Shravani has not YET turned negative - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

82

Views

6.5k

Users

17

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#21
Devashree
I really dont see what is so criminal or wrong about honestly attempting to move on in life . Moving on doesnt mean being unemotional or ruthless , neither does it imply that the person never was in love at all .
When this same Shravani was sitting with Sachin's photo , like a stone , with eyes that were perpetually wet due to tears , everyone told her to move on , that moving on is only life .
Damodar told her ......Girish told her , Savita told her and most of all , Manav told her repeatedly .
We see a young girl who knew Sachin for barely few months , and like many normal girls , she allowed him to make love to her ............it happens all the time . Unfortunately that guy died and she found she was pregnant .
Not wanting to abort the baby was a very humane decision that she made inspite of the pressures of a traditional society . For the sake of that society Shravni did not decide to kill a foetus and I applaud her for it coz i see humanity there and also guts . I mean seriously , why shud a baby die so righteous minded society shud be happy ? I dont see the connection or logic.
She asked manav to consider Archana many times , and each time Manav assured her Archna was his bad past .
When she heard Manav admitting to tarun about his love for archu , Shravni's pregnancy had already advanced and many decisions had already been taken . They had not consummated , there was no child in that marraige , the divorce was going on , and Archhna was honestly not welcome in that family by anyone , except Damodar , whom everyone overrode . So many such 'loves' are forgotten after marraige . Was it so abnormal of her not to give it too much thought and instead focus on her own relationship with him? I think NOT . Thats the way any normal girl wud behave . She wud look after her interests . It is not necessarily called being selfish , it is being practical .
The marraige was going to be a compromise , said the great Manav . So Shravni , who had a baby in her tummy and the babys future as her goal dried her tears , adjusted with sachins dysfunctional family , put sachins memory on hold as nothing was gonna yield by constantly crying over him , and decided to give this compromise her hundred percent . She started trying to give her relationship with Manav her hundred percent as a woman as a dead relationship with no emotion , no interest , sleeping with backs to each other , smiling forcefully and perhaps having forced sex by popping viagra pills [ as the great Manav had visualised] wud be very unhealthy not just for the baby but an entire future to come . She seems to be the only one who seems to have visualised what this compromise wud be and so very rightly she decided to make this compromise better from her end at least . Is that so wrong or normal ? For starters , she started dwelling on Manav's unselfish acts and tried reading goodness in them so she cud like him . In short she started working on their relationship .
Manav the great meanwhile doesnt seem to have really given a thought about what was going to be expected of Shravni as a woman by simply referring to the marraige as 'COMPROMISE" everytime . It seems it was perfectly ok for him to sleep with his back to her , tell her with dead pan expressions that whatever u wish will happen , ignore her extreme youth and emotional or physical needs that wud change with time , simply give the baby a middle name to display and pack him off to school , walk off to the garage while his greedy mother fleeced even this second wife of all her money . For Manav doesnt even seem to have the maturity to know that even in a compromise , one has to walk half way through . Which shravni , albeit young , understood , and tried to do .
For that maturity she is being branded as a weirdo who doesnt love Sachin , forgot Sachin sooooo soon , bad , this and that .
Very frankly , its Manav who although 31 , doesnt know the seriousness of his commitment........hence the constant switching of brides in poojas , the thinking of Archu in private , the indifference to shravni , the total dumbness in not imagining or foreseeing what this compromise that he so enthusiastically jumped into and talked about was really going to expect from this girl ........Shravni . Why the hell shud she , so young , live the life of a nun by marrying him because of the word 'compromise ' . Is a compromise Marraige necessarily not succesful?No , it can be very succesful if both walk half way and try their best . Shravni is trying exactly that but Manav ............god knows what this character is exactly doing .
Archna meanwhile is sending mixed signals with such alarming speed that she will cause a bad accident one day . Even her own mom who loves her so much today commented [ and very rightly too] that she shud take vows only she can fulfil , not like thse that create controversy .
Shravni quietly went to collect the money at Savitas behest .She cud easily have argued that today is pooja , the money isnt running away , ill go next week . She even quietly gave up money to Savita . Her jewels , she is least interested in them . She dresses with sobriety , still indicating mourning for Sachin .But yes , this sad compromise that she did in life , to that she is trying to give her hundred percent .Is she so bad ?
Two times she fell for Savitas lies about archu just like each and every person fell upto this point , including Manav and Archu who believed savitas lies during the divorce .
So how come she is so wrong and so bad ? I fail to see her as a shallow human being [ upto this point ] or bad .I felt more sorry for her than archu and Manav even . Coz when she goes , she will truly be broken .
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

Archna meanwhile is sending mixed signals with such alarming speed that she will cause a bad accident one day .

