Dilemma-Manav Deshmukh

smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1

To thee, I have come with a quarrel, My Lord… Even as a mere mortal that I am, with You-Almighty, I have a quarrel. And yet, only to You, I can turn for any succor or grace. He... Ganesh, judge my quarrel and prayers.

Was it not You, The Bountiful, who had granted me the most beautiful person-internally as well,-as my companion of the life, even when I was filling inadequate to such blessings? For she was the person, I idolized from the moment, I first became awakened to her; For she was the person whose very presence was making me oblivious to the rest of the surrounding- so much so- that even a glimpse of her shimmering green Pallu, swishing over the balustrade of a railway foot bridge, would pull me out of an accelerating rail-car. For she was the person, I have never imagined in my dream, to be approachable, and yet You had fused my life with hers! Why was that largesse? - Only to be withdrawn later? Only to be parted in such cruel a way? And pray what play Thou hast in store for our days? Forsaken?

Tarun's stern rebukes-"To hell with your commitments, if they subtract your life,"-so rightly-ever spurring me to face the hell, if that is the payment I were to pay for a breach on my commitment. Yes, I would prefer a hell in the after life if I were to stay united with Archana in this life. Yes, all I want is to LIVE a life and not forced to grow larger then that life.

But then again, how do I attain a heaven if its road is through the snuffing of Sachin's last memory-a dear brother whose untimely departure can not be entirely exonerated from the shadow of my own unfortunate trials? How do I betray the trust of Aai whose favourite child had been violated under that shadow? No, renege is not an option left to me.

But then I am shuddering at the sight of Her resolve-her resolve to stay committed to my worthless memories; her resolve to stay unmoved in life, when, so valiantly, she is contributing her own sacrifice in fulfillment of a commitment, which was never her own nor made with her consent. My last drop of courage is failing me to convince her otherwise, to move on in the life. Why have you made me a bane of her life? Why am I destined to bear such a heavy cross of cowardice when in reference to her?

And how was that Commitment made? What other fines is it going to draw out of me? Since when had I encouraged/ provoked those stifling effusions of a woman from Shravni? Was it not a compromise call extended to only a helpless mother and never to a woman who was so recently attached to Sachin?

Extract me out of this turmoil- tumult of a dilemma that I am not equal to solve. Bappa, show me the way. And if You have ordained this trial irrevocably-these burning of all my desires - a ruin on divorce, then grant me one last prayer… In years to come, prop me up till I can discharge the brought up of Sachin's child and then after, grant me the quickest end of my ghost walk through the joyless years of my barren life.

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

5.8k

Users

8

Likes

79

Frequent Posters

nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Excellent.. excellent.. superb!!!!

The last line was especially wonderful.. loved it!!!!
carpe-diem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Samarth beautifully written and very well expressed what Manav must be feeling 👏
smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

@ Nikita @ Carpe-diem

I would dedicate this to you both! I remeber your encoragements in other post...😊
On serious note...the intrigue is rolling on...how sensitively creatives would go about it.
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Aww.. thanx Samarth. We love reading your unique perspectives. At this time when the story has become hogwash, I am frankly interested only in the literary and fun aspects of this forum. There are many good writers here.

It is better not to depend on the creatives now Samarth. They have made a mess of the story. We must rely on our own understanding of the character, that is it. I have serious doubts that they will handle Manav so sensitively- their only interest these days seems to be to portray Archana as mahaan. Owing to this, they have butchered Manav badly.

These creatives are useless.
carpe-diem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Samarth thank you😊
As for the creatives, i agree with Nikki, i don't think they care as much about the characters. its all about making money😒
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: carpe-diem

Samarth thank you😊
As for the creatives, i agree with Nikki, i don't think they care as much about the characters. its all about making money😒



No carpe, they care about characters, but only female characters.

There is a very simple logic in Ekta's shows- to make heroine mahaan, she will sacrifice the hero. The hero's characters are ironically always better written (in the beginning) and appeal to the audience. Example: Mihir Virani, Sujal garewal, Angad, Manav deshmukh.

But later when the male character becomes more popular, she nips it. So we see Archu undergoing abuse and Manav too weak to stop it. This makes Archu mahaan for her tolerance.

I call it reverse chauvinism.
smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Nikita, would you grant that Manav is not buddhu😊…just little unpolished, obstinate, confused and caught in a net of circumstances.😔

carpe-diem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
I agree Nikki, they are trying to attract female viewership, and many can relate to them as well. But their care is for the purpose of making money and not the story.😔
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
It would have been better if they had shown Manav as buddhu rather than a bigamist. Now everyone calls him a chauvinist. And that hurts all his fans.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".