Court case on Hanuman singh - Page 2

may be sartar Singh don't know actual truth of imarti condition and he may be blaming HS for the delay in operation as the Doctor Who have operated her would have told that if u have got her early she would have saved and sartar Singh would have thought HS has done it purposely... As he is unaware of that it was imarti decision... May be this will be explained to sartar Singh...

I wonder HS dint try to explain all this to him since 2012...thats quite awkward... But if babes or Minni or anyone who had put sense in to sartar Singh mind also... What would. Have they done...

Originally posted by: inlieu

Seedhi si baat hai. Beti ki maut ke gham me bawra ho gaya tha uska bapu.

Exactly. I think he lost his ground and sense. And since HS had convinced everyone for the operation, he put it on him. That's exactly why the case was dismissed.

Now that the confusion would be clear, they would get a chance to cry together. And that would be the real closure for Imarti.

I do wanna see Imarti's soul smiling that them when they're crying 🥺

That is why the case didn't pass in lower court. It's simple... A father couldn't take the death of his daughter..

As far a dark secret which was buildup by writers through HS guilt, I have understood one think uptil now... They go for simple routes. I don't think I witness anything which can not happen in real lives in the story. Struggle, love, marriage , upbringing etc are all in light of reality. It is us who are spoilt by other shows k kuch bura, ajeeb nikle ga.. maybe HS father was involved, HS in unintentionally Dhaka dedya and what not... But it turn out to be simple...a brain tumour. The gult which was shown was regarding imarti resistance on going to hospital. K shayad agar na le Kar jata to Bach jati.. hospital decision HS ka tha. I know it's not upto mark of suspense as compared to other shows😂.. but it's PB.. it is real k koi bhi apne ko blame karta..

P.s: I even realized this after a clear thought. 😂

I think that her father is confused as to why he never took her earlier.

Originally posted by: attiya1.3

That is why the case didn't pass in lower court. It's simple... A father couldn't take the death of his daughter..

As far a dark secret which was buildup by writers through HS guilt, I have understood one think uptil now... They go for simple routes. I don't think I witness anything which can not happen in real lives in the story. Struggle, love, marriage , upbringing etc are all in light of reality. It is us who are spoilt by other shows k kuch bura, ajeeb nikle ga.. maybe HS father was involved, HS in unintentionally Dhaka dedya and what not... But it turn out to be simple...a brain tumour. The gult which was shown was regarding imarti resistance on going to hospital. K shayad agar na le Kar jata to Bach jati.. hospital decision HS ka tha. I know it's not upto mark of suspense as compared to other shows😂.. but it's PB.. it is real k koi bhi apne ko blame karta..

P.s: I even realized this after a clear thought. 😂

This show is the 2nd Indian TV serial I am watching after Sarabhai vs Sarabhai. I was expecting some Korean drama like suspence -likes of healer in this treck. And since Imarti had advanced stage tumor she would have died anyways. So logically HS's guilt is way too much to believe. And I have more expectation from this show as the writers did good research on divorce laws, alimony, domestic violence laws etc..

I agree to all your points.. As few of you said, he might be misunderstanding that the delay was becos of HS. But we never know what the CVs have stored for us

Originally posted by: Sakurablossom

This show is the 2nd Indian TV serial I am watching after Sarabhai vs Sarabhai. I was expecting some Korean drama like suspence -likes of healer in this treck. And since Imarti had advanced stage tumor she would have died anyways. So logically HS's guilt is way too much to believe. And I have more expectation from this show as the writers did good research on divorce laws, alimony, domestic violence laws etc..

I had watched many.. you are lucky that you just saw the most logical show before..

Yes she would have died anyway.. but woh Jo ehsas haina k" I could have listen her last time" transcends all logic... I have seen someone really close whose daughter was suffering from some cancer. Yes she died and we all knew she would ultimately because that was some rare cancer but, point is she was scared of injections and when she came to know this, she refused. Her family tried everything because chemo is only way you can extend your life ...she couldn't survived first chemo and still her mother says I could have listen to her...

Baat sahi ya galat ya overboard honay ki nahi..baat surf yeh hai k we couldn't fulfill that last wish..

Originally posted by: Sakurablossom

This might sound as nitpicking, but after today's episode I have a question.

Imarti had a brain tumor - in some advanced stage where operation was necessary. So after all discussion they went on for the operation. If Imarti died due to operation- how exactly is it culpable homicide by Hanuman Singh? (Unless Hanuman Singh operated on her- highly unlikely). If at all- it could be medical negligence- a culpable homicide by doctor but then dangers of operation were explained in advance. So actually there's no tangible reason to file culpable homicide. Hanuman Singh would have understood the law better as he is policeman.

Am I the only one who thinks that the writers kind of goofed up here? It looked like they were going for some dark idea and then suddenly made decision to show something less controversial.

I thought this also.

Unless there’s something more to the story like the FIL fabricating evidence I don’t see how any high court in their right mind would agree to go ahead and charge Hs. There was no crime that was committed as far as I can see and no matter what happened he would have blamed himself. If he didn’t convince her to go for the operation he would have always blamed himself for not forcing the issue and if she did go and something bad happened he would blame himself. She was dying anyways and it was the only way she had of potentially living longer. I can understand hs guilt (he convinced her when she didn’t want to) but what crime has really occurred that he’s being charged by a high court of culpable homicide? Last time I checked it weren’t culpable homicide to convince someone to go for an operation and they die on the operating table?

I’m also really confused about this storyline and have the same questions as u. I don’t think it’s nit picking, because up until now the story has always maintained a sense of realism, in fact from the start this is what ppl praised it for.

This is starting to feel like a zee tv drama when you’ve got to put all your sense and logic aside to watch it.

It feels like something the writers have thought up in haste without thinking it properly through ie, wanting to create some elaborate drama without spoiling Hs innocent character for eg.

Hope it clears up in the next few days

Imarti knew she was going to die

So did Imarti ask HS to help her die? Did she finally convince him for no surgery? Died in his arms in the hospital so that it wouldn't look suspicious?

I hope we get a FB scene where we see what happened that night...however I don't want him to share this private moment...it has to be him alone

Originally posted by: silvermoonlight

Imarti knew she was going to die

So did Imarti ask HS to help her die? Did she finally convince him for no surgery? Died in his arms in the hospital so that it wouldn't look suspicious?

I hope we get a FB scene where we see what happened that night...however I don't want him to share this private moment...it has to be him alone

I wouldn't mind him sharing it with Minnie, though. Wouldn't Naeem Bi and Lala have been there? They had left 8 hours earlier for the hospital so the others could have come later on.