I do not agree with this at all.
Edited by Tanyaz - 15 years ago
448368 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#23
Kool just for fun sake (u do hve gr8 sense of humor) howd u react if Shravni metamorphose into an evil vamp....conspiring wid Savita to create rift betn ArMan...constantly negating nd humiliating Archu....mistreating D family....wld u conveniently xcuse yrself saying Damn CVs....or wld u still defend her....I know it's hypothetical....nd too far fetched....bt still wanna know yr reaction.
addenise thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#24
ginally posted by devashree_h

Akash watch todays episode and also Friday's epi.She does not need to say those words, it shows she is in love with him.
How can anyone after seeing today's episode doubt her love for him?...i refuse to even call him by name...dislike that guy now.
Ya, the US is way behind...only last nite we saw him going to her father to say he will marry her, she agreed, after one "second"..then she went to live with them...Even evil Savita was mortified when she saw her, thinking what the neighbors will say..but nooooo, not mr...he was like, she will stay here....
gaurimisha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#25
I am nt angry on shravani for questioning Manav...its very natural on her part.
But yes I hate her...here's why:
1.Her actions towards Manav dont justify tht she loved sachin so dearly tht she cud bcome pregnant before marriage..I disagree tht its abt her secure future she's worried abt.I find it hard to understand tht a well-educated rich independent and confident girl like shravani(who cudnt wait for consummation till after marriage) is getting insecure abt her future...with due credits to the CRs,I have hardly seen a scene in PR where Shravani bothers abt her child's future or for tht matter her future...all she said"Manav is the most important person in my life now"...one qs...wht abt ur baby dear or sachin?
2.She was the one to suggest to Girish ...actually plead with him tht both she n sachin shud leave for US after marriage instead of stayin in deshmukhs',after the savita-archu fiasco at sachin's engagement.
Now wht?Doesnt she realise tht if she marries Manav she'll hav to stay there forever.After Sachin's death,she agreed to marry Manav..tht decision cud hav been taken on a n impulse...but now she had quite some months to think...abt adv or disadv of her own decision.
Manav and Archana will b always this way...stupid emotional fools but atleast they remain true to themselves tht they love only each other.
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#26
I agree 100 % . I a mnot angry with her for questioninghim but it is very bad the way she is expecting him to start acting like her husband ....
She is not even thinking about the baby , now it is all Manav .
Her anger towards Archana is totally unjustified ...She should be grateful to archana because she has bailed her and Manav out of so many tricky situations ....
Just asking for gurudakshna and then now she expects Archu to forget about her husband ( and she knows that Archana loves him ) in the snap of a finger .
gaurimisha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#27
Shravani is the most inconsistent character on the show ,I feel.
right Tanya,how can she expect tht Archu will forget Manav in the snap of a finger?Does she intend to give Archu lessons on tht...how she so easily forgot sachin
I understand Manav n Archana...I get angry on why they behave foolishly,but slowly I'm learnin to accept tht that is the way they are.
Hadnt it been so,Manav wud hav gone n proposed to Archu before marriage...nope.These two people are made for each other...as was once so aptly explained by Archu.So,I cant ever hate them.
Shravani is supposed to be 5 months pregnant by now,do I ever see her thinking lovingly abt her child for happy memories of sachin?No
All I get to see as a viewer is ,out of nowhere,she has given all importance to Manav n why?Bcoz she thinks he's mahaan n a gr8 human bein as he helped his to-be-ex-wife durin her accident.
That's so ridiculous.
May b somewhr CRs r at fault but as a viewer I wud only hate her
Edited by gaurimisha - 15 years ago
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#28
I disagree with both ........gauri and Tanya.
See this is where we fundamentally differ . I dont 'hate' any character as such , even Manav although I have criticized him so much . My criticisms of Manav are based on the degradation of woman in this serial and him calmly adhering to a chauvinist mentality , not being 'different ' enough to justify the craze his fans have for him ...........which boils down to that his popularity is due to his hot looks rather than a unique diffrent character being played on the small acreen . Many will jump and say nno this isnt so , but I am afraid it is so . All male characters on the Tv screen have this two wife scenario , all rush to take responsibility , all watch abuse silently but get heated up when their own sisters and moms r abused even briefly for some time . Manav Deshmukh is no different . So he fails to impress me , but i dont hate him .
I have already made myself amply clear in my latest post but I will say this again.
It is being held against Shravni that she forgot Sachin so soon . I dont think so . What is being expected of her by forum membwers is she shud constantly weep about Sachin and with puffed up eyes like red russet potatoes , she shud leave Manav and Archu alone to have quiet moments of romance [ by which forum members will get immense viewer satisfaction 😊] and quietly accept like a bhikaari , a beggar , whatever Manav throws her way while sighing for Archu from inside .
Well , I find this demand simply ridiculous and unfair . Everyone who are on this 'understanding ' Manav spree now , seem to forget that Manav wanted this compromise marraige much much more than Shravani . He told her.........his words ..........What archna r u talking about , there is NOthing between me and Archna to even talk about it .
All these loveaffairs one has in young age , r brief , and in a sense one doesnt even really know the man . Did Archna know Manav ?No na ? How much did this Shravni know Sachin? When she knew him she was faithful to him , she wasnt lusting after his elder bro . Now he is dead and gone and the full world advised her to 'MOVE ON" . And when she really tries to move on , she is being branded as a bitch who never really loved Sachin in the first place .
Savita Sachins mother is the true evil who equates her son with money and thanks his photo for giving her 7 lacs . Any shame that woman has ? None whatsoever . Shravni doesnt even dress like Savita . She has lost interest in clothes , jewels , money , she is only trying to focus on this relationship as Akash rightly said coz the baby needs a happy couple , not the compromose that the great Manav visualised . Everything that the great Manav visualises is actually very unrealistic and stupid .
Tanya u disagreed about mixed signals . But telling Varsha , Manav Vaishu that I want this marraige to proceed [ Shravni and manavs] and then in private going boo hoo hoo on his shoulder is indeed a blunt mixed signal . Like I said the man seemed to have more control over his emotions than her .She cud have congratulated him quietly and then sobbed her heart out in private . We dont see that .
agreeing to savitas demand that shravni shud sit for pooja and then wearing her sari coz someone forced her and sitting for pooja without having any bloody personal stand on the matter is again a mixed signal . If I were in Shhravnis place I wud start eyeing archna with disbelief and raised eyebrows . This woman says toh nice nice things and seems also sincere , but her behaviour is ekdum ulta , is she the chuparustom type ? Would be my nagging doubt .
As far as Archna being very nice about the divorce and helping Shravni is concerned ..........I dont deny that but I feel like pointing out that Archna was in no position at that time to do any damned thing , she had lost out as a woman on ALL FRONTS . Her husband was not ready to look at her face , her sasuraal hated her , she had made a classic fool of herself by refusing the divorce and hence was forced to spend 3 months in that hell hole . At this point honestly speaking Shravni was the only one who wasnt hating her as such ,Rest all were , even Manav and even that useless Vandu . The help that archu gave was at moment appreciated but that doesnt mean forever Shravni as a woman will worship archu like devi as she seems to be a normal character . When she gets insecure , she will , as a woman .
Piya : If and when Shravni joins Savita and plots inhumanly to achieve goal , I will be first one to critique her . I criticised sulochna when she welcomed Manju warmly back in the house inspite of Manju being so outright nasty to her daughter . Thats why I named my post Shravni is NOT YET NEGATIVE . These thoughts r only for the current episode . Aage ka Allah jaane ! But currently I feel no anger as a viewer for shravni she comes across as normal . However I feel immense sadness and anger at Manav for not rising upto any uniqque standard and degrading woman , and even Archana for taking such blatant shit and abuse and degrading women in general inspite of being a lead . I dont feel like giving the excuse to both of them saying that they r emotional fools , they r made that way etc etc as then what is happening is creatives r getting succesful in their ploy of making us get used to their chauvinistic portrayal .........we r swallowing it and now gradually even accepting it .
I won't . For me , currently Shravni and Varsha r the only two normal , refreshing characters . They too will be butchered in no time..........Varsha after her marraige and Shravni by making her evil and collaborating with an evil scheme of Savita.
NKSUDHIR thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Akashspartan


