind of a game is this guy playing What does he gets by hurting Archana ????
Why >Asked Damo , practical and sane as ever .Why the hell r u making her give one BS EXAM after the other ?
Coz i need HOUSLA lied Manav . Only She can give it to me .
What BS......
Ya Ya go and call her HA said Bogus Savita sweetly .{ USKE BAAP KA KYA JAATA HAI SO LONG AS MANAV IS GIVING HER EXACTLY WHAT SHE WANTED }
Hated her today .Her eyes are firmly fixed on one goal only ...sachin's kid ...that's it .
manav knows that and is going along with what momma wants ....what makes him look good ....
He then went away after giving his stupid invitation and spoiling yet one more moment in Archus life .
Is he Archana's lover or is he a hater in disguise of a lover ....
My comment : Manav shud be slapped .
Yes ...two hard ones on the left and two hard ones on the right ....
How dare he ...
When will he stop trying to hurt this girl .I have never seen anyone as selfish as him ever ....
Damodar still talks to Bappa . Poor thing . He needs medication .
He should be the one slapping his son ....
Nice commentry Kool....Thanks a lot ......
Edited by Tanyaz - 15 years ago
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#26
One thing for sure ..
This time Archana Karanjkar is dealing with a real man ...not some sissy who goes running to his momma and does everything , right or wrong , to keep mummy happy ....
Manav is now a puppet in the hands of savita and Shravani ..
Jaywant is a totally different ball game ...
Archana better stop playing her stupid games .... he won't put up with them ...
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Tanyaz

One thing for sure ..

This time Archana Karanjkar is dealing with a real man ...not some sissy who goes running to his momma and does everything , right or wrong , to keep mummy happy ....
Manav is now a puppet in the hands of savita and Shravani ..
Jaywant is a totally different ball game ...
Archana better stop playing her stupid games .... he won't put up with them ...

I am VERY VERY glad Archu got Jay . She needs a real man . She needs someone to hold the ponytail on her air head and hold it FIRMLY . Im so pissed with her Manav devotion .
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: anu rulz

i dnt understand what the creatives(?) think when they write the script of the show??first of all archu who wasnt even a matriculate ends up as a supervisor wid sum one-yr course..pray which course is this??am sitting at home wid a fricking drop after finishing MBBS...

next she has the audacity to take decisions and THN informing merely to the owner of the company..and the actual partner satish stands like a prop...yes,i want archu to take decisions bt her own life's..not of dharmu's company which she has now decided to turn bankrupt..
next,i dnt understand y and how manav-archu "rishta" which technically is non-existant,is pavitra..the two of thm are getting married to other people now for crying out loud...what frndship is this??one wid eyelocks and mental flirting??and if their spouses dnt like it (only thing normal in this show) thn they are evil..kamaal hai..the two of thm in every single episode end up embarassing the hell out of jay and family..how is tht pavitra??lets see how either of thm wud like if sum past flame walks in now and the same scenario tht is happening wid shravani and jay happens to them..

Agreed with EVERY WORD in this post😊
448368 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#29
Archana nd Jaywant looks out of sync on lot of issues personal / professional ..... not sure its a good match .... tough times ahead if the marriage goes thru
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#30
Waiting for sherma's posts . Karen nowdays doesnt say much ........😔

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".