Proof of Family - Page 10

Originally posted by: inlieu

Yeah, they are showing HS as someone who was not able to understand his own feelings back then and is now singing a different tune.

I can't buy this... nonsense.

Utter nonsense !

this was raised in another thread. why did HS call mini his daughter in the hospital. there babita was not there to assure her

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. It’s not that we expect HS to be a perfect human being who can’t falter. I don’t expect him to have all the wisdom in the world.

But to show him neglecting Mini to this level simply to prove how besotted he is with Babita and how much he always loved and did everything for her....I don’t buy it either.

And I’m tired of the endless “assurances” Babita is being given at the cost of others.

even when babita asked HS if he really loved mini the assurance she was asking was for her not for mini. Because mini currently needs HS to deal with her they way he does not the way babita wants

Originally posted by: naq5

this was raised in another thread. why did HS call mini his daughter in the hospital. there babita was not there to assure her

LOL itne logical questions na puchho 😛

Writers ne ab bol diya hai ki sirf Babita ke liye Mini ko beti bola tha toh ab yehi maan lo. 🤷‍♀️

This is a new era wala HS who is just obsessed with Babita. Mini kaun? Naukri kya?? He doesn’t care anymore. Bas Babita hi sab Kuch hai 🙄

Originally posted by: naq5

even when babita asked HS if he really loved mini the assurance she was asking was for her not for mini. Because mini currently needs HS to deal with her they way he does not the way babita wants

Exactly. It has always been about her own assurance only. Mini toh kabhi factor hi nahin hui....she was just an instrument to use.

Babita has her set ideas about what fathers do. So HS saying he doesn’t really consider himself Mini’s father and neither does Mini made Babita panic ki phir Ab father waale kaam kaun karega? She expected HS to instantly align with her as an extension of her parenting approach to handle Mini.

HS-Mini ki independent equation ko kisi ne samjha? Aur kitna samjha? I don’t know anymore 🤷‍♀️....thanks to this horribly convoluted mess.

Originally posted by: inlieu

Since when did Minie know he didn't think of her as his daughter, and since when did HS know that she knew?

All those mhaari chhori dialogues seem meaningless now, when in fact when we first heard them they were totally genuine and from the heart.

LOL since the CD incident I guess 🤷‍♀️....that’s how the writers are playing it. Cuz CD incident mein HS explicitly said that he feels Mini never accepted him as a father. And Mini didn’t say anything in response.

Toh I guess HS is taking that as a confirmation that both him and Mini knew this? 🤔😂

Or is he trying to say that even when he declared himself father at the Pooja, Mini also knew it was just for Babita and not for her?

Well in that case, the scene failed in execution...and it still doesn’t explain why they continued to call each other father daughter before and after that 🤷‍♀️

HS ko jhoota and confused prove karna chahte hain writers 🙄😂

Writers need to be move forward rather than circling back over and over to past scenes and conversations and giving them ulterior meanings

Enough already

Clean up yer mess and move the F on

Just give me one episode where everybody is where they are supposed to be

Mini in school

PB at her biz

HS at police station

NB doing her presidential duties

Just one normal siapa free epi

Originally posted by: inlieu

Yesterday's episode highlighted to me more than ever before how much Minnie needs HS now. Her friends are there but they cannot provide the wisdom that HS can.

I agree. Mini’s loneliness was so piercing despite having her friends around her.

When she said, “ main itni bhi brave nahin hoon”, it just broke my heart and I so badly wished for HS to show up somehow and tell her that she will always be his brave girl🤗

Remember that scene during the depression track when only he could get through to Mini? When he told her ki Ab itni bhi brave banne ki zaroorat na hai, and she broke down and hugged him? How I loved that scene. Sigh.

So yes, Mini needs him. And he needs her. But he is too caught up with Babita ke endless dramas 🤷‍♀️....Babita ki aakhein padhne mein busy hai Ab toh Mini ko kaise samjhega🙄

Atleast one question got answered yesterday. Mini did want a father in her life. And she did start to feel HS could be that person before it got all twisted.

Itne delicate relationship ko repair karne ki bajaaye Babita is stomping around like a bull in a china shop 🤦‍♀️....not even an iota of cognizance in this woman of how to manage delicate relationships.

Anyways, I guess they will wrap up the issue today....with a father acceptance ya jo bhi. Aage feather romance and random Poojas bhi toh karni hain.

LOL when the GP scene promo had aired, they had called it HMB ka “happily ever after” 🙄😂

Toh Ab is next “reunion” ko kya label denge? Happily ever after 2? Lol bhai kitne ever after honge? 🤔 Just call it “happy for now” 😆

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL since the CD incident I guess 🤷‍♀️....that’s how the writers are playing it. Cuz CD incident mein HS explicitly said that he feels Mini never accepted him as a father. And Mini didn’t say anything in response.

Toh I guess HS is taking that as a confirmation that both him and Mini knew this? 🤔😂

Or is he trying to say that even when he declared himself father at the Pooja, Mini also knew it was just for Babita and not for her?

Well in that case, the scene failed in execution...and it still doesn’t explain why they continued to call each other father daughter before and after that 🤷‍♀️

HS ko jhoota and confused prove karna chahte hain writers 🙄😂

Whatever CVs show I will never believe HS showered love on MIni to impress Babitha. Yo baat phinal hai. The guy is simply incapable of even thinking that way.