No Devu i watch all the repeat telecast too,
She is not in love with Manav, they have a mutual respect she knows that very well.😊
Its a compromise of sorts which has been worked out, so thats nothing wrong on her part!😭
Archu decides too walk away when she wants and walk back in Manav's life when she wants, thats not done!
She very well knows that how much Manav loves Archu, so it would be really foolish for her too think in those lines!
Its every time that she sees Archu being with Manav grows her insecurity towards her future???????

If she is not in love with Manav and she knows that Manav is sacrificing his life for his bro' baby then why cannot she do something to unite Arman. I hate this that only baba can see Archana's love for Manava nd no one else can.
I hope Arman unite soon.
sensodyne thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#30
Kool I agree even I'm angry with Manav for degrading women and supporting a women who is been insulted in front of his eyes but where we see him helping other women in streets which is very bad.
and i don't agree that we girls like Manav because he looks handsome and have cute smile we like him because the way he portrays Manav character(especially initial Manav).
plzz don't compare Varsha to Sharavani my most fav character in PR is Varsha as she is believialbe character and which we can relate u are talking about move on in life Varsha who has been cheated by married man has still not able to move on in life because she truly love him didn't every one advise her to move on in her and forget her past time and she did respect other people view and took quiet a time and then decided to move on in life but where as Sharavani took wrong step in her life with a guy who a road romeo before marriage after his death he has decided to move on in life so early that she is not even remembering him we are expecting her cry every day but we do want her show that she is feeling lonely that love of her life is gonna and build herself in to strong women so that she can face world when her child in born and she is worried that after her marriage people will ask her how come u are 5 months pregnant ??? no she is worried about loosing her fiance that is the part which irritates me most.
one more thing she can't listen when Manav is shouting that he loves Archu and Savita saying that u entry into my house is like Lakshmi coming and can't see a women is being tortured in front of her eyes but she can see her future hubby is loving his wife daha give me a break.
i don't think that any women who has lost her bf/hubby would move in her life like this.